The fun budget gets approved, and someone in HR books a bowling night. Part of the team comes. In the next retro, someone says team events made them want to leave past jobs. The plan wasn’t wrong about play. It skipped a step: asking the team what play at work looks like for them. This guide is for the team lead or HR partner who wants that conversation first. It fits into one meeting and works with a word on a sticky note.
What the research says about managed fun
Play at work can lift or lower how people feel at work, depending on whether they agree to it. Ethan Mollick and Nancy Rothbard tested this with a sales game run by managers. In their field experiment, employees who consented to the game reported more positive affect at work, and those who didn’t consent reported less. A follow-up lab study found two sources of consent: the game had to feel legitimate, and people needed a sense of their own agency (Mollick and Rothbard 2013). The study ran with several hundred e-commerce salespeople, and for those who didn’t consent, the game even came with drops in performance (Wharton Magazine).
A second finding explains where the resistance comes from. Peter Fleming studied a “culture of fun” program at a communications firm. The managed fun borrowed from family, lifestyle and school life, and blurred the line between work and the rest of life. For some employees, that blurring fed cynicism (Fleming 2005). For a team lead, the two studies point the same way. People need a say in the fun, and they need their life outside work to stay their own.
Four kinds of play your team might mean
“Play” covers activities that have little in common, so a team talking about it needs a shared map. Nicole Celestine and Gillian Yeo reviewed 122 studies on activity-based play at work. They sorted play along two lines: who starts it, a manager or the employees themselves, and whether it happens inside the work or as a break from it (Celestine and Yeo 2021). That gives four kinds.
- Manager-started, inside the work: a planning session run as a structured game.
- Self- or peer-started, inside the work: treating a task as a puzzle, a race or a sport.
- Manager-started, as a break: celebrations, parties and team events.
- Self- or peer-started, as a break: the running jokes and small rituals a team builds on its own.
The bowling night sits in one corner of that map. A team’s play may live in another one: the shared playlist, the puzzle someone turns a bug hunt into, the joke that’s run for months. The conversation below helps the team find its own corner before anyone books anything.
How to run the conversation
The conversation fits into a regular team meeting. Follow the steps in this order.
- Say why. One sentence: “Before we spend the team budget, I’d like to hear what play at work means to each of you.”
- Agree how passing works. The Thesis rules put it as “Before you start, decide together how passing works.” At work, a pass costs nothing and needs no reason. Say it before the first turn.
- Show the four kinds. Put the list above on a slide. Ask people to notice which kind they already do, without saying it yet.
- Go first yourself. Name one thing you do at work that feels like play, in two sentences. Your length sets the length for the round.
- Go around once. Each person names one moment of play from their own work, or passes.
- Ask about the line. In a second round, ask what would turn that same thing into a chore. This is where the consent findings show up in plain words.
- Write down two things. Note what people want more of and what they’d rather skip. Share the notes after the meeting, and let them shape the budget.
Remote teams can run the rounds in the chat. Post the question, give people a few minutes, then ask everyone to send at the same moment.
Ten questions about play at work
The questions below stay with work and leave private life out, and each one works at any depth. Pick two or three per meeting.
- When did work last feel like a game to you?
- What task do you turn into a puzzle to get through it?
- What’s a running joke on this team, and how did it start?
- Which team event did you enjoy, and what made it work?
- What would make a team event feel like an obligation?
- What’s something you do at your desk that nobody asked for and you’d keep anyway?
- Who on this team makes meetings lighter, and how?
- What did play look like at your first job?
- What would you do with an hour of the workday to play?
- What should stay outside work, even if it’s fun?
Three cards for the conversation
A card gives the team one word to talk around, so the answers stay personal without getting private. Each Thesis card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other.
Play has Laptop on its back. For this meeting, the pair puts the whole topic on one card. The Play side brings up what people do for fun. The Laptop side brings the talk back to the work itself: the tool where someone first played with code, a spreadsheet built for no reason, or the screen that follows them home in the evening.
Joy has Chair on its back. Joy lets someone talk about a good day at work without calling it fun. The Chair side gives a quieter way in: the seat by the window, the chair in the office kitchen where the best talks happen, or a chair someone’s sat in for years.
Friendship has Ball on its back. At work, Friendship can bring up the colleague someone first laughed with. The Ball side reads as play in its oldest form, and it lets anyone talk about a game or a sport instead of their friendships at work.
Running it as a card round
With the deck or the free online table, each turn follows the same steps. Draw a card, choose the idea or the thing, roll the die and look at the word from that side. The die has six plain words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” The rules then say: “Say as much or as little as you like. The others ask, gently.” Good follow-up questions are short and open: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?
The rules also set one line that matters at work: “What is said at the table stays there.” Say it before the first card, so nobody’s answer about a boring task travels to their review.
Before the next team event
Look at the last three events your team ran and place each one on the four-kinds list. If all three sit in the manager-started break corner, ask the team about the other three corners before booking the next one. The cards above have their own pages: Play, Joy and Friendship. For more on running it at work, see Thesis for teams and classes. For the studies behind the deck, see the research page. See the rules and the box. For a slower team talk, see deep conversations at work. Related: what does success mean at work? How to ask your team.