An awkward one-on-one can have a plain cause. The manager fills the quiet, the report holds back, or the meeting repeats what both already said at their desks. Research on these meetings points to all three, and to a gap in how each side rates the same meeting. This post goes through the causes one by one, with a change a manager can make for each. The changes work with a shared note and a word on a sticky note.
Two people leave the same meeting with different ratings
The awkwardness can be visible to only one side. Steven Rogelberg studies one-on-one meetings. In his research, nearly 50 percent of employees found their one-on-ones lacked substance, even when their managers rated those same meetings as positive. He also writes that managers’ self-ratings of their skill at running them appear inflated (Rogelberg 2024). His summary draws on a global survey of 1,200 knowledge workers, a US survey of 250 employees, and interviews with about 50 leaders.
So a manager who leaves the meeting feeling fine has learned little about how it went for the report. The report has a reason to keep quiet about it, too. Telling a manager that their meeting feels empty is its own awkward conversation.
The manager fills the quiet
A pause in a one-on-one is easiest to end for the person running it. The fastest way is to talk: an update from leadership, a story from last week, advice nobody asked for. Rogelberg’s data puts a cost on that habit. The biggest predictor of an ineffective one-on-one was a manager who talked more than the direct report. The ideal balance appeared to be the report speaking 50–90 percent of the time (Rogelberg 2024).
Part of the pull is built in. Tamir and Mitchell let people choose between answering questions about their own opinions and questions about someone else, with small payments attached to each choice. When the payoffs were equal, people chose to talk about themselves 69% of the time. In the same study, they gave up an average of 17% of their potential earnings to do it (Tamir and Mitchell 2012). A manager who talks through a pause may be following that pull, and the report loses the time the meeting was for.
What helps: count to five before you speak after a question. If the report is still thinking, the pause is doing its job.
The report holds back
Even a report who likes their manager may keep their guard up. On a workplace forum, one employee described monthly one-on-ones with a new manager she found capable and kind. She still held back how she felt, struggled to find topics, and felt she had to carry the meeting. The meetings had been framed as a record for her annual review.
Research on employee silence describes the same pattern from the inside. Milliken, Morrison and Hewlin interviewed 40 employees. Most had been in situations where they were concerned about an issue and didn’t raise it with a supervisor. The reason mentioned most often was fear of being viewed or labeled negatively, and of damaging relationships they valued (Milliken et al. 2003). In a meeting framed as review evidence, every sentence can feel like it goes on file.
What helps: separate the record from the conversation. Agree at the start what goes into notes and what stays in the room. The Thesis rule card has a line for this: “What is said at the table stays at the table.” In a one-on-one the manager holds more power, so the manager says it first.
Everything was already said at the desk
A weekly one-on-one can feel empty when the two people talk all day anyway. Commenters on one tech forum thread described the result: every update has already been shared in chat or stand-up, so the one-on-one turns into a performance of having something to say. The forum employee above made the same point. She saw her manager almost every day.
Status updates fill that gap because they’re easy. Rogelberg calls it the status update trap. He suggests giving 5–10 minutes of each meeting, or one meeting in four, to longer-term topics such as career plans (Rogelberg 2024). Those topics don’t come up at the desk, so they give the meeting something only it can hold.
What helps: move updates to the tracker or the team channel. Keep the one-on-one for what a tracker can’t hold.
“What do you want to talk about?” lands on an empty page
Rogelberg recommends that opening question, and both reports and managers rated meetings highest when the report created the agenda (Rogelberg 2024). Asked cold, the same question can feel like a test. The forum employee heard it at the start of every meeting and felt she was being asked to unpack a whole month on the spot.
Rogelberg’s fix is a plan. Rogelberg describes a listing approach: each person writes their own topics, then the two of them work through the lists, the report’s list first. He also notes that monthly meetings tend to focus on whatever happened most recently. A weekly or every-other-week rhythm fits the research best (Rogelberg 2024).
Questions about the meeting itself
A one-on-one that feels awkward can be the topic of one meeting. The questions below ask about the format, so the report can answer without talking about their own performance:
- What would make this meeting worth keeping in your week?
- What do you want to stay out of the notes?
- Which topics would you rather send me in writing first?
- How often would you like to meet?
- What should I stop asking about here?
- When I go quiet after a question, how does that land?
- What would you bring if updates were off the table?
- Which longer-term topic would you like a whole meeting for?
After each answer, ask one follow-up before you add your view. The Thesis rule card gives three: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?
A word instead of a question
A direct question from a manager can feel like an assessment. A single word on the table gives the report the choice of angle and depth. Write a word on a sticky note, or draw a card from Thesis and let the report pick a side. Each card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other. The rule card is clear about depth: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”
Silence has Tree on its back. It suits a one-on-one that keeps stalling, because it names the thing in the room. A report might talk about the meetings where they’d rather say nothing, or about quiet hours they protect for deep work. The Tree side is an easy way out for anyone who’d rather not.
Boundaries pairs with Shoes. It opens the question of what belongs in this meeting and what doesn’t, in the report’s words. The Shoes side can lead to commutes, office dress, or the walk they take after work.
Enough sits behind Photograph. In a one-on-one it can turn into a talk about workload: when a week is enough, and when it’s too much. The Photograph side gives a lighter route, a picture on a desk or a phone.
The deck also has a die with six words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. Look at the word from that side. For a remote one-on-one, share the online table and draw a card together.
For your next one-on-one
Send your report a shared note with two empty lists, theirs and yours, and one word at the top. Add the line “Bring a thought about this, if you like.” In the meeting, start with their list and count to five after each question.
The three cards have their own pages: Silence, Boundaries and Enough. For group sessions, see Thesis for teams and classes. For the research behind the deck, see Thesis research. For more on awkward conversations, see why deep conversations feel awkward. See the rules and the box.