A circle of strangers sits, coats still on, and the host has to say the first sentence. A host can open with one question: “What brought you here?” It works because everyone in the room has an answer, and the answer can be one sentence long. This post gives that question and nine more, in an order that starts with the easiest to answer and ends with hopes for the group. It’s written for anyone running the first meeting of a peer support group, a grief circle, or a caregiver group.
Every question here works on its own, with nothing but a circle of chairs. The last section shows how a single word on a card can do the same job, for groups that freeze at a direct question.
What a first meeting asks of people
A first meeting asks people to speak to strangers about something that matters to them, before they know how the room will respond. Some aren’t sure yet whether they belong in the group. Newcomers can start shy and nervous and warm up as the evening goes on. The opening questions decide how fast that happens.
People also misjudge how the room will react. In a series of experiments, Kardas, Kumar and Epley found that conversations between strangers felt less awkward than participants expected (Kardas et al. 2021). Participants overestimated the awkwardness of deep conversations most, and they expected others to care less about their disclosures than the others did. A newcomer who holds back at the first meeting may be making that same guess.
So the first questions have one job: let each person say something true at a size they choose. A big question asked first gets small or rehearsed answers. A small question asked first gets real ones, and the bigger questions come later in the session.
Before the first question
Three things make the openers easier to answer. They take a few minutes and come before any question.
- Agree on passing. Say how a pass works, and that a one-sentence answer counts as a full turn.
- Go first yourself. Answer the first question as the host, briefly, so the group sees the size of an answer.
- Name confidentiality. One sentence on what stays in the room, in your group’s own words.
The host’s own answer sets the length of everyone else’s. If you speak at length, the group hears that a long answer is expected. A few sentences leave room for the quietest person in the circle.
Arriving: openers 1–3
The first three openers ask about the present moment. Nobody has to explain their story yet, and every answer is correct.
- What’s your name, and what would you like us to call you here?
- How was it to get here today?
- What’s one word for how you feel sitting in this circle right now?
The second question can get a laugh about traffic or a late bus. That laugh is useful. It’s the first moment the group reacts together. The one-word question gives quieter people a turn that’s complete in a single breath.
What brought you here: openers 4–6
The middle three openers ask the question the group exists for. “What brought you here?” comes first, because it lets each person pick the depth: a date, a name, a diagnosis, or “a friend told me about it.”
- What brought you here?
- What did you almost decide, before you came today?
- What would you like the people in this circle to know about you?
The fifth question names the doubt that came in the door with people. When one person admits they nearly stayed home, others who did the same can say so too. The sixth hands control to the speaker: they decide what the group learns, and what stays private for now.
What you hope for: openers 7–10
The last four openers turn toward the group itself. They’re easier to answer after a round of stories, when people have heard each other once.
- What would make this group worth coming back to?
- What do you need from the rest of us when you’re speaking?
- What’s something that helped you this week, even a small thing?
- What would you like to be different by the time this group ends?
Questions 7 and 8 give you material for the group’s agreements, in the members’ own words. Write the answers on a sheet and bring it to the second meeting. Question 10 is a good place to stop the first session. People leave with something they’ve said out loud, and you have a reference point for later meetings.
When a direct question is too much
Some groups freeze at “What brought you here?” because it points straight at the hardest part. A word on a card gives people a side door. Put a word in the middle of the circle and ask each person to say what it brings up. A player can talk about the loss that brought them, or about a thing in their kitchen. Both are full turns.
Thesis cards work this way. Each card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other, and a player chooses the side. The rules close with a last round: “each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” That line also works as the final question of any first meeting, with or without cards.
Courage sits on the back of Bicycle. In a first meeting it names what everyone in the circle did to get there. A person can talk about walking through the door today, or about learning to ride a bicycle. Both answers tell the group something about how they face new things.
Belonging is on the back of Headphones. It fits the doubt a newcomer brings about whether this group is theirs. Someone might talk about a place where they felt at home, or about the headphones they wear to shut a room out. Both answers say something about how they join a room.
Hope is on the back of Teddy bear. It suits the last stage of a first meeting, alongside openers 7–10. A person who isn’t ready to say what they hope for can talk about a teddy bear they kept for years, and the group still hears something about what they hold on to.
Try one round before the meeting
You can test the order on a shared screen before the group arrives. The online table lets you draw a card, choose a side, and roll the die.
The die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” The others ask follow-up questions from the rule card: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?
Thesis is a conversation format, and you decide how it fits your group’s purpose and limits. Before your first meeting, write openers 1, 4 and 10 on an index card and keep it in your hand. Answer each one yourself first, in two sentences.
For running Thesis in a session, see Thesis for therapy groups. The three cards above have their own pages: Courage, Belonging and Hope. You can play online for free, see the rules and the box, or read the research behind the deck. To close the same session, see check-out questions for group therapy. Related: cancer support group discussion topics about everyday life.