The chairs are in a circle and you ask who’d like to start. The men look at the floor. One says his week was fine. Later, the same men are stacking those chairs, and one of them mentions, while carrying a stack, that his brother hasn’t called in a while. The talk you hoped for happened. It happened beside a task, with nobody looking at him.
Men in a group may talk more easily when their hands are busy and their eyes are on something else. Members of Men’s Sheds, the community workshops where men build and repair things together, have a name for it: talking shoulder to shoulder. This guide covers what the research on that idea shows, where the evidence stops, and how to plan a meeting around a shared activity. It’s for anyone who runs a men’s group, a peer group or a club and wants the talking to come easier.
What the Men’s Sheds research says
The clearest description comes from Scotland. Kelly and colleagues interviewed 62 members of five Men’s Sheds about their health (Kelly et al. 2021). Members said working beside other men in the workshop gave them chances to talk. One called it working “shoulder to shoulder”. The authors note that this way of talking was often easier for men who lacked confidence than sitting across from someone. Some members said they talked with each other about problems such as alcohol. One put it this way: men bottle things up, but over a cup of tea they open up.
A smaller study in Canada heard something similar. Hopper and colleagues interviewed 12 members aged 55 and older at one Shed in British Columbia (Hopper et al. 2026). Members rarely named mental health as their reason for joining. They came for a use of their time, for giving back, and for friendship. Well-being showed up as a side effect of the connection and the purpose. The authors suggest that recruiting men around social contact and contribution may work better than recruiting them around mental health.
Where the evidence stops
These findings describe what members say. They don’t prove that side-by-side talk causes better health. A narrative review of the Men’s Sheds literature found 5 reports and 19 articles, made up of descriptive surveys or small qualitative studies, and said the factors behind good practice hadn’t yet been adequately measured or tested (Wilson and Cordier 2013).
The two interview studies state their own limits. Kelly and colleagues say causal links can only be proposed at this stage, and most of their participants were retired men over 60. Hopper and colleagues studied one woodworking Shed at one point in time. The Canadian paper also describes the shoulder-to-shoulder model as founded on a belief about how men talk.
So treat side by side as a format worth trying, with no promise attached. What the research does support is a description: men in these groups report that talk comes up during shared work and over a cup of tea. One session will show whether it fits your group.
Why the circle can feel harder
A circle puts every man on display at once. All eyes go to the speaker, and the topic is the speaker himself. A man who hasn’t spoken in a group before has to start a story and hold everyone’s attention in the same moment.
A shared task changes three things. The eyes go to the work, so a pause can read as concentration. The task gives a ready topic, so a man can start with the wood, the recipe or the route. And the talk can stop and restart, so nobody has to finish a story he began.
Six steps to plan a side-by-side meeting
These steps work for a weekly group, a one-off evening or a club that wants a talking slot.
- Pick an activity with pauses. Good choices keep the hands busy but leave the head free: fixing a bike, cooking one dish together, a walk, a card game. Activities that need full concentration or a lot of noise can leave little room to talk.
- Set people at angles. Seat or stand men next to each other, or at the corners of a table. In the Scottish study, this was described as more comfortable than sitting face to face for men who lacked confidence.
- Name the job, not the feeling. Open with what you’ll do tonight. “We’re building a planter for the front step” gives everyone a reason to be there that isn’t about himself.
- Plan a tea break. In the Scottish study, one member said men open up over a cup of tea. A pause with drinks and no task gives a story started at the bench a place to go on.
- Keep an optional short round. End with one turn each, two or three sentences, with the right to pass. By then the work may have done some of the warming up, so the round can ask less.
- Let the next meeting repeat the format. Repeating it gives the group a chance to get used to it. Same activity slot, same break, same closing round, for a few meetings in a row.
Questions that fit a shared task
Questions asked during the work can land more easily when they point at the task, a memory of a place or a person. These are easy to drop in while hands are busy:
- Who taught you to do this?
- When did you last fix something yourself?
- What did your father do with his hands?
- What’s a job you’re proud of?
- Where did you go when you needed to think as a kid?
- Who do you call when something breaks?
- What’s a skill you’d like to pass on?
- What did this week ask of you?
A card game as the shared activity
A card game is a shared activity that fits in any room. Everyone looks at the card on the table, not at the speaker. The Thesis card deck works this way: each card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other, and the player picks a side. A word written on a coaster does the same job.
The rules start with the pass: “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” The table card adds “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.” Thesis is for 2–6 players, so a larger group plays at two tables.
Nature has Car on its other side. For some men the car is where talking already happens: a drive with a father, a long trip with a friend, both looking at the road. The car side invites those stories. The idea side opens a place outdoors a man goes back to, which can lead to what he goes there for.
Self-discipline sits on the back of Teapot. It fits a group that meets over tea, and the teapot side starts with a kitchen, a grandmother or a break at work. The idea side lets a man talk about training, early mornings or a habit he kept, in words he already uses.
Community has Mirror on its other side. The word suits a group that’s asking what it is for. A man can talk about a club, a team or a street he belonged to. The mirror side is more personal: what he sees in it now, and who he looks like.
After a turn, the others ask what they’re curious about. The rule card gives three examples: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?
Try it at your next meeting
Open the online table on a phone or laptop in the middle of the workbench or the kitchen table, and play one round during the tea break.
The Thesis die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” With the die, the same card gives a different round each week.
You know your group and you decide what the meeting is for. Thesis is a conversation format and makes no health claims. Before your next session, pick one activity, move the chairs from a circle to the sides of a table, and add a tea break to the plan.
For other ways to bring in the men who say least, see how to get quiet group members to talk. For more on running it in a group, see Thesis for therapy groups. The three cards above have their own pages: Nature, Self-discipline and Community. You can play online for free, see the rules and the box, or read the research behind the deck.