You say “I hope it works out” without thinking about it. Then a hard month comes, someone asks if you still have hope, and you can’t tell whether the honest answer is yes, no, or “I’m waiting.” The word you use every day turns out to have no clear edges.
This guide gives you a working definition, shows how hope differs from optimism and from wishing, and ends with ten questions to find what hope means in your own life. You can work through them alone with a pen, with a friend, or with a word on a card.
A working definition
Hope is wanting a good outcome while seeing at least one way toward it and the will to keep going. It sits between two simpler states. A wish wants the outcome and stops there. Optimism expects the outcome and doesn’t need a plan.
That definition comes from psychology more than from a dictionary. In 1991, C. R. Snyder and colleagues described hope as a cognitive set with two parts. Agency is goal-directed determination: the sense that you can start and keep moving. Pathways is planning: seeing one or more ways to reach the goal. They built a self-report scale around those two parts. Its scores predicted goal-related activity and coping strategies beyond other self-report measures (Snyder et al. 1991).
In this model, a hopeful person can name a next step and still wants to take it.
Hope and optimism side by side
Optimism has its own research line. Michael Scheier and Charles Carver defined it as generalized outcome expectancies: a broad belief that things will turn out well (Scheier and Carver 1985). Optimism is about the forecast. Hope, in Snyder’s model, is about the route and the drive to walk it.
The difference shows up in ordinary situations. You can be optimistic about the weather for a picnic without any plan, because nothing you do changes the sky. You can hope a job interview goes well while doubting your odds, and still prepare an answer for the question you dread. The second case has a goal, a path and effort. The first has an expectation.
Hope also has a feeling side. David Feldman and Hooria Jazaieri note that many scholars and laypeople view hope mainly as an emotion, and they built a 6-item scale to measure hope as a feeling. They tested it across three studies with 2,900 adults in total. In the first study, with 182 undergraduates, scores on the feeling scale correlated with optimism at r = 0.71 (Feldman and Jazaieri 2024). That’s a strong link. In the same paper, the feeling scale explained variance that the cognitive hope scale didn’t, so the two still carry different names.
Why the word gets blurry
Hope blurs because the same sentence covers three states. “I hope I get better at this” can be a wish with no plan. It can be optimism that time will fix it. It can be a plan for next Monday with a reason to follow it. From the outside the words are identical.
The blur matters in the moments when hope runs low. Someone who keeps missing their own goals may say they feel hopeless about it. In Snyder’s terms, the issue might be agency (no energy left to try) or pathways (no idea what to try next). Those point to different kinds of help. Encouragement speaks to agency. Brainstorming one small next step speaks to pathways.
Your own answer to “what is hope” can live in stories more than in a definition. A grandparent who planted trees they’d never sit under. A move to a new city with one suitcase. A test result you waited days for. The ten questions below are built to bring those stories up.
Ten questions about hope
These questions work best answered with a story: a place, a year, a person. Skip any that land too close.
- What’s the first thing you remember hoping for as a child?
- Who in your family was the hopeful one, and how could you tell?
- When did you hope for something and get it, and what happened next?
- When did you keep hoping after it stopped making sense?
- What do you hope for that you’d never say out loud?
- Where does hope sit in your body when you have it?
- What’s the difference, for you, between hoping and expecting?
- What do you hope for that you can’t influence at all?
- When did someone else’s hope carry you for a while?
- What do you hope is still true about you in ten years?
Question 7 is the one that sorts the definitions. If your answers keep mentioning a plan, your hope leans on pathways. If they keep mentioning a feeling, it leans on emotion. Both count.
Look at the word from six sides
Another way in is to keep the word fixed and change the angle. The Thesis die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.”
Roll it, or pick a face, and say what Hope brings up from there. Then roll again. One word gives a different story each time, and six stories about hope say more than one careful sentence.
Hope has a Teddy bear on its other side. Choose the idea when you want to talk about what you’re hoping for now. Choose the Teddy bear when a story is easier: the one you slept with, the one you gave away, the one someone kept for you. The object lets you reach hope sideways, through a childhood story.
Try it with someone
Hope said out loud to another person can get clearer. The listener may hear where your voice changes and asks about that part. Two or three people at a kitchen table is enough.
The Thesis rules say: “Before you start, decide together how passing works.” Then take turns:
- Draw a card. Pick a side: the idea or the thing.
- Roll the die. Look at the word from that side.
- Say as much or as little as you like. The others ask, gently.
- Hand the die to the left.
Three follow-up questions fit every word: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? For Hope, the third one does most of the work. Hope at 15 and hope at 40 can be about different things.
“There are no right answers.” For a word like Hope, that line also covers hope that didn’t come true. A story about waiting for a call that never came is a full answer.
A word close to Hope
Hope sits next to other words in the deck. One of them pulls the conversation toward the part you can’t control.
Luck has a Passport on its other side. Put Luck next to Hope and the split from the definition shows up on the table: what you hoped for and worked toward, and what arrived by chance. You might tell about a lucky break you’d stopped hoping for, or choose the Passport side and talk about a trip, a border, or a move. If the word lands too close, pass.
What to do tonight
Write the word Hope on a piece of paper. Pick question 7 from the list, or one face of the die. Tell one story to someone you trust and let them ask one follow-up. “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”
When you’re done, try a last round: each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today. “Sometimes one word is enough.”
See the rules and the box, or open the free online table. The cards above have their own pages: Hope and Luck. For a word that sits near Hope, see Courage. For playing with a few close people, see Thesis for friends. The research behind the deck explains where the words came from. For the questions a move to a new country brings up, see what home means after moving abroad. Related: what does a sense of belonging mean? A plain definition and 10 questions.