The liking gap at work: your team likes you more than you think

The team call ends and you’re still replaying it. Your idea got a polite nod and then the topic moved on. Two colleagues laughed at something you didn’t catch. At lunch you sat with the group and couldn’t think of anything to say. By the evening you’ve decided the team puts up with you.

This post is for that evening. Researchers have a name for the gap between how much a group likes you and how much you think it does: the liking gap. Below is what a study of groups and teams found, where the evidence stops, and what to try at work this week.

The short answer

Your team probably likes you more than you think. Adam Mastroianni, Gus Cooney, Erica Boothby and Andrew Reece ran three studies on the liking gap in groups. They found it in conversations among small groups and in engineering teams working on a project together. In a third study with working adults, the gap was linked to how well teams could work together (Mastroianni et al. 2021).

The authors end their abstract with a plain line: group conversations and team interactions often leave people unsure where they stand, but people are liked more than they know.

Where the idea comes from

The liking gap was first described for pairs. Boothby, Cooney, Sandstrom and Clark had people talk one-on-one and then guess how much their partner liked them. People underestimated how much their partners liked them and enjoyed their company. The gap showed up between strangers in a lab, among first-year college students who shared dorms, and among adults at a personal development workshop. It held across conversation lengths and for several months as the dormmates got to know each other (Boothby et al. 2018). The original study is covered in more detail in the liking gap explained.

Work adds two things a pair conversation doesn’t have. There are several people to read at once, and you’ll see them again on Monday. The team study asked whether the gap survives both.

What the team study found

The three studies move step by step from the lab toward the office:

  1. Small groups. People talked in small groups instead of pairs, and the liking gap appeared there too.
  2. Engineering teams. The gap continued to exist in teams working together on a project, where people had a shared task and repeated contact.
  3. Working adults. In a sample of people with jobs, the gap was linked to consequences for their teams’ ability to work together.

Two more results matter for a normal workday. The gap was largest between peers, the colleagues at your own level. And it depended partly on how much people focused on the negative parts of the impression they thought they’d made (Mastroianni et al. 2021). In other words, the person who spends the evening on the polite nod may be the one guessing wrong.

Why the replay runs harsher than the meeting

The replay has more material than anyone else in the room. You know the version of your idea you meant to say, and the shorter one that came out. You noticed your own pause before you answered. Your colleagues heard the idea once and moved on to their own part of the agenda.

A group makes the guess harder. In a pair, one person’s face gives you feedback. In a meeting, you’re watching several faces at once, and any one of them can look bored for reasons that have nothing to do with you. A laugh you didn’t catch fills the gap with the worst reading.

Small talk with colleagues brings its own version. People describe having little in common with their coworkers and struggling to find topics. Others say team activities feel awkward when people don’t know each other well. Both read silence as a verdict. The study suggests the verdict in your head is harsher than the one in theirs.

Where the finding stops

The study shows an average pattern across groups. It doesn’t tell you what one colleague thought of you after Tuesday’s standup. Some teams have real conflict, and the liking gap doesn’t erase it. A team where someone is left out on purpose is a different problem from a team where someone underestimates how they come across.

The abstract also links the gap to teams’ ability to work together, but it doesn’t show that closing the gap fixes a team. Use the finding as a reason to doubt the harshest version of the replay. It’s no guarantee about any one person.

Eight questions for the day after a hard meeting

These questions move attention from your own performance to what your colleagues did. Write the answers down the next morning, before the first meeting of the day.

  1. Who asked you a follow-up question, in the meeting or after it?
  2. Who used your name or built on something you said?
  3. Who messaged you about work they didn’t have to involve you in?
  4. Which moment are you replaying, and how many seconds did it last?
  5. What else was going on for the person who looked bored?
  6. When did someone ask your opinion before deciding something?
  7. What would you tell a colleague who described this same meeting to you?
  8. What do you like about the people on your team?

The last question points the other way. If you like a colleague and they can’t tell, the gap runs in both directions.

Three cards for a team that wants to talk about it

A word on a sticky note works for a short round in a team meeting. The Thesis deck has an idea on one side of each card and an everyday thing on the other. Three cards sit close to this topic.

Competition
Bench
Card 35: Competition / Bench. Tap to turn it over.

Competition has a Bench on its other side. The study found the gap largest between peers, and peers are also the people you’re compared with. The idea side opens talk about a rivalry that turned into respect. The Bench gives an easy way in: waiting to be picked for a team, or a lunch break outside the office.

Gratitude
Fence
Card 31: Gratitude / Fence. Tap to turn it over.

Gratitude has a Fence on its other side. A colleague may like your work and never say so. The idea side can bring up a time someone’s help at work mattered more than they knew. The Fence lets someone talk about neighbors, borders between teams, or the line between work and home.

Kindness
Book
Card 46: Kindness / Book. Tap to turn it over.

Kindness has a Book on its other side. The idea side can bring stories about small acts at work: a colleague covering a shift, a message after a bad presentation. The Book side suits someone who’d rather talk about something they’re reading.

Running a round with your team

The Thesis rules start with one line: “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” At work, a pass has to cost nothing. Each turn, someone draws a card, picks the idea or the thing, rolls the die and looks at the word from that side. The die has six plain words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.”

The rule card keeps the turns short: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.” The others can ask a gentle question. The rule card gives three examples: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?

Roll the die

The game ends with a round that speaks to the liking gap: “each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” For someone sure the team barely notices them, that round puts the answer out loud.

What to do this week

Pick the colleague you feel least sure about. Send them one short message about something they said or did in a recent meeting: an idea you liked, a question that helped. Then answer question 8 from the list above for that person. Both steps test the replay against something real.

See the rules and the box, or open the free online table. The cards above have their own pages: Competition, Gratitude and Kindness. For more on running it at work, see Thesis for teams and classes. For a short opener before the agenda, see check-in questions for team meetings. For the studies behind the deck, see the research page. Related: team building card games for work: one word per turn. See also trust at work: how to talk about it with your team. Related: what does success mean at work? How to ask your team. Related: competition at work: how to talk about it as a team.