You leave a party where you met someone new. On the walk to the train you start the replay. The story about your job ran long. You laughed at your own joke. There was that pause after they asked where you’re from. By the time the doors close, you’ve decided they were being polite.
They probably liked you more than that. In a lab study at Yale, people rated their liking of a new partner at 5.82 out of 7 on average. They guessed the partner’s liking of them at 5.17. Both numbers describe the same conversations, so the lower one is a mistake.
The clock on the table
Erica Boothby, Gus Cooney, Gillian Sandstrom and Margaret Clark kept the first study plain. They put up fliers near the Yale campus, and 36 people came to the lab. Two strangers sat side by side at a large table with a sheet of icebreaker questions: “Where are you from?” “What are some of your hobbies?” They talked for about five minutes.
On the table sat a computer showing an analog clock, there to help them pace themselves. That was the cover story. The computer was recording them.
Afterward, in separate rooms, each person answered two sets of questions. How much did you like the other person? How much do you think they liked you? The second answer came out lower (Boothby et al. 2018).
Then the researchers used the recordings. Two trained assistants, who didn’t know what the study was testing, watched the videos and rated how much each person seemed to like their partner. Their ratings matched what people said they felt. The participants’ own guesses didn’t match them. The signs of liking were on the video. The person sitting next to them missed it.
It didn’t go away
The team kept looking for the edge of the effect. Pairs who talked as long as they liked, anywhere up to 45 minutes, still showed the gap. So did adults who met at personal development workshops in the UK.
The longest test followed 102 first-year students at Yale who shared dorm suites. They rated their suitemates five times over one school year: September, October, December, February and May. The gap was there at the first four points. At the last survey, half of the students were offered a cash bonus of a hundred dollars for the most accurate guess. The offer didn’t change their estimates. They believed what they said.
The gap was gone by May. The authors suggest two reasons: the students knew each other well by then, and they were deciding who to live with next year, which may have forced some honest talks.
Why your replay is harsher
When you tell a story, you know the better version you had in mind. The listener only hears the version you told, and it was fine. You also feel your nerves and assume they show. The other person sees your face and hears your words, and those tend to be smooth. People smile, laugh, take turns and pause in sync without trying.
In a second lab study, 84 Yale students and recent graduates talked about whatever they liked. Then each wrote down the top three moments behind their impression of the partner, and the top three behind the partner’s impression of them. The moments about themselves came out more negative. That gap in the moments tracked the gap in how much they thought they were liked.
There’s a useful side to the replay. Going over your mistakes helps you tell the story better next time. The cost is that it hides how the evening went for the other person.
Try this the next time
When the replay starts on the train, ask a different question. Skip “how did I come across?” and ask “what did I like about them?” Somewhere on another train, they’re running the same replay and guessing you liked them less than you did. Send them a message about one thing they said.
The longer version of the research is in the liking gap post.