You ask the room, “What are the underlying drivers here?” Everyone looks at their notes. One person gives a polished answer that sounds like a slide, and the discussion stops there. The question took effort to write, and it gave the group nothing to hold. Facilitation questions do more when they’re plain: short, open, and about what the group is working on right now. This guide gives 11 of them, sorted by the moment in a session where each one helps, plus three follow-ups that fit after almost any answer.
The questions work in workshops, team sessions, classes and support groups. The last section shows how to practice them with one word on the table, from the Thesis card deck or written on an index card.
What a host’s question is for
A participant asks about the topic. A host asks about the group’s thinking: which question are we answering, do we mean the same thing by this word, whose view is missing. That job suits plain questions, because nobody has to decode them before answering. The question a newcomer could ask may be the one the room skipped.
Plain questions also say something about the room. When the host asks “What do we mean by that?”, it can become normal for anyone to ask it. A clever question shows the host thought hard. A plain one shows the group it can think out loud without getting it right first.
Before the discussion: check the question
A group can start answering before it agrees on what it’s answering. A session booked as “planning” can hold a different plan in each head. Spend the first minutes on the question itself. These three help:
- What question are we trying to answer today?
- When we say this key word, what do we each mean by it?
- What will we leave out of today on purpose?
Write the agreed question where everyone can see it. When the talk drifts, point to it and ask whether the group wants to change it or come back to it.
While ideas come in: open the thinking
Once people start talking, the host’s work is to slow the first answer down and widen the circle. Each of these four questions asks for one more step, and none of them judges what was said:
- What makes you say that?
- What’s an example from your own work or life?
- Who sees this differently?
- What haven’t we talked about yet?
Question 6 works best when it’s asked as an invitation, with a pause after it. If nobody answers, the host can say what a different view might look like and ask whether anyone holds it.
When the group gets stuck
A stuck group can keep circling the same positions. Two questions move it sideways:
- What would the opposite look like?
- What do we know for sure, and what are we guessing?
The first one turns the question around, which can show what the group takes for granted. The second one sorts the table into facts and assumptions, and the assumptions become the next thing to check.
Before the end: name what happened
The last part of a session shapes what people take out of the room. Two questions close the thinking without forcing a conclusion:
- What did we decide, in one sentence?
- What’s still open?
An honest answer to question 11 is a result too. It tells the group where the next session starts.
Three follow-ups that fit after almost any answer
The Thesis rule card lists three questions under the line “Good questions are short and open”: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? Each one picks up the answer that came before it. The first asks about experience, the second about the people in it, the third about change over time.
The study below looked at conversations between two people. In live conversations studied by Huang and colleagues, people who asked more questions, and follow-up questions in particular, were liked more by their partners (Huang et al. 2017). Asking made them seem more responsive. Participants didn’t expect questions to have this effect. In a group the host’s follow-up does a second job: it shows the room what kind of question is welcome.
Keep the follow-up gentle and let it go if the speaker stops. The rule card puts it this way: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”
Why hosts reach for clever questions anyway
Hosts prepare, and a prepared question carries that effort. A plain question can feel too small for the room or for the time people gave up to be there. There’s also the silence after a plain question. “What makes you say that?” leaves a gap, and a host who fills it with a second, longer question loses the answer to the first.
A useful habit is to write the plain version next to each prepared question in your notes. Ask the plain one first. Wait while you count slowly in your head. Use the prepared one only if the group needs a push.
Practice with one word
A word on the table gives a group a shared object to think about, which makes the host’s questions easier to hear. The Thesis deck has 50 double-sided cards: an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other. A player draws a card, picks a side, and talks. The others ask what they’re curious about, “gently, without judging.”
Curiosity sits on the back of Sewing machine. It’s a good card for a group of hosts practicing questions, because the word names the skill. One player can talk about something they wanted to understand as a child. Another can describe a sewing machine at a grandparent’s house. The rest of the table practices questions 4 and 5 on either answer.
Enough is on the back of Photograph. It pairs well with question 9, because a sense of enough mixes what a person knows with what they guess. A player who takes the photograph side might describe one picture they kept. The follow-up “Who else was there?” fits that answer well.
Honesty sits on the back of Radio. In a team it opens talk about what gets said in meetings and what doesn’t. On the radio side, a player can talk about a station that played in the kitchen. Either side gives the host a chance to try question 6 and wait.
The die adds a direction. It has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.”
Try it at your next session
Write question 1 at the top of your agenda and ask it before anything else. Close with question 11, and write the answers down as the first item for next time. Between those two, use the three follow-ups whenever an answer feels unfinished.
If you work with therapy or support groups, you know your group and decide how far a game format goes in it. Thesis is a conversation format.
For opening a session with a round, see check-in questions for group therapy. For running the game with a team or class, see Thesis for teams and classes. The three cards above have their own pages: Curiosity, Enough and Honesty. You can play online for free, see the rules and the box, or read the research behind the deck.