It’s evening. You’re outside the bar where the meetup is, reading the event page again. Through the window, people are laughing in small circles, and it looks like they all came together. You came alone, and part of you is already planning the walk home.
The first night alone goes easier with a plan small enough to remember on the doorstep: one goal, one question, one time to leave. This post gives you that plan. It also covers what research says about the fear, because the fear makes predictions, and they’ve been tested.
The fear makes predictions
Before a conversation with a stranger, people can fear three things about themselves: they won’t enjoy it, they won’t be liked, and they won’t know what to say. They can fear the same three things about the other person: that they won’t enjoy it, won’t like you, and won’t know what to say either. A mini meta-analysis pooled seven studies with 2,304 participants and compared those fears with what people reported afterward. The authors’ summary: the fears are often overblown, and conversations go better than expected (Sandstrom and Boothby 2021).
A field experiment with London train commuters found the same pattern. Commuters asked to talk with a stranger had a more positive experience than those asked to sit in solitude. A second experiment found the reason people hold back: they expected others to be uninterested in talking (Schroeder et al. 2022).
Those studies looked at strangers who hadn’t come to meet anyone. A meetup can be easier ground. Everyone in the room signed up for an evening with people they don’t know yet, including the ones laughing by the window.
The plan for the first night
The plan has five steps, in the order you’ll do them.
- Set one goal. One real conversation counts as a good night. A room full of handshakes doesn’t. A small goal is one you can reach early, and then the rest of the evening is extra.
- Find the host. Tell them it’s your first time. A host may know who else is new, and an introduction from them skips the hardest part: the first sentence to a stranger.
- Look for an open spot. A person standing alone, a pair at the bar, a circle with a gap facing outward. A gap in a circle can read as an invitation, even when nobody says so.
- Ask one question, then one more. The first question can be about the evening itself. The second one is where the talk starts.
- Leave at the time you set. Pick it before you go in. Knowing when you’ll leave can make it easier to stay until then. Take one name with you.
Questions for the first few minutes
The room gives you shared ground: the place, the group, the reason everyone came. These questions use it, from light to a little deeper:
- Is this your first one too?
- How did you find this group?
- What made you come tonight?
- What’s the best thing that’s happened at one of these?
- Do you live close by?
- What do you do when you’re not here?
- What’s something you’ve been wanting to try?
- What would make you come back next time?
A first answer is the opening. The rule card of Thesis lists three follow-ups that fit almost any answer: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? One of them, asked once, can turn an exchange of facts into a story. For more on what happens after the talk, see the liking gap.
When the meetup has a table
Some meetups are a table and a game: board game nights, language exchanges, dinners for newcomers. A card in the middle takes away the job of inventing a topic. Everyone looks at the same word, and the person who came alone gets the same turn as the person who came with friends.
Thesis works this way: 2–6 players, a card with an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other, and a die. The rules open with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” For a table of strangers, that line matters. Nobody has to say more than they want, and “A short answer is a full answer.”
These three cards read in their own way for a first night.
Courage has Bicycle on its other side. Going in alone is a small act of courage, and the card names it without making it heavy. The bicycle side is lighter: a first ride, a fall, a person holding the seat and letting go.
Belonging has Headphones on its other side. On a first night, the idea side can feel close to home, so the thing side is a soft start. Headphones bring up the music people played to shut the world out, and the places where they took them off.
Community has Mirror on its other side. In a room of new people, it brings up what makes a group feel like one. The mirror side turns inward: a hallway mirror before going out, checked one more time.
On the way home
The game ends with a last round: “each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” It works without a game, too. On the walk home, name one thing you learned about one person. That one thing is your opening line next time.
Write the date of the next meetup in your calendar tonight. The second night starts with one face in the room that may know yours. For playing with a group you’ve met, see Thesis for friends. The cards above have their own pages: Courage, Belonging and Community. See the rules and the box, or try a round on the online table. For more studies on talking with strangers, see the research page. For your first line, see how to introduce yourself. Related: how to keep a new friendship going after the first hangout.