You get on the morning train and take a window seat. Someone sits down next to you. You both look at your phones, or out the window, all the way into the city. Neither of you says a word. It feels polite.
It may be the worse ride. Chicago commuters who were asked to talk to the stranger next to them had a more positive trip than commuters asked to keep to themselves. Their conversations lasted 14 minutes on average. Other commuters on the same line had predicted the opposite.
A gift card and a stamped envelope
Nicholas Epley and Juliana Schroeder of the University of Chicago ran the study at the Homewood, Illinois, Metra station, on inbound morning trains (Epley & Schroeder 2014). Homewood is one of the first stops on the express line, so the trains arrive nearly empty and everyone starts the ride alone.
Research assistants recruited people walking to the platform on their own. 118 commuters agreed. Each got a stamped envelope with a survey, a small gift card and one of three instructions, chosen at random. One read: “Please have a conversation with a new person on the train today. Try to make a connection.” Another read: “Please keep to yourself and enjoy your solitude on the train today.” A third said to commute as usual. At the end of the ride, they filled in the survey and mailed it back.
97 usable surveys came back. The people who talked to a stranger reported the most positive commute of the three groups, and a clearly more positive one than those who sat in solitude. Their conversations averaged 14.2 minutes, and they rated them 5.1 for pleasantness on a scale from 0 to 6. The longer the talk, the better the ride. Their commute wasn’t any less productive.
Then the researchers went back to the same station and asked 66 other commuters to imagine the same three instructions. These commuters predicted the reverse. They expected talking to a stranger to give them the least positive and least productive commute.
The banana round
A later round at Homewood asked commuters how open others would be to a chat. This time the thank-you gift was a banana. Commuters said they’d be more interested in talking than the person next to them would be. They guessed that fewer than half of their fellow passengers would be willing to talk.
The first experiment had already answered that. Everyone who mailed back a survey from the talking group had talked with the person they approached. Not one reported being rebuffed. The seven who couldn’t follow the instruction said nobody had sat next to them. The authors put it plainly: “As far as we can tell, it posed no risk at all.”
Why the silence holds
The paper’s explanation is a loop. You stay quiet because you think the other person doesn’t want to talk. They stay quiet for the same reason. Each of you reads the other’s silence as proof. So nobody tries, and nobody learns that the conversation would have gone well.
The researchers found a sign of this in the taxi line at Chicago Midway airport. Travelers asked to talk to their driver had a more positive ride than those asked to sit in silence. Others in the same line predicted each ride. Those who usually chat with drivers expected talking to be better. Those who usually don’t expected the opposite. Only the people with practice knew how it goes.
The other seat
One more experiment turns the idea around. In a lab waiting room in downtown Chicago, one stranger was asked to start a conversation and the other got no instructions. The person who was talked to had as positive a wait as the person who did the talking. The pleasure didn’t stay with whoever spoke first.
Next time someone sits down next to you, think about the commuter in the other seat. If the paper is right, they’re guessing you don’t want to talk, the same way you’re guessing about them. Say something first. On the Homewood line, nobody who tried got turned down.
For a related finding about first conversations, see the liking gap.