Two friends run the same race every spring and text each other their times before they text anyone else. A group plays cards every Friday, and one of them still brings up a game he lost months ago. A pair of old school friends compare salaries, kids’ grades and marathon splits, and laugh about it, mostly. That’s a competitive friendship. The score is part of how they stay close.
This guide is for friends who compete and like it, and for the moments when it stops being funny. It covers what rivalry does for people, where it stings, and a short round to talk about it with one word: Competition. You can play it with the Thesis deck, on the free online table, or with the word written on a napkin.
What a rival does for you
A rival is someone you’ve raced before and expect to race again. In one study of long-distance running, runners were faster in races that included their rivals, identified from similar demographics and earlier races against each other. Two further studies of adults found that rivalry was linked to more motivation and better performance than competition against someone who wasn’t a rival (Kilduff 2014).
Between friends, it can look like this. The friend who beat you last time is the reason you train on a rainy Tuesday. The bet you lost is the story you both retell. A rivalry is a shared history, and friends can have plenty of that.
Comparison moves people even without a friendship. In a trial with 790 university students, some were placed in six-person networks and saw how their activity ranked against anonymous peers. Attendance at exercise classes in the two conditions with comparison was 90% higher than in the two without it (Zhang et al. 2016). The peers there were anonymous. Between friends, the ranking comes with a name, a face and a history, which can make it stronger in both directions.
Where it stings
Competition between friends works while both people know they’re playing. It stings when one of them stops playing and the other doesn’t notice. These signs can show it:
- The joke lands once too often. That old loss gets mentioned at every game night, and the person who lost has stopped laughing.
- The game moves to real life. A running bet turns into comparing jobs, homes or partners, and only one side signed up for that.
- Winning gets quieter. Someone hides good news, a promotion or a fast time, because they know how the other will react.
- One person sets the rules. The friend who cares most about winning picks the game, keeps the score and decides what counts.
None of these means the friendship is in trouble. Each one means the two of you are playing by different rules and haven’t said so. The obvious advice is to talk about it, and it can get skipped for a plain reason. Saying “this bothers me” in the middle of a rivalry feels like losing.
Talk about it on a neutral night
A game night is a good place for this talk, as long as the game isn’t the one that causes the friction. A word card gives everyone the same starting point, and nobody wins the round.
The Thesis deck has 50 double-sided cards, an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other, and a die you fold from a card into a six-sided prism. 2–6 players. Before the first card, agree on passing. The rules open with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” A pass, or turning the card to its other side, keeps it light for anyone who’d rather not go there tonight.
A turn has six steps, from the rule card:
- Whoever suggested the game goes first.
- Draw a card. Choose a side: the idea or the thing.
- Roll the die.
- Look at the word from that side. Say as much or as little as feels right.
- The others ask what they’re curious about, gently, without judging.
- Hand the die to the left.
The die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. Look at the word from that side. One roll can take Competition back to a school sports day, to the person at the table you most like beating, or to what you’d want it to look like years from now.
There’s one more line on the rule card worth reading aloud before you start: “There are no right answers.” For a group that keeps score on everything, that’s the point of the round.
Three cards for competitive friends
Each of these three cards reads in its own way for friends who keep score.
Competition has Bench on its other side. The idea side gets straight to it: who taught you to want to win, and when it stopped being fun. The bench side works for anyone who’d rather come at it sideways. Benches are where substitutes wait, where teams sit before a match, and where two friends sit after one.
Play has Laptop on its other side. Rivals can forget the game was supposed to be play. This card asks what playing felt like before anyone kept score. The laptop side brings up late-night online matches, group chats and the screen where the scoreboard now lives.
Fairness has Sweater on its other side. It suits the friend who argues every rule, and the one who feels the rules favor someone else. Hearing how each person at the table learned what’s fair can explain the arguments. The sweater side goes to hand-me-downs, and to who got the new one first.
Questions about competing with friends
If you’d rather talk without cards, these questions work on a walk, at a bar or after a match. They run from light to deeper:
- What’s the first thing you remember wanting to win?
- Which friend do you most like beating, and why that one?
- What’s a loss you still think about?
- When did a game between us stop being a game?
- What do you do when you’re losing and nobody else can tell?
- Is there something you’ve won and kept quiet about?
- Who in your family made winning matter?
- What would you want our rivalry to look like at 70?
Pick two or three. The rule card’s follow-ups keep any answer going: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?
End the night with the last round
When you’re done, finish the way every game of Thesis ends: “When the group is ready to stop, finish with one last round: each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” For competitive friends, it’s the only round of the night with no score.
Next game night, put the Competition card on the table after the usual game. See the rules and the box, or open the online table. The words above have their own pages: Competition, Play and Fairness. For more on playing with a group, see Thesis for friends. For the studies behind the deck, see the research. If the rivalry is a sign you’ve moved in different directions, see outgrowing friends.