ESL questions about honesty and lies: twelve for adult classes

Honesty works in an adult English class when the questions ask about lies in general, about other people, and about culture, and leave each student to decide how much of their own life comes in. This page gives you twelve questions sorted by level, the phrases to write on the board, and a lesson plan that starts with white lies and ends with values. You can print the questions, write one word on the board, or put a card on the table.

Phrases to put on the board first

Honesty has a large set of fixed phrases, and students may reach for them as soon as the talk starts. Give them the phrases first, so the effort goes into the opinion.

  • a white lie: a small lie told to be polite (“I love the sweater.”)
  • to tell the truth: to say what happened
  • to be honest: a phrase before an opinion someone may not like
  • to keep a secret: to tell nobody
  • to make an excuse: to give a reason that may be untrue
  • to exaggerate: to make something sound bigger than it was
  • to be caught lying: when someone finds out the truth
  • to come clean: to finally tell the truth about something

Ask which phrases have a direct match in the students’ languages. “To come clean” may not, and “to be honest” can sound rude or friendly depending on where a student comes from. That makes a short discussion before the first question.

Why the questions stay general

A question like “When did you last lie?” asks for a confession, in a second language, in front of classmates. Some students may answer it with a joke and some may go quiet. The questions below ask about lies people tell, about rules in a family or a country, and about stories students choose to share.

Everyday lying has been studied with diaries. In two diary studies by DePaulo and colleagues, 77 college students reported telling about two lies a day and 70 community members about one. Participants described their lies as not serious, and social interactions in which a lie was told were less pleasant and less intimate (DePaulo et al. 1996). Those are self-reports from a small sample, so treat them as a conversation starter. Read the result to a C1 class and ask whether it sounds right for the people they know.

Culture changes which lie counts as good. Lee and colleagues told Chinese and Canadian children aged 7, 9, and 11 short stories in which a child did a good deed. When a teacher asked who had done it, the story child either told the truth or lied. The Chinese children rated the modest lie more positively and the truth less positively than the Canadian children did. The authors linked this to the value placed on modesty in Chinese culture (Lee et al. 1997). In a class with students from several countries, the same story can split the room, and that’s the discussion you want.

A lesson in five steps

The steps below run in the order of the lesson. Fit their length to your class.

  1. Phrases. Put the eight phrases on the board. Students mark the ones they’ve used.
  2. White lies in pairs. Pairs take question 1 or 2. Each partner tells the class the other’s answer in one sentence.
  3. One word. Write “Honesty” on the board, or put the card on the table. Each student picks the idea or the thing.
  4. Small groups. Groups take one level’s questions. Each student picks the question they want to answer.
  5. Last round. Each student names one thing they discovered about a classmate today.

Step 2 opens with white lies because the stakes are low. A gift someone didn’t like or a meal that didn’t taste good gives a B1 student a story with a clear past tense, and nobody has to admit to anything serious.

Twelve questions about honesty and lies

The questions below are grouped by level. Each one has no right answer to check, and students can pass or pick another question.

B1: everyday situations

  1. Have you ever said you liked a gift when you didn’t? What happened?
  2. What do you say when a friend cooks something you don’t like?
  3. What’s an excuse people often make for being late?
  4. Did your parents tell you stories that weren’t true when you were a child?

B2: opinions and experience

  1. Is a white lie ever kinder than the truth? Give an example.
  2. Who’s the most honest person you know, and how do you know?
  3. Is it harder to tell the truth to a friend, a boss, or a stranger?
  4. When is it right to keep a secret, and when is it right to tell?

C1: values and culture

  1. In your country, is it polite to refuse a compliment? Is that a kind of lie?
  2. Should a doctor always tell a patient the whole truth?
  3. Does social media make people more honest or less honest?
  4. Has your idea of honesty changed since you were a teenager?

Question 4 suits a mixed class well: tooth fairies, gift-bringers, and warnings about what happens if you swallow a seed differ by country, and students can bring one from home. Question 9 brings in the modesty finding without naming it. Read the study after the answers, and ask whether it matches what the class said.

Follow-up questions that keep the answer going

A short answer in a second language can be a first draft. The Thesis rule card gives three follow-ups:

What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?

They’re short enough for a B1 student to ask a classmate. For this topic, Has it always meant that to you? fits question 12 and pushes a C1 student from opinion to story. The same rule card says: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.” Read it to the class before the small groups start, so a student who gives one sentence about a secret isn’t pushed for more.

Three cards for this lesson

One word on the table gives students room to choose their own angle. Thesis has 50 double-sided cards: an idea on one side, an everyday thing on the other. The card for this lesson is Honesty, and two others help when the group wants to keep going.

Honesty
Radio
Card 14: Honesty / Radio. Tap to turn it over.

Honesty has Radio on its back. A B1 student can describe a radio: the one in a grandparent’s kitchen, a car radio, a station they listened to while learning English. A C1 student can take Honesty and talk about news, trust in what’s on air, or a time they heard the truth from a stranger. The Radio side gives a student who’d rather not talk about their own lies a full turn of speaking practice.

Trust
Window
Card 34: Trust / Window. Tap to turn it over.

Trust pairs with Window. It’s the next step after honesty: what happens once someone has told the truth, or hasn’t. A window can bring up a story about a neighbor, an open window in summer, or a view from a first apartment abroad.

Privacy
Diary
Card 43: Privacy / Diary. Tap to turn it over.

Privacy sits behind Diary. It gives the class the other side of honesty: the things people keep to themselves without lying. Students can compare what counts as private in their countries, such as salary, age, or religion, and the Diary side works for a student who kept one as a teenager.

For a second angle, the deck has a die with six words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. Look at the word from that side.

Running it online

For an online class, share your screen with the online table and draw a card together. Each student reads the word aloud before answering. “Honesty” starts with a silent h, which gives a quick pronunciation point before the first turn.

Roll the die

Agree at the start what stays in the class. The rule card says: “What is said at the table stays at the table.” For a topic about secrets, that line can decide whether a student tells a real story or an invented one.

Before your next class

Write “Honesty” on the board, with the eight phrases under it. Open with question 1 in pairs, and keep questions 9–12 for the end of the lesson or a second one. The first time a student says “to be honest” in a later lesson, point it out.

See the rules and the box. The three words have their own pages: Honesty, Trust and Privacy. For class and team sessions, see Thesis for teams and classes. For the studies behind the deck, see the research page. For a lesson on goals and setbacks, see ESL questions about success and failure. Related: ESL questions about luck: twelve for adult classes.