The engagement survey comes back and one line has dropped: “I feel I belong on this team.” HR asks the team lead to talk about it. The obvious move is to ask the team straight out who feels left out, and the room goes quiet. This guide shows a team lead or an HR partner how to run one conversation about belonging at work that people can answer without exposing themselves. It works with one word written on a sticky note, and the free online table covers the rest.
What belonging at work covers
Belonging at work has two parts, and a team needs both. Lynn Shore and colleagues reviewed the research on inclusion in work groups. They described inclusion as meeting two needs at once: the need to belong and the need to stay distinct (Shore et al. 2011). A team where people fit in only by hiding what makes them different meets the first need and fails the second. A conversation about belonging can check both: whether people feel they’re inside the group, and whether they can bring their own way of working into it.
The need behind it is old and broad. Roy Baumeister and Mark Leary reviewed the evidence for a basic human need to form and keep lasting relationships. They found that people form bonds easily and resist losing them, and that a lack of attachments was linked to worse health and well-being (Baumeister and Leary 1995). A team is one of the groups where that need shows up every working day.
Where the gap shows
Loneliness is one sign that belonging is missing. In Gallup’s State of the Global Workplace 2024 survey, 20% of employees worldwide said they had felt lonely a lot of the previous day. The share was 25% for fully remote workers, 21% for hybrid workers and 16% for those fully on-site. Loneliness was also more common among employees under 35 (Gallup 2024). For a team lead, that points to the people to think about first: the remote hire, the newest person, and the youngest person on the call.
Remote hires describe the same gap in forum threads about their first year. Someone joins, works with the team for months and has never met anyone off camera. The online happy hour turns into a work call with drinks. Months in, the new hire still feels like a guest.
Why a direct question gets silence
“Do you feel you belong here?” asks people to rate the team in front of the team. Saying no sounds like a complaint about the people in the room, and the manager is one of them. Saying yes costs nothing, so yes can be the only answer the question gets. The people with the most to say can be the ones with the most to lose by saying it.
A word works better because it lets people talk about belonging somewhere else first. A first team, a school sports club, a choir, a group of friends from a first job. The stories carry the same information: what made someone feel inside a group, and what made them feel at its edge. The team hears what helps without anyone grading the current team in public.
A belonging round in five steps
The round below fits one team meeting. Each step takes a few minutes, and the order matters, because the safest part comes first.
- Say why, and agree on passing. Name the reason in one sentence: “The survey said some of us don’t feel part of the team, and I want to hear what helps.” Then agree that anyone can pass with no reason given. The Thesis rules start the same way: “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” If you’re the manager, you go first and you say the pass rule out loud.
- A story from another group. Write the word Belonging on a sticky note or the whiteboard. Each person talks about a group where they felt inside, or one where they felt at the edge. It can be a club, a class or an old job. This round is easy to give, and it shows the team what belonging looks like for each person.
- A story from this team. Ask for one moment on this team when someone felt included. A colleague who explained an acronym in the first week counts. So does a meeting where someone’s idea got picked up. Keep this round to positive moments, so nobody has to accuse anyone.
- One thing that helps. Each person names one small habit that would make the team easier to join. Write them down without debate. Pick one or two to try for a month.
- Close the round. The Thesis rules end each game with one last round: “each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” A few people saying one line is enough for a meeting.
Belonging also changes with the room. If a skip-level manager or someone from HR joins, people may answer with that person in mind. Run the round with the team alone when you can, and share only the list from step 4.
Ten questions about belonging at work
These questions work at any depth, and none of them asks someone to rate the people present:
- What’s a group you joined where you felt at home fast?
- What did someone do in your first week here that helped?
- When did you feel like a guest somewhere, and what changed it?
- What’s something about how you work that took this team a while to see?
- What’s a habit from an old team you’d bring here?
- Who did you go to with questions when you were new?
- What makes it easier to speak up in a meeting?
- What’s a small ritual that makes a group feel like a group?
- What do you do differently from the rest of us that you’d keep?
- What would you tell the next person who joins?
Questions 4 and 9 cover the second half of belonging: staying distinct inside the group. They’re worth keeping in, even when the team only asks for the first half.
Three cards that fit the round
Each Thesis card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other. The thing side gives anyone a way to answer without talking about their feelings at work.
Belonging has Headphones on its back. On a team, Headphones can read two ways: the person who puts them on to shut out an open office, or two colleagues sharing one earbud on a train. Someone who’d rather not talk about fitting in can talk about headphones, and the team still learns how that person likes to work.
Community has Mirror on its back. It suits step 2, because the word pulls stories from outside work: a neighborhood, a club, a group chat. The Mirror side lets someone talk about how they see themselves in a group, or how they think the group sees them.
Trust has Window on its back. It fits step 3, since a moment of feeling included can be a moment someone was trusted with something. The Window side is an easy way in: a desk by a window, a view from a first office, a video call that’s a window into someone’s kitchen.
Running it as a card round
With the deck or the online table, each turn follows the same steps. Draw a card, choose the idea or the thing, roll the die and look at the word from that side. The die has six plain words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” The others can ask one short question. The rule card gives three examples: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? One line from the rule card matters most in this round: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”
Before the next team meeting, write your one-sentence reason for the round and put it in the invite with the word Belonging. If the survey line points to one person who feels outside, see the liking gap at work. For more on running it at work, see Thesis for teams and classes. For the studies behind the deck, see the research. See the rules and the box. Related: boundaries at work: a team conversation in five steps. Related: talent at work: a strengths conversation for your team.