Your group chat used to be one conversation. Now one friend posts a sonogram, one posts a job title, one posts an apartment in another country, and one hasn’t posted in weeks. When you meet, the talk splits into updates: the baby’s sleep, the new team, the visa. Everyone listens politely, and nobody quite knows what to ask the person whose life looks nothing like theirs.
This guide is for old friends at different life stages who still want to hear how each other’s lives feel from the inside. It uses one word, Success, and one question under it: whose definition is this? You can play it with the Thesis deck, on the free online table, or with the word written on a napkin.
Why the paths split in adulthood
A meta-analysis of 277 studies with 177,635 participants found that friendship networks shrink across adulthood, and that events tied to certain ages, such as becoming a parent or starting a job, bring network changes too (Wrzus et al. 2013). Those events don’t arrive for everyone in the same year. One friend’s thirties are diapers, another’s are night shifts, a third’s are a second degree.
The split can be quiet. Nobody announces that the friendship has changed. You notice it in the small things: the dinner that now ends early, the story that needs too much background, the advice that doesn’t fit your life.
Where success comes in
Success is the word under updates like these. A promotion reads as success. So does a wedding, a house, a child, a sober year, a business that broke even, or a quiet life with free weekends. Each friend measures with a different ruler, and each ruler came from somewhere: parents, a first boss, a city, a hard year.
When those rulers stay hidden, updates start to feel like a scoreboard. The friend with the baby hears the travel story as a judgment. The friend who travels hears the baby news as one. Neither said anything of the kind. Talking about the ruler itself, instead of the results, can take the scoreboard off the table.
That’s the turn this format makes. It asks what “doing well” means to each person at the table, and where they learned it.
One word, six angles
The Thesis die has six faces, each a plain word: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.”
For friends on different paths, the angles do something useful. They move the talk away from this year’s news. A friend who’s tired of being asked about the baby can look at the word from another side. The word stays the same, and each person brings their own version.
Without a die, write the six words on a scrap of paper and pick one each round.
Setting it up
The format fits a long dinner, a walk, or a video call with a friend in another time zone. It takes four things, and the deck is optional:
- Players. 2–6. Two old friends on a call is a full game.
- The deck. 50 double-sided cards, an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other.
- The die. You fold it from a card into a six-sided prism and roll it like a pencil.
- No deck. Open the online table on a shared screen. It draws, flips, and rolls.
Agree on passing first. The rules say: “Before you start, decide together how passing works.” For friends in different places, this matters. Someone going through IVF, a layoff, or a breakup may not want to talk about Success that night. A pass without a reason, or turning the card to its other side, keeps the evening open for them.
One round
A round takes four steps from the rules:
- Draw a card. Pick a side: the idea or the thing.
- Roll the die. Look at the word from that side.
- Say as much or as little as you like. The others ask, gently.
- Hand the die to the left.
The follow-up questions help here. Three from the rule card fit every word: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? The third one is made for this topic. When a friend’s idea of success has changed, the change can be the story.
Questions about success for friends on different paths
If you’d rather start with questions, these work for friends whose lives have gone different ways. They move from light to deeper:
- What did success look like to you at 12?
- Who in your family had the clearest idea of it?
- What’s something you were proud of this year that nobody saw?
- What did you think your life would look like at this age?
- What part of that picture do you still want?
- Which of my choices do you understand least?
- What does a good ordinary Tuesday look like for you now?
- When did you last feel like you were behind?
- What would you count as success in five years?
- What do you miss from the years when our lives looked the same?
Question 6 needs care. Ask it only if the group agreed on passing, and take the answer as one person’s view of your life.
Three cards for friends on different paths
Each of these cards reads in its own way when lives have diverged.
Success has Notebook on its other side. On the idea side, friends at different life stages can give answers that surprise each other, and the question “whose definition is this?” fits every roll. The notebook side is the gentler way in: school notebooks with grades in them, a planner from a first job, a notebook where someone wrote plans that changed. It gets to success without anyone listing what they have.
Adulthood has Coin on its other side. Friends can hit the markers of adulthood in a different order, so this card brings out the moment each person felt grown up, which can differ from the moment on paper. The coin side opens money talk sideways: pocket money, a first wage, a coin kept for luck.
Enough has Photograph on its other side. It’s the counterweight to Success. Asking a friend when they have enough can say more about their life than asking what they’ve achieved. The photograph side works for old friends in particular: a photo from the years when you all lived in the same city, and what each of you remembers outside the frame.
After the game: reach out first
For friends on different paths, the gap between meetings can be the hard part. In preregistered experiments, people underestimated how much others appreciate being reached out to, and the gap was larger between people who were more socially distant (Liu et al. 2023). A friend whose life now looks far from yours may be glad to hear from you, more than you expect.
One way to use that: after the evening, send the friend one line about something they said about success. “I keep thinking about your Tuesday answer” is enough to restart the thread.
What is said at the table stays there, so keep the message between the two of you.
Next time the group meets, bring one word. See the rules and the box, or play on the online table. The cards above have their own pages: Success, Adulthood, and Enough. For more on playing with a group, see Thesis for friends. For the studies behind the deck, see the research. If the different paths have made it harder to say no to plans or favors, see boundaries with friends. Related: jealous of friends’ success: when their news drains you.