Ask an adult class “Are you a lucky person?” and the answers come back as “Yes” or “No,” and the topic is over fast. Luck works better in an ESL lesson when the questions ask for a story or a custom: a lucky number, a near miss, a saying from home. This page gives you twelve questions sorted by level, ten phrases to put on the board, and a short debate for C1 built on two studies. You can print the questions, write one word on the board, or put a card on the table.
Ten phrases for the board
Luck comes with a lot of fixed phrases, and several of them can trip up learners. Write these on the board before any question.
- to be lucky: “I was lucky,” not “I had a luck.”
- luckily: at the start of a sentence (“Luckily, the bus was late too.”)
- by chance: without a plan (“We met by chance.”)
- a coincidence: two things that happen together by chance
- a near miss: something bad that almost happened
- beginner’s luck: a good result the first time you try
- a lucky charm: an object someone carries for luck
- to cross your fingers: to hope for a good result
- knock on wood: said after mentioning something good, so it stays good
- superstitious: believing that certain actions or objects bring luck
Ask students how their language says “knock on wood” and “cross your fingers.” Comparing them is a first conversation before any question.
Why lucky numbers make a good opener
Lucky and unlucky numbers give every student something to report about their own culture without telling a personal story. A number is a fact about a place, and anyone can describe it.
The effect of those beliefs can be measured. Fortin, Hill and Huang studied close to 117,000 house sales in Greater Vancouver between 2000 and 2005. In neighborhoods where the share of Chinese residents was above the area average of 18%, houses with an address ending in 4 sold at a 2.2% discount, and those ending in 8 sold at a 2.5% premium, compared with other addresses. The authors explain why. In Mandarin, Cantonese and several Chinese dialects, the word for four sounds close to the word for death. The word for eight sounds close to the word for wealth (Fortin et al. 2012).
Tell the class that result, then ask which numbers matter where they grew up. Students who say “none” can describe a number in a phone, a birthday or a sports shirt. Customs use the present simple, stories the past simple.
A lesson in five steps
The steps below run in the order of the lesson. Fit each one to your timetable.
- Phrases. Put the ten phrases on the board. Students mark the ones they already use.
- Numbers in pairs. Each partner names a lucky or unlucky number from their country and explains it. Then they tell the class the other’s answer in one sentence.
- One word. Write “Luck” on the board, or put the card on the table. Each student picks the word or the object on its other side.
- Small groups. Each group takes one level’s questions. Each student picks the question they want to answer.
- Last round. Each student names one thing they discovered about a classmate today.
Step 2 is the warm-up: by the time the groups start, each student has spoken once.
Twelve questions about luck
The questions below are grouped by level. Each one asks for a story, a custom or an opinion, so there’s no right answer to check. Students can pass or pick another question.
B1: past events and customs
- What’s a lucky or unlucky number where you grew up?
- Tell us about a time you were lucky.
- Do you have a lucky charm, or did someone in your family have one?
- What do people say in your language before an exam or a game?
B2: chance and choices
- Tell us about a near miss: something bad that almost happened.
- Have you ever had beginner’s luck? What were you trying for the first time?
- Tell us about a coincidence that surprised you.
- Which superstition from your country do you follow, even if you don’t believe it?
C1: opinion and argument
- Do people make their own luck, or does it come from outside?
- Should a house cost less because of its address number?
- Is a successful person mostly lucky or mostly hardworking?
- Can a lucky charm help someone perform better? Why or why not?
Question 8 suits a mixed class. A student who follows a custom they call silly has to explain the gap, and that takes complex language: “I know it’s a superstition, but I still…” Questions 10 and 12 connect to the research on this page, so they work as debate prompts.
A C1 debate: does a lucky charm work?
Two studies on lucky charms give a C1 class a real argument with evidence on both sides. Damisch, Stoberock and Mussweiler ran four experiments. Across them, a good-luck phrase, crossed fingers or a lucky charm went with better results on golf putting, a dexterity task, a memory task and anagrams. Their explanation was confidence: the superstition made people feel more able to do the task (Damisch et al. 2010).
A later team tested the golf task again, twice, with high statistical power. Players told they had a lucky ball putted about as well as players without one (Calin-Jageman and Caldwell 2014). Give half the class the first study and half the second. Each side explains its result in three sentences, then the class discusses why a second study might not find the same thing. The topic brings in the language of evidence: “found,” “suggests,” “couldn’t repeat.”
Follow-up questions that keep the answer going
A one-line answer about luck is a starting point. The rule card in Thesis gives three follow-ups:
What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?
They’re short enough for a B1 student to ask a classmate. For this topic, Has it always meant that to you? works well after a superstition: a student who followed a custom as a child may see it differently now. The same rule card says: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.” Read that line to the class before the small groups start.
Three cards for a luck lesson
A single word gives each student room to choose an angle. Thesis has 50 double-sided cards: an idea on one side, an everyday thing on the other. One card carries this lesson, and two more help when the group wants to keep going.
Luck has a Passport on its other side. In a class of adults who’ve moved countries, a passport can bring up travel stories, and it can also bring up visas, waiting and paperwork. Say before the round that either side can be chosen and the card can be passed. A student who takes Luck can stay with numbers and charms. A student who takes Passport decides how far the story goes.
Success pairs with Notebook. It fits question 11: was a good result luck or work? A B1 student can take the notebook and describe the one they keep for English.
Hope sits behind Teddy bear. It’s the word behind “cross your fingers” and “knock on wood.” A teddy bear can also be a lucky charm, which makes it an easy B1 story about childhood.
For a second angle, the deck has a die with six words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. Look at the word from that side.
Running it online
For an online class, share your screen with the online table and draw a card together. Each student reads the word aloud before answering.
Agree at the start what stays in the class. The rule card in Thesis says: “What is said at the table stays at the table.” For an adult class with a mix of countries and histories, that line helps a student decide how much to say.
Before your next class
Write the ten phrases on the board and add one number from your own life. Open with question 1 in pairs, and end with the last round. Keep the debate for a C1 group or a second lesson.
See the rules and the box. The three words have their own pages: Luck, Success and Hope. For class and team sessions, see Thesis for teams and classes. For the studies behind the deck, see the research page. For a lesson on effort and setbacks, see ESL questions about success and failure. For a lesson on hours and rest, see ESL questions about work-life balance. Related: ESL questions about honesty and lies: twelve for adult classes.