Conversation questions about luck and chance

Someone at the table says “I was lucky,” and the talk moves on. The story behind that line can be the best one of the evening: the missed train, the friend of a friend, the job that came through a wrong email address. Luck is a light word with long stories attached.

This page gives friends twelve questions about luck and chance, in three groups that go from easy to personal. It adds two studies that make good talking points and one Thesis card to put on the table. A word written on a napkin works as well.

Start with the event, then the meaning

Questions about luck go further when they ask for a moment first. “Do you believe in luck?” gets a yes or a no. “Tell us about a time you were lucky” gets a place, a year and a person. Once a few stories are out, the bigger question comes up by itself: was it luck, or something else?

That order also keeps the talk light for longer. A lucky break is quick to tell. The questions about where you were born, or what you got that others didn’t, land better after the table has laughed once.

Twelve questions about luck and chance

The questions below come in three groups. Pick one or two from each group rather than going through all twelve. Anyone can pass, or answer a different question instead.

Moments of luck

  1. Tell us about a time you were lucky in a small way.
  2. What’s the luckiest thing that happened to you before you turned 12?
  3. Is there an object, number or habit you keep for luck?
  4. Who in your family talked most about luck, and what did they say?

Near misses and chance meetings

  1. Tell us about a near miss: something that almost went wrong.
  2. Which person in your life did you meet by chance?
  3. What’s a plan that fell through and turned out better?
  4. When did you come close to something you wanted and miss it?

What luck means to you

  1. Which part of your life do you think of as luck, and which part as work?
  2. What did you get by luck that someone else at this table didn’t?
  3. When did you call something bad luck that was a choice?
  4. Has your idea of luck changed since you were a teenager?

Question 6 can start long stories. Question 10 asks the most of a group, so it works later in the evening, once a few stories are out.

Two studies to bring to the table

Chance meetings have a place in psychology. Albert Bandura argued that chance encounters play a large part in the paths people’s lives take. He described an encounter as two chains of events, each with its own causes, that cross by accident. Some of those meetings have only minor effects. Others last and send a life in a new direction (Bandura 1982). Question 6 is that idea in a single line: the friend, partner or boss you met by chance.

Near misses change how a result feels. Victoria Medvec, Scott Madey and Thomas Gilovich looked at bronze and silver medalists at the 1992 Summer Olympics. Bronze medalists looked happier than silver medalists, both right after their events and on the medal stand. The authors explain it by what each athlete could picture instead: silver can picture gold, bronze can picture no medal at all (Medvec et al. 1995). Questions 5 and 8 ask about the same two kinds of moment. One is the bad outcome that almost happened. The other is the good one that almost did.

Both studies make good openers on their own. Tell the medal result, then ask the table who they’d rather have been, and why.

One card for the evening

A single word gives each person room to choose their own angle on luck. Thesis has 50 double-sided cards: an idea on one side, an everyday thing on the other.

Luck
Passport
Card 07: Luck / Passport. Tap to turn it over.

Luck has a Passport on its other side. Luck brings up the lucky breaks from the list above. The Passport side brings up trips, borders and the country printed on the cover. For some players that’s a holiday story. For others it’s a visa queue, or a country they had to leave. Say before the round that either side can be chosen and the card can be passed. The person who takes Passport decides how far the story goes.

The deck also has a die with six words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. Look at the word from that side. Rolling CHILDHOOD with Luck gives a different story than rolling FUTURE, and both are easy to tell.

How to play it at the table

Two to six people around a table after dinner is enough. You can use the cards, the free table online, or one word on a piece of paper.

Roll the die

The Thesis rules start with one agreement: “Before you start, decide together how passing works.” Then the turns go like this:

  1. Draw a card. Pick a side: the idea or the thing.
  2. Roll the die. Look at the word from that side.
  3. Say as much or as little as you like. The others ask, gently.
  4. Hand the die to the left.

The rule card gives three follow-up questions: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? For luck, Who else was there? does a lot. A lucky break can have a second person in it: the stranger who held the door, the teacher who passed on a name.

“There are no right answers.” That line suits luck well, because the table may split. Some players say you make your own luck. Others point to the family and the place they were born into. Both answers can sit next to each other.

Two more words close to luck

Luck pulls in other words from the deck. Two of them move the talk toward the parts people argue about.

Competition
Bench
Card 35: Competition / Bench. Tap to turn it over.

Competition has a Bench on its other side. It fits the medal study: who won, who came second, and how much of it was the bounce of the ball. The Bench side brings up the player who waited to be picked, and whether getting picked came down to chance.

Fairness
Sweater
Card 39: Fairness / Sweater. Tap to turn it over.

Fairness pairs with Sweater. It follows question 10. If some of what you have came by chance, the next question is whether that’s fair. The Sweater side is gentler: a hand-me-down, a gift, a thing that came to you from someone else. If the word feels too close, choose the other side, or pass.

What to try tonight

Write the word Luck on a piece of paper. Ask question 6 first, and let each person tell one chance meeting. Then ask the follow-up Who else was there? and see where the second person in each story leads.

When you stop, end the way a game of Thesis ends: each player names one thing they discovered about someone today. “Sometimes one word is enough.”

See the rules and the box, or open the free online table. The cards above have their own pages: Luck, Competition and Fairness. For an evening with a few close people, see Thesis for friends. For more on the studies behind the deck, see the research page. For a conversation about winning and losing, see is competition healthy?