Questions to ask your partner about death: two short talks, passing agreed first

You’re driving home from a funeral. Your partner looks out the window and says, “If that ever happens to me, don’t let them,” and stops. You both wait. Then someone mentions dinner, and the sentence stays unfinished for another year.

This post is for couples who’ve started that talk once or twice and dropped it. It gives you ten questions to ask your partner about death, split into two short talks: one about stories and values, one about wishes. Passing is agreed before the first question. You can use the list on its own, with the Thesis deck, or with one word written on a piece of paper.

Why a partner’s answer is hard to guess

It’s easy to assume you already know what the other would want. You’ve shared a bed, a lease, and years of opinions about hospitals on TV.

A review of 16 studies tested that kind of confidence. Across 2,595 pairs of patients and the people who’d decide for them, the surrogates predicted the patient’s end-of-life treatment choices in hypothetical scenarios correctly 68% of the time. Surrogates the patient had named, and pairs who’d discussed treatment wishes before, did no better (Shalowitz et al. 2006). The review covered surrogates in general, not couples alone, and it can’t say why earlier talks didn’t help. One reasonable reading for a couple: a vague talk about “not wanting machines” leaves a lot of room for guessing.

The talk also gets put off. In a January 2018 survey of 1,004 US adults, 32% had talked with loved ones about their wishes for end-of-life care, and 68% hadn’t. A primary reason was that it felt “too soon.” In the same survey, 53% said they’d feel relieved if a loved one started the conversation (The Conversation Project 2018). So the partner who changes the subject in the car may still be glad you asked on a calmer day.

Why two talks instead of one

A single big talk asks one evening to hold grief, fear, money, and medical choices at once. It can end at the first hard question, and the next try starts from zero.

Two shorter talks split the load. The first one is about what death means to each of you: the first funeral you remember, who you’d miss, what you hope to have done. Nothing gets decided. The second one, on a later evening, turns to wishes: who decides if you can’t, what matters most at the end, what should happen after. The first talk can make the second one easier, because you’ve heard each other’s stories before you hear each other’s wishes.

Before the first question

Pick an ordinary evening. A walk works, or the kitchen table after dinner. Avoid the night after a funeral or a scary test result, when one of you is already raw.

Agree how passing works before you start. Either of you can pass on a question without giving a reason, and the other doesn’t ask why. The Thesis rules have a line close to it: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.” A pass agreed in advance can take pressure off the person answering, and also off the person asking, who no longer has to guess when to stop.

Decide who answers first. The one who suggested the talk can go first, the way the game starts: “Whoever suggested the game goes first.” Hearing an answer before giving one can make the second turn easier.

Ten questions to ask your partner about death

The first five belong to the first talk. They stay with memories and values. The last five belong to the second talk and come closer to decisions. Each of you answers each question you choose to answer.

  1. What’s the first death you remember, and how did the adults around you handle it?
  2. How did your family talk about death when you were a kid, if they did?
  3. Whose death changed something in you?
  4. What are you afraid of when you think about dying: the pain, the timing, or the people you’d leave?
  5. What would you want to have done, or said, by the time it comes?
  6. If you couldn’t speak for yourself in a hospital, who would you want to decide for you, and what would make that hard for them?
  7. What would matter most to you at the end: time, comfort, being at home, being clear-headed?
  8. Is there a treatment or situation you’d want to avoid, and can you describe it in one concrete scene?
  9. What do you want to happen after: burial, cremation, something else, and who should be there?
  10. What would you want me to do with my life afterward, and is there anything you’d want me not to carry?

Question 8 asks for a scene on purpose. “I don’t want to live like that” is hard to act on. “If I can’t recognize you and can’t eat on my own, I’d want comfort care only” gives the other person something to hold on to. When an answer stays vague, one follow-up helps: Has it always meant that to you?

Question 10 can be the hardest one to ask. Ask it slowly, and let the answer be short.

Three words to start from

A question can feel too direct to begin with. A single word gives each of you a way in at your own distance. These three from the Thesis deck fit the first talk.

Death
Phone
Card 11: Death / Phone. Tap to turn it over.

Death has Phone on its other side. The word goes straight to the subject, and the object gives a gentler door: a phone call that brought bad news, a voicemail you kept, a number you still can’t delete. For a couple, the phone side can bring up who called whom when someone died, and that says a lot about who each of you leans on.

Regret
Lamp
Card 09: Regret / Lamp. Tap to turn it over.

Regret has Lamp on its other side. Regret fits question 5: what each of you would want to have done in time. It keeps the talk on how you live now, which can feel easier than talking about the end itself. A lamp can lead to a bedside, a late night of studying, or a room in a parent’s house.

Hope
Teddy bear
Card 32: Hope / Teddy bear. Tap to turn it over.

Hope has Teddy bear on its other side. Hope balances the evening. It asks what each of you still wants, for yourselves and for the other. The teddy bear can bring up childhood, and with it the question of who looked after you and how.

Playing it as a short game

If the list feels like an interview, try the format from the Thesis rules. Draw a word or pick one of the three above. Choose a side: the idea or the thing. Then roll the die. Its six faces are:

MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE

“Look at the word from that side.” The other person asks what they’re curious about, using one of the rule-card follow-ups:

What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?

Play a few rounds, then stop. You can try it now on the free online table.

Roll the die

When one of you doesn’t want to talk

A partner who says “let’s not be morbid” may be saying the timing is wrong, or that the subject scares them more than they can say. Ask which. Then offer the first talk only: stories, no decisions. It’s easier to agree to talk about a grandmother’s funeral than about your own.

If the answer is still no, leave one word on the table and wait. The pass rule covers the whole evening as well as a single question. “Play for as long as it feels good,” and that can mean a few minutes.

After the second talk

Write down what you heard, in your partner’s words, and show it to them. Ask if you got it right. Then end the way a game of Thesis ends: each of you names one thing you found out about the other today.

The forms and the paperwork can come after that, with a doctor or a lawyer who knows your state’s rules. The two talks give those forms something to rest on.

For a list that also works with a parent, a sibling, or a friend, see questions about death and dying. The three words have their own pages: Death, Regret, and Hope. For more on playing as two, see Thesis for couples. For the studies, see the research behind the deck. To see the cards and the die, read the rules and the box.