You have a question ready for the team lunch: “What made you say yes to this job?” Then you picture the faces. Someone shrugs, someone laughs, someone looks at their phone. You ask about weekend plans instead, and the lunch stays where every lunch stays.
This post is for team leads who want one deeper conversation with their team and keep backing out of it. It covers what one set of experiments found about that hesitation, which part of the risk is real at work, and how to run a short round that keeps the real part small. A word on a sticky note is enough to try it.
The short answer
Much of the dread is a forecast, and the forecast runs low. In experiments by Michael Kardas, Amit Kumar and Nicholas Epley, people expected deep talk with someone new to feel more awkward than it did. They also expected the other person to care less about their answers than the other person did (Kardas et al. 2021). One part of the risk holds up at work: what a person shares can affect how colleagues see them, and that cost is larger for people with more status. Both parts can be handled in the same round.
The study with finance executives
The first experiment ran at a management conference. Twenty-five pairs of financial services executives, 50 people in all, joined a session without knowing it was an experiment. Each person read four deep questions, including “For what in your life do you feel most grateful?” and “Can you describe a time you cried in front of another person?” They predicted how the talk would go, talked with someone they hadn’t met for about 10 minutes, and then rated how it went on the same scales.
The talks went better than predicted. The executives had overestimated how awkward they’d feel, and they had underestimated how connected and how happy they’d feel. They had also underestimated how interested their partner would be in their answers. That wrong guess about the partner helped explain the gap in awkwardness and connectedness (Kardas et al. 2021).
A second experiment repeated this with 50 pairs of managers and employees at a large financial services firm. The pattern held. Participants again underestimated how much their partner would care about what they said and how interested the partner would be. After the first session, the executives also reported that they wished they had more deep conversations with strangers than they do, and that wish was stronger than the wish for more small talk.
Why coworkers are hard to predict
A later experiment in the same paper explains where the forecast goes wrong. The researchers recruited 200 pairs in public parks. Some pairs were strangers. Others were friends, partners or family members visiting the park together. People predicted their conversations more accurately with close others, whose care was already known, than with strangers (Kardas et al. 2021).
Coworkers can sit between those two groups. You see them every day, but you may not know how they’d react to something personal. By the paper’s logic, that unclear care is where the forecast drifts low. This is an inference: the study paired strangers and close others, and only 2% of the close-other group were colleagues. The authors also name their limits. Each finding comes from a single conversation, measured right after it, in the United States.
The part of the risk that’s real
Deep talk at work carries a cost that a talk with a stranger at a park doesn’t. The people at the table will review your code, approve your leave and sit in your next planning meeting. Kerry Roberts Gibson, Dana Harari and Jennifer Carson Marr tested one version of that cost in three lab experiments. When a higher-status coworker disclosed a weakness during a shared task, the receiver saw them as lower in status. The discloser then had less influence, there was more task conflict, and the working relationship was rated lower. Peers who disclosed the same weakness didn’t trigger these effects (Gibson et al. 2018).
The authors also note a limit and an exception. Their participants had no chance to answer the disclosure with one of their own, which might have changed the result. And a team lead might choose to disclose a weakness on purpose, to draw quieter members into the work. For a deep round at work, the practical reading is narrower: depth and confession are two different things. A person can talk about what a word means to them without telling the room about a weakness, a diagnosis or a family problem. The risk stays low when the speaker sets the depth.
Five ways to keep the real risk small
The steps below come in the order you’d use them in a round.
- Agree how passing works. The Thesis rules open with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” At work, a pass costs nothing and needs no reason. Say it before the first turn.
- Use a word as the topic. A word gives each person room to choose a story, a value or an object. A personal question points at one slot of someone’s life. A word lets them pick the slot.
- Offer a second side. Each Thesis card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other. The thing side lets anyone take part without talking about their own life.
- Go first with a value, and skip the confession. If you lead the team, talk about what the word means to you, or a choice it reminds you of. Given the status finding above, a weakness is the riskiest thing to open with.
- Name where the talk stays. The rule card says: “What is said at the table stays at the table.” Say it out loud, and keep it out of the next one-on-one.
Ten questions that stay on the safe side
The questions below go past weekend plans and give no slot for health, money or family details. Each one works at any depth:
- What made you say yes to this job?
- What’s a piece of work you’re still proud of?
- What’s something you learned the slow way?
- Who taught you the most about doing your job?
- What does a good workday look like for you?
- What’s a decision you’d make the same way again?
- What’s a skill you’d like to have in five years?
- What’s an object on your desk that has a story?
- When do you feel most like part of a team?
- What’s something you changed your mind about?
Three words for a team round
Each of these ideas has a work reading and a less obvious one.
Work has Stone on its back. On a team, Work can bring up a first job, a parent’s trade, or the moment someone knew which work they wanted. The Stone side gives an easy way out: a stone from a beach, a paperweight, the weight of a long week.
Success has Notebook on its back. Answers can show what each person counts as done: a launch, a calm sprint, a skill finally learned. The notebook side lets someone talk about how they keep track of work.
Belonging has Headphones on its back. It’s the deepest of the three. Someone might talk about the first team where they felt at home. Someone else might pick headphones and describe what they listen to when they need to focus.
Running it as a card round
With the deck or the online table, each turn follows the same steps. Draw a card, choose the idea or the thing, roll the die and look at the word from that side. The die has six plain words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” The others ask short questions, and then the die goes to the left. The rule card gives three examples: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? It also says: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”
For your next team lunch, pick one of the three words above and write it on a sticky note. Answer it yourself first, with a value, and let the rest of the table decide how deep to go. For the research on the awkwardness itself, see why deep conversations feel awkward. For more on running it at work, see Thesis for teams and classes. For the sources behind the deck, see the research page. See the rules and the box. Related: how to have deep conversations where both people talk.