You put a question to the group on a Thursday evening. Some look at their phones, someone says “this is so cringe”, and the rest wait for it to be over. The question was fine. The setup made it a lesson: an adult asks, everyone answers in order, and someone seems to be checking for the right answer. This post gives youth workers 12 discussion questions for older teens (16–19) and a session plan around them. The plan puts the adult at the table as a player, gives every turn a way out, and makes a one-sentence answer count.
The plan works with questions on slips of paper. The examples also use the Thesis card deck, which is rated 16+ and built for 2–6 players.
What makes a question session feel like class
Older teens spend school days in rooms where adults ask questions and grade the answers. A session that copies that pattern can get the same response: short answers, eye contact with the floor, and the confident few doing the talking. The trigger may not be the question itself. It’s the shape around it.
These signals can read as school, and each one has a swap:
- The adult only asks. Sit in the circle and take a turn like everyone else.
- Everyone answers in order. Agree on a pass before the first turn.
- Answers are written down. Keep paper for the prompts only.
- There’s a right answer. Use prompts about the speaker’s own life, where nobody else knows the answer.
- Long answers win. Say out loud that one sentence is a full turn.
There’s also a reason teens hold back that has little to do with the format. In a series of experiments, deep conversations with strangers felt less awkward than participants expected, and participants expected others to care less about their disclosures than the others did (Kardas et al. 2021). Those studies were run with adults, so treat them as a lead for teens, not proof. The point for a session is practical: people can guess the room won’t be interested, and the first few turns are where that guess changes.
It’s also a group that may be short on these conversations. The WHO reports that young people, especially adolescents, have the highest loneliness rates, with 21% of adolescents saying they’re lonely (WHO). A youth club evening is a place where they can talk with peers outside a classroom.
A session plan in four parts
The plan has four parts in the order you run them. The rules are written for 2–6 players, so with a bigger group, split into two tables and move between them.
1. The agreement. Before the first turn, agree together how passing works. The Thesis rule card opens with that line: “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” Let the group decide the details: whether a reason is needed, whether the turn comes back later, whether someone can swap the prompt. Then say what you’d have to pass on under your safeguarding policy. The rule card says “What is said at the table stays at the table.” With young people, that line sits under your organization’s policy, and saying so at the start avoids a broken promise later.
2. The object round. Start with everyday things before ideas. Every Thesis card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other, such as Coin, Mug, or Headphones. A turn on headphones is easy to take and still says something about the speaker. Go first yourself. In Thesis, “Whoever suggested the game goes first,” and in a youth session that can be you.
3. Word or question rounds. Move to the idea side, or to the questions below. Each player draws, chooses a side, and talks for as long as they like. The rule card leaves the length open: “Play for as long as it feels good.” “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.” The others can ask follow-ups, such as the three on the rule card: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?
4. The last round. End before energy drops. When the group is ready to stop, the Thesis rules close with “each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” A young person who passed every turn can still take part, because the round is about what they heard.
12 discussion questions for older teens
These questions are about the speaker’s own life, so there’s no right answer to look for. They lean toward the topics 16–19-year-olds are living through: leaving home, work, friends, and who they are becoming. Write them on slips, fold them, and let players draw.
- What’s something you’re better at than people assume?
- Which rule from home would you keep in your own place?
- What song would sum up your last year?
- What’s something an adult told you that turned out to be true?
- Where do you feel most like yourself?
- What did you believe at 12 that you don’t believe now?
- Who do you go to when something’s off, and why them?
- What’s one thing you want to have done by 25?
- What question do people your age get asked too often?
- What’s a small thing that makes a day good?
- What would you change about how adults talk to you?
- What’s something you’ve started doing for yourself this year?
Questions 9 and 11 can land well with groups that roll their eyes at the rest. They invite a complaint, and a complaint is an easy first turn.
Three cards that suit this age
A single word can do the work of a question with less pressure. The player picks the angle, so nobody has to answer what an adult chose to ask. These three cards from the deck fit the 16–19 range.
Adulthood sits on the back of Coin. At 16–19 the word is close to home: a first job, a first rent payment, being treated as an adult by some people and as a kid by others. A player who’d rather not go there can talk about a coin they kept, or the first money they earned.
Belonging is on the back of Headphones. It suits a group where some members are new or on the edge. Headphones are an easy object for this age: what’s playing, when they go on, and who they keep out. The idea side can open a talk about where a person feels they fit, at the pace they choose.
Independence is on the back of Mug. It can bring up the first things done alone: a trip, a meal, a decision made without asking. The mug side can lead to a story about a kitchen, a parent’s morning routine, or a first apartment.
Running it with the die
The Thesis die adds one more choice to each turn. It has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” A player who rolls a side they don’t want can pass on it like any other prompt.
The deck is 16+ because some words, such as Death and Betrayal, go further than a younger group might. Each of those sensitive words has an everyday thing on its other side, and the pass agreement covers them. You know your group and its context, and you decide which cards stay in the pile.
If you don’t have the box, the online table runs the same game on a shared screen or a phone in the middle of the table.
Try it at your next session
Before your next session, write the 12 questions on slips and fold them into a cup. Open with the agreement, go first with the most ordinary answer you can give, and stop after the last round, even if the group would keep going. Ending while it’s still easy can make the next session easier to start.
For more on running a game in a group setting, see Thesis for therapy groups. If loss comes up in your group, grief support group discussion questions has prompts for that. The three cards above have their own pages: Adulthood, Belonging, and Independence. You can play online for free, see the rules and the box, or read the research behind the deck.