Your 1:1s have a career slot. Every so often you ask about the next level, the person names the title above theirs, and you both move on. Months later you learn they wanted something else: a project they could finish, a weekday at home, a skill nobody on the team has. This guide is for team leads who want that answer early. It gives a 1:1 format, a team round built on one word, ten questions, and a way to use what you hear.
The short answer
Success at work means different things to the people on one team. For one person it’s a promotion. For another it’s leaving on time with nothing half-done. For a third it’s being the one people ask when the build breaks. A manager can’t guess which, and the job title doesn’t tell you. The only way to know is to ask, give people time to think, and listen longer than you talk.
Why the career question falls flat
Career researcher Peter Heslin reviewed how studies measure career success. He argued that research has often measured it in a deficient way, and called for more attention to the criteria people themselves use to judge their careers. He also separated self-referent standards, where people judge against their own goals, from other-referent ones, where they judge against other people (Heslin 2005). “What’s your next level?” only reaches the other-referent part. It asks where someone stands on a ladder the company built.
The format of the meeting adds to the problem. Steven Rogelberg, who studies one-on-one meetings, summarizes his research this way: nearly 50 percent of employees found their 1:1s lacked substance, and managers’ ratings of their own 1:1 skills appear inflated. The biggest predictor of an ineffective 1:1 was a manager who talked more than the direct report. He puts the direct report’s ideal share of the talking at 50–90 percent. He also recommends adding longer-term topics such as career planning from time to time, so the meeting doesn’t turn into status updates (Rogelberg 2024). A career question asked at the end, after a status update the manager led, gets the short answer.
A 1:1 format in five steps
This format takes one full 1:1. Run it every few months or when someone’s role changes.
- Send the topic a week ahead. Write one line in the invite: “Next time I’d like to hear what success at work looks like for you.” Rogelberg reports that 1:1s were rated highest when the direct report created the agenda, alone or with the manager. Ask them to bring two or three notes.
- Start with a story. Ask for one week, project or day at work that felt like a success, and why. A story gives you their criteria without asking for a definition.
- Keep your share small. Ask one follow-up at a time and wait. If you notice you’ve talked longer than they have, stop and ask a question.
- Name what you heard. Repeat their criteria in their words: “So a good quarter for you is one where you shipped something you’d show a friend.” Let them correct it.
- Pick one thing for the next quarter. Agree on one change you can make: a project, a skill, a schedule, a type of feedback. Write it where you’ll both see it next quarter.
Ten questions about success at work
These questions work in the 1:1 above or in a team round. Pick two or three. Each one leaves room for a short answer.
- What’s a day at work you’d call a good day?
- What’s a piece of work you’re proud of that nobody asked for?
- When did you hit a target and feel less than you expected?
- What would a good year in this role look like to you?
- Whose work here do you admire, and which part of it?
- What would you like to be known for on this team?
- What does enough work look like in a week?
- What did success at work mean to you in your first job?
- What’s a skill you’d like to have in a year?
- How would you know this job is working for you?
Questions 3, 7 and 10 ask about a person’s own standards. Questions 5 and 6 ask about the comparison with others. Both kinds are useful to hear.
Running it as a team round
A team round shows the range of answers in one room. People hear that their colleague’s version of success differs from theirs, which can make the 1:1 version easier later. A word can work better than a direct question here, because each person can choose how personal to go.
The Thesis rules open with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” At work, a pass has to cost nothing. Say that before the first turn, and say it as the manager. Then run the round the way the rule card describes:
- Draw a card. Choose a side: the idea or the thing.
- Roll the die.
- Look at the word from that side. Say as much or as little as feels right.
- The others ask what they’re curious about, gently, without judging.
- Hand the die to the left.
The die has six plain words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” The rule card gives three follow-up questions: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? For a word about work, the third one turns a definition into a career history.
Success has Notebook on its back. On a team, the idea side brings up targets, reviews and launches. The Notebook side is the easier way in: a planner from a first job, a to-do list, the notebook someone fills in every meeting. Old plans show what success used to mean for that person, and the gap between that plan and today can be the answer.
Enough has Photograph on its back. It suits teams where people work long hours, because it asks where the line is without naming anyone’s workload. Someone might talk about the week they stopped checking email at night. Someone else might pick the photograph and talk about a picture from a team event.
Balance has Watch on its back. Some people on a team define success by output, others by time they keep for themselves. This card lets both talk about it without a debate. The Watch side brings out stories about deadlines, time zones and the first watch someone bought with their own pay.
“There are no right answers.” The rule card prints that line, and it carries weight on this topic. Each person at work already has right answers about success in their job description.
What to do with the answers
Answers about success are useful only if something follows from them. After the 1:1, write down each person’s criteria in a sentence or two. Look at them before you assign the next project. A person who wants to finish things gets a project with a clear end. A person who wants to be the expert gets the problem nobody else has solved. A person who wants their evenings back gets a clear say when a deadline slips.
Bring the answer back next quarter. Ask whether the sentence you wrote still fits. “Has it always meant that to you?” works here too, because definitions of success change when people change roles, teams or lives.
Start with one invite
For your next round of 1:1s, add the one line about success to a single invite and see what the person brings. For a team session, start the round on the free online table with three cards. The words above have their own pages: Success, Enough and Balance. For the personal side of the same question, see what success means to you. For more on running it at work, see Thesis for teams and classes. For the studies behind the deck, see the research page. For the full set, see the rules and the box. Related: what does your work mean to you? Ten questions and one word. Related: play at work: ask your team what counts before you plan the fun.