You moved to Berlin, or Lisbon, or Amsterdam, because you wanted room. Nobody here knows your school grades or your ex. A few years later you fly home for a wedding, and there you feel like a guest too. Freedom came with the move. Belonging stayed behind, and it doesn’t fit in the suitcase.
This post is for people who left a country by choice and now feel they belong nowhere in particular. It names what each side of the trade-off costs, what research says about the two needs, and how to talk it through with one person you trust. You can do that with the Thesis deck, the free online table, or two words on a napkin.
The short answer
Freedom and belonging are both needs, and a move abroad changes the balance between them overnight. At home, belonging was given: family, school friends, a language you didn’t have to think about. Freedom was the part you had to fight for. Abroad, the roles swap. Freedom is the default, and belonging is the part that takes work.
That swap can explain a feeling some people who move describe. Writers in expat communities describe feeling that they no longer fully belong in the new country, and then noticing the same thing on a visit home. Some describe a long search for a place to call home and a slow acceptance that the search may not end. The feeling is a cost of the trade, and the trade can be renegotiated.
Why both sides pull
Two lines of research treat both sides as basic needs. Richard Ryan and Edward Deci proposed three innate psychological needs: competence, autonomy, and relatedness. In their account, motivation and well-being rise when these needs are met and fall when they’re thwarted (Ryan and Deci 2000). Autonomy is close to what people mean by freedom. Relatedness is close to belonging.
Roy Baumeister and Mark Leary reviewed evidence for a need to belong. They describe it as a need for frequent, nonaversive contact inside an ongoing bond. They found that people form attachments readily and resist losing them, and that a lack of attachments is linked to ill effects on health, adjustment, and well-being (Baumeister and Leary 1995). The definition has two parts: frequent contact and an ongoing bond. A move can keep the bond with old friends and remove the frequent contact.
Small contact counts
Belonging in a new city can start smaller than friendship. Gillian Sandstrom and Elizabeth Dunn studied weak ties, the acquaintances at the edge of a social life. In one study, students reported more happiness and a stronger sense of belonging on days they interacted with more classmates than usual. Two further studies covered all daily interactions and found that weak ties also related to social and emotional well-being (Sandstrom and Dunn 2014).
For someone abroad, weak ties are the baker who knows your order, the neighbor with the dog, a colleague you eat lunch with on Thursdays. They cost little freedom. Nobody expects you at a family dinner. They still add some of the frequent contact that the move took away.
What each side costs
Each side of the trade has a price, and naming the price makes the choice easier to talk about. These lines come from the situations people describe after a move:
- Freedom costs witnesses. Fewer people saw you as a teenager, so fewer people can tell you how much you’ve changed.
- Freedom costs defaults. Nobody invites you by habit, so every plan is one you make.
- Belonging costs choices. Family and old friends expect you at events you’d skip if you could.
- Belonging costs edits. A group you belong to has a picture of you, and changing the picture takes effort.
Read the list and notice which line stings most. That line shows which side you’re short on right now. The answer can change after a breakup or a second move.
Ten questions to talk it through
These questions suit a talk with one person who also moved, or one who stayed. Answer with a story where you can: a place, a year, a person.
- What did you want to get away from when you left?
- When did you first feel free in the new city?
- Who would you call in the middle of the night here, and who back home?
- Where do you feel like a guest now?
- Which friendship has lasted across the distance, and what keeps it going?
- What does your family expect from you that the new city doesn’t?
- Which small daily contact would you miss if it stopped?
- When did you last feel you belonged somewhere, even for one evening?
- What would you give up to belong more, and what wouldn’t you?
- Where do you picture yourself in ten years, and who’s there?
Words that repeat across your answers are worth a second look. A name or a place that comes up more than once is part of where you belong.
Three cards for the trade-off
The deck has both words, and they sit on separate cards. Playing them one after the other shows the trade-off from both ends. A third card, Home, sits between them.
Freedom has a Compass on its other side. Choose the idea when you want to talk about why you left and what you gained. Choose the Compass when a story is easier: a first trip, a map, a time you got lost and liked it. The Compass reads as direction, and for someone who moved, direction is the part of freedom that’s easiest to tell.
Belonging has Headphones on its other side. Choose the idea for the people and places where you feel part of something. Choose the Headphones for a quieter way in: music from home on a commute, a podcast in your first language, a playlist from a summer before the move. Headphones can shut a city out or bring home into it, and both stories say something about belonging.
Home has a Spoon on its other side. After Freedom and Belonging, Home is a way to talk about where the two meet. A player might name a city, a person, or a kitchen. The Spoon side can bring up a dish someone cooked, and who used to cook it.
Look at the word from six sides
The Thesis die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” Roll it with Freedom, then roll it with Belonging. The same face gives two stories that answer each other, and the gap between them is the trade-off in your own words.
Try it with someone
A trade-off said out loud is easier to weigh. Another person hears which side you talk about with more warmth, and which side you keep explaining. A video call across two countries works.
Before you start, agree how passing works. The Thesis rules open with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” Then take turns:
- Whoever suggested the game goes first.
- Draw a card. Choose a side: the idea or the thing.
- Roll the die.
- Look at the word from that side. Say as much or as little as feels right.
- The others ask what they’re curious about, gently, without judging.
- Hand the die to the left.
The rule card gives three follow-up questions: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? For people who moved, the third one does the most work. Freedom at 20 and freedom at 35 can be different words.
“Every view is welcome, especially one that differs from yours.” That line helps when one player left and the other stayed. Neither choice is the right one, and the table has room for both.
What to do this week
Write Freedom and Belonging on two scraps of paper. Pick the one that stings more right now, and one question from the list. Tell one story to someone who knows you from before the move, and one to someone who knows you from after. Then add one weak tie: say a few words to the person you see every week and never talk to.
When you play, end the way every game of Thesis ends: each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today. “Sometimes one word is enough.”
See the rules and the box, or open the free online table. The cards above have their own pages: Freedom, Belonging and Home. For playing with a few close people, see Thesis for friends. For the studies behind the deck, see the research page. For a team spread across countries, see how to get to know your remote team.