Trust at work: how to talk about it with your team

A report has a capable, fair manager and still holds back in every one-on-one. Someone else gave softened feedback once and was ignored for a while afterward. Both stories are about trust at work. This guide is for team leads who want to talk about trust with their team in a regular meeting, with no workshop and no exercises. It covers what research links to trust in teams, two kinds of trust worth telling apart, and a short round built around one word. A word on a sticky note is enough, and the free online table covers the rest.

Trust inside a team goes with better team results. De Jong, Dirks and Gillespie combined 112 studies covering 7,763 teams. Trust between team members was positively linked to team performance, and the link held after accounting for trust in the leader and the team’s past performance (De Jong et al. 2016). The strength of the link depended on how the team was set up: how much members depend on each other’s work, how flat the hierarchy is, and how different their skills are. It’s a link across many teams, so it shows a pattern and not a recipe.

A related idea is team psychological safety. Edmondson defined it as “a shared belief held by members of a team that the team is safe for interpersonal risk taking.” In 51 work teams at a manufacturing company, it went with more learning behavior in the team, and learning behavior in turn went with team performance (Edmondson 1999). Trust is about one colleague and another. Safety is about the whole room. A team can have the first between pairs and still lack the second in meetings.

Two kinds of trust a team runs on

The meta-analysis found the link for both kinds of trust the studies measured: cognitive and affective. In plain terms, cognitive trust is “I can rely on your work.” Affective trust is “I think you care what happens to me.” Telling them apart helps a team lead pick the next step.

Cognitive trust rests on a track record. Deadlines met, code that runs, a handover that covers the edge cases. A conversation can name what’s missing, but the record itself gets built in the work. Affective trust leans on what people know about each other beyond the task. A short round can help there, because it gives people a reason to hear how a colleague thinks.

The gap shows when one kind is thin. A team with strong cognitive trust and little affective trust can meet every deadline and still stay quiet about problems. A team with the reverse can get along well and still double-check each other’s work. Naming which one is thin is a useful first step.

Why start with a word instead of a direct question

Asking “Do you trust each other?” in a meeting puts people in a bind. Saying “no” in front of the manager can feel like a risk. Saying “yes” ends the conversation.

A word opens the topic from the side. When the word Trust comes up on a card, nobody has to raise the topic, and nobody has to rate anyone. Each person talks about what trust means to them, from wherever they choose to start. Colleagues hear what earns someone’s trust and what loses it, and nobody in the room gets named.

A short round about Trust

The round below works with 2–6 people and fits at the start of a team meeting or a retro. For a bigger team, split into groups of that size.

  1. Say why. One sentence: “We work closely, and I’d like to hear how each of us thinks about trust.”
  2. Agree on passing. The Thesis rules open with this line: “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” At work, anyone can pass with no reason given, and the manager says so.
  3. Name the confidentiality line. The rule card says: “What is said at the table stays at the table.” Say it out loud before the first turn.
  4. Go first, briefly. Take the Trust card yourself and keep your answer to two or three sentences.
  5. One word per person. Each person takes one of the three cards below and picks a side: the idea or the thing.
  6. Close. Each person names one thing they heard that surprised them.

The rule card also covers depth: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.” In a round about trust, a short answer can be the honest one.

Three cards for a team talking about trust

Each Thesis card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other. The thing side gives anyone who’d rather stay light an easy way in.

Trust
Window
Card 34: Trust / Window. Tap to turn it over.

Trust has Window on its back. On a team, Trust can bring up moments: the first time someone handed over a project and didn’t check on it, or the manager who backed someone in a meeting. Window gives a lighter route. Someone might describe the view from their desk, or what they can and can’t see of the team’s work from where they sit.

Honesty
Radio
Card 14: Honesty / Radio. Tap to turn it over.

Honesty has Radio on its back. It fits teams where feedback is the sore spot, because people may talk about the last time honesty cost them something, or paid off. The radio side can lead to how news travels on a team, or who hears things first.

Loyalty
Camera
Card 48: Loyalty / Camera. Tap to turn it over.

Loyalty has Camera on its back. On a team, Loyalty brings up who people feel loyal to: the team, the manager, a former colleague, the customer. Those answers say a lot about trust without using the word. The camera side can lead to a photo from a team trip, or what someone would keep a record of.

Questions about trust for a team

The questions below work at any depth and don’t ask anyone to judge a colleague:

  1. What’s something a colleague did that made you trust them?
  2. How long does it usually take you to trust a new teammate?
  3. What makes you trust a piece of work without checking it?
  4. What’s a small thing that makes you trust someone less?
  5. When did someone trust you with something before you felt ready?
  6. What helps you bring a problem to a manager early?
  7. How do you show someone you trust them at work?
  8. What did a past team do that made trust easier?
  9. What makes feedback feel safe to give?
  10. What’s something you’d like this team to trust you with?

Running it as a card round

With the deck or the online table, each turn follows the same steps. Draw a card, choose the idea or the thing, roll the die and look at the word from that side. The die has six plain words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” The rule card gives three example follow-up questions: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? The rules add one line that suits this topic: “There are no right answers.”

Roll the die

What to do after the round

A round about trust shows where it’s thin. The rebuilding happens in the work. If people named reliability, agree on one handover or deadline habit and check on it in two weeks. If people named feeling heard, add a short opener to your weekly meeting; check-in questions for team meetings has a list. For a longer talk that goes past the meeting, see deep conversations at work.

The three cards have their own pages: Trust, Honesty, and Loyalty. For more on running it at work, see Thesis for teams and classes. For the studies behind the deck, see the research. See the rules and the box. Related: honest feedback at work: how to say it and keep the team.