Partway through a session, you ask what your client wants, and they say “I don’t know” again. You rephrase the goal question. They describe the problem again, in the same words. When the goal question stops working, the next useful question may not be about the goal at all. Put one word on the table, such as Enough or Balance, and ask the client what it brings up. This guide covers when to switch, how to set the word up, ten questions that start from it, and how to bring the session back to the goal.
The method works with a word written on a sticky note. The examples use the Thesis card deck, because each card has a word on one side and an everyday thing on the other.
Why the goal question stops working
A stuck client may have answered the same kind of question several times already. “What do you want?” and “What’s stopping you?” both point at the problem the client has been circling. Each new version of the question gets the old answer back, because the client is searching the same place.
The type of question changes what comes back. In a study of 204 university students, each person described a real problem they wanted to solve and then answered either solution-focused or problem-focused questions. The solution-focused group showed larger gains in self-efficacy, goal approach and action steps, and a larger drop in negative affect (Neipp et al. 2016). The study was a replication of an earlier experiment. It tested question types, not words or cards.
A word gives the client a different place to search. It isn’t a question about the problem, so the client doesn’t have to defend or repeat their last answer. They talk about Enough, a photograph, or their grandmother’s kitchen, and the problem can show up again from a side they haven’t described before.
Step 1: Notice the loop and name the switch
Three signs tell you the goal question has run out: the same answer twice, “I don’t know” with a shrug, or a long story that ends where it started. When you see one of them, say what you’re about to do. “Let’s leave the goal for a few minutes and try something different.”
Naming the switch matters for two reasons. The client knows the goal hasn’t been dropped. And the word doesn’t feel like a trick question with a hidden right answer. On the Thesis rule card the line for this is plain: “There are no right answers.”
Step 2: Let the client choose the word
Pick three or four words that sit near the client’s topic and lay them out. A client stuck on a career move might see Work, Enough, Courage and Balance. Ask them to pick the one that pulls at them, or the one they’d rather avoid. Both choices tell you something.
With the deck, the client can also turn a card over. The Thesis rules say: “Draw a card. Choose a side: the idea or the thing.” The everyday side gives a client who feels exposed a lower first step. Talking about a watch can be easier than talking about balance, and it can lead there within a few sentences.
Enough sits on the back of Photograph. For a client who keeps raising their own bar, the word names the question they haven’t asked: when would this count as done? The photograph side works too. A client can describe a photo of a moment when things felt like enough, and you both have a concrete scene to work from.
Step 3: Ask from the word, not from the goal
Once the client has a word, stay with it for a few minutes. The questions below start from the word and leave the client’s goal out of the sentence. Use two or three, not all ten. Replace “the word” with the word on the table.
- What’s the first thing this word makes you think of?
- Where in your life does this word fit right now?
- Where doesn’t it fit at all?
- Who taught you what this word means?
- When did this word last feel true for you?
- What would this word look like on an ordinary Tuesday?
- If this word had a place in your home, where would it be?
- What would change if you had a bit more of it?
- Who in your life would pick this word for you?
- What did you want to say about this word but didn’t?
Questions 4 and 9 bring in other people, which can show the client whose standard they’re working to. Question 6 pulls an abstract word into a day they can picture.
Balance is on the back of Watch. A client who describes a schedule that’s too full can start with the watch: who gave it to them, when they stopped wearing one, what they check it for. From there, balance is one question away, and the client arrives at it with their own examples.
Step 4: Follow up on what they said
The first answer to a word can be short. Useful material may come in the answers after it, and that’s where follow-up questions do the work. The Thesis rule card gives three: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?
Follow-up questions may also change how the client experiences you. In live conversation studies, people who asked more questions, especially follow-up questions, were liked more by their partners, and perceived responsiveness explained the effect (Huang et al. 2017). The participants were strangers in conversation, not coaching clients. For a stuck client, a follow-up on their own words can be a sign they were heard.
Keep the follow-ups short and open. “Gently, without judging” is how the Thesis rules put it. If the client says “that’s all”, accept it. A short answer is a full answer, and you can come back to the word later.
Courage sits on the back of Bicycle. A client who says they lack the courage to act may tell a different story through the bicycle: learning to ride, a fall, someone holding the seat and letting go. That story may hold the evidence the client says they don’t have.
Step 5: Bridge back to the goal
After a few minutes with the word, return to the goal with one bridging question. “You said Enough would be a free Sunday. What does that tell you about the decision?” The client now has new material, in their own words, to answer with.
If the bridge doesn’t land, leave it. Some sessions use the word to open something the client needs to sit with until next time. Write the word and the client’s key phrase in your notes, and start the next session there.
Using the deck in a session
The full Thesis game is for 2–6 players, so it runs one to one. One way to use it is as a short opener: the client draws one card, rolls the die and talks for a few minutes before the goal comes up.
The die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” For a stuck client, the roll picks the side for them, which removes one more decision.
You know your client, your contract and your limits, and you decide whether a card format fits a session. Thesis is a conversation format and makes no clinical claims.
Try it in your next session
Before your next session, write four words on four sticky notes: Enough, Balance, Courage and Work. Keep them in your notebook. The next time a client says “I don’t know” twice, lay them out and ask which one pulls at them.
For more on opening with the everyday side, see low pressure conversation starters. For more on card formats in group work, see Thesis for therapy groups. The three cards above have their own pages: Enough, Balance and Courage. You can play online for free, see the rules and the box, or read the research behind the deck.