How to facilitate a workshop discussion when nobody knows each other

People sign up for your open workshop. They arrive one by one, take a seat near the door, and look at their phones. When you ask the room a question, two people answer and the rest wait. A discussion with strangers starts in small groups, with a prompt that’s easy to enter, clear agreements, and a way out for anyone who isn’t ready. This guide walks through those steps in the order you run them, for public workshops, meetups, library evenings and any session where the people in the room are meeting for the first time.

The steps work with any prompt. The examples use the Thesis card deck, because each card holds one word and the rules fit on two cards. A word written on a sticky note works the same way.

Why strangers hold back

A quiet room at the start of a workshop is a forecast, made by each person on their own. They guess that the others won’t care, that a personal answer will feel awkward, and that they’ll be liked less if they say the wrong thing. Research suggests those guesses run low.

In experiments by Kardas, Kumar and Epley, people expected deep conversations with strangers to be more awkward than they turned out to be. They also expected strangers to care less about their disclosures than the strangers did. After the talks, people felt more connected than they’d predicted (Kardas et al. 2021). A second set of studies found a “liking gap”: after a conversation, people underestimated how much their partner liked them. One of the samples was members of the public at a personal development workshop (Boothby et al. 2018).

So the host’s task is narrow. Give people a first experience that corrects the forecast, at a cost they can accept. The steps below do that in order.

Step 1: Set two agreements before anything else

Agreements said at the start set the frame for the session. Keep them to two or three and say them before the first prompt. The Thesis rule card opens with one: “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” The second comes from the table card: “What is said at the table stays at the table.”

Ask the room to settle the pass in one sentence, for example “Anyone can say ‘pass’ and the turn moves on.” When the group says the rule out loud, everyone has heard it from the others, not only from the host. For more on the pass itself, see the post on grief support group discussion questions, which builds every prompt around it.

Step 2: Start in pairs, then small groups

The first time a stranger speaks, the audience size matters. Talking to one person is a smaller step than talking to the whole room. Start with pairs for a few minutes, then join pairs into tables of up to six.

Tables of up to six also match how the card game works: Thesis is for 2–6 players. Each table runs its own turns, so nobody waits long for a turn. Give each table one deck, or one stack of word cards, and one person who goes first. In the Thesis rules, “Whoever suggested the game goes first.” At a workshop, ask each table to pick that person by any quick method, such as whoever arrived earliest.

Step 3: Use a prompt people can enter at any depth

A prompt for strangers works when it allows both a light and a personal answer. A single word does that. The speaker picks the depth, and a short answer still counts.

A Thesis card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other. The rule is “Choose a side: the idea or the thing.” Then the player rolls the die and looks at the word from that side. The six faces are MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE, and the only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” The table card adds: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”

Curiosity
Sewing machine
Card 19: Curiosity / Sewing machine. Tap to turn it over.

Curiosity sits on the back of Sewing machine. It’s a good first card for a room of strangers, because it names the attitude a workshop runs on. One person might talk about a subject they followed for years. Another might describe a grandmother’s sewing machine and what it sounded like. Both answers are complete turns, and both give the table something to ask about.

Step 4: Teach the room to ask follow-up questions

The listeners decide how far a turn goes. Step 5 of the Thesis rules says: “The others ask what they’re curious about, gently, without judging.” In conversation studies by Huang and colleagues, people who asked more follow-up questions were liked more by their partners. Participants didn’t expect question-asking to have that effect (Huang et al. 2017).

Strangers may not know what a good follow-up sounds like. Write three on a flip chart and leave them up for the whole session. These come from the Thesis table card:

  1. What did that feel like?
  2. Who else was there?
  3. Has it always meant that to you?

A follow-up is an offer. The speaker can answer it, keep it short or pass, and the asker lets it go. If one voice starts to fill every table’s time, the post on how to handle someone dominating a group discussion covers what to say.

Belonging
Headphones
Card 44: Belonging / Headphones. Tap to turn it over.

Belonging is on the back of Headphones. In a room where nobody knows anyone, it can open talk about the first time a place felt like theirs. The object side gives a lighter way in: what someone listens to on the way to a new place, or how headphones keep a crowd out.

Step 5: Bring the tables back to the room

After the small-group rounds, the whole room meets again. Ask each table to share one thing, chosen by the table, and leave out who said it. That keeps the confidentiality agreement from step 1 and still lets the room hear the range of answers.

This is also the moment to open a whole-room discussion, if your workshop needs one. By now each person has spoken several times at a table, so the room has more voices ready than it did at the start. Pick one word that came up at several tables and ask the room for a second look at it.

Trust
Window
Card 34: Trust / Window. Tap to turn it over.

Trust sits on the back of Window. It suits the whole-room part of a workshop, because by this point people have trusted a few strangers with a story. A player can talk about who they trust and why, or about a window they used to look out of. Either answer gives the room a concrete picture to respond to.

Step 6: End with the last round

A workshop with strangers needs a clear ending, so people leave with a picture of the others. The Thesis rules close with this: “When the group is ready to stop, finish with one last round: each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.”

The last round works at the table level or in the whole room. It asks nothing new about the speaker, so a person who passed every turn can still take part. It also answers the forecast from the start. Each person hears, out loud, that someone listened to them.

Try one round before the workshop

The quickest way to test this plan is one round with two or three friends. Open the online table on a shared screen, agree on the pass, and play one turn each.

Roll the die

Before the session, write your two agreements and the three follow-up questions on one flip chart sheet. Put it where every table can see it, then go first at your own table.

For hosts who run sessions with teams, classes or workshop groups, see Thesis for teams and classes. The three cards above have their own pages: Curiosity, Belonging and Trust. You can play online for free, see the rules and the box, or read the research behind the deck.