How to make friends through friends: the plus-one night

You have a few good friends, and each of them knows people you’ve heard about for years: the climbing partner, the old flatmate, the colleague with the funny stories. You’ve met some of them once, at a birthday, briefly, by the coats. Nothing came of it, because a birthday is a crowd, and a crowd gives nobody a reason to talk past the first round of “how do you know Anna.”

A plus-one night changes the format. Each friend brings one person the others haven’t met. The group stays small, the host is the shared link, and one word on the table gives strangers something to talk about besides jobs. This guide covers the setup, the evening and the week after.

Why friends of friends are the easy start

A friend of a friend arrives pre-vetted. Your friend already likes them, and they already like your friend, so the evening starts with one thing in common. The host is the bridge, and the talk has somewhere to start.

The harder part is turning one pleasant evening into a second one. People leave a first conversation with a worse picture of how it went than their partner has. In studies of strangers in a lab, new college dorm mates and adults at a workshop, people underestimated how much the other person liked them and enjoyed their company. Among dorm mates, that gap lasted for several months (Boothby et al. 2018). So the new person you clicked with may think it went fine too. The gap may explain why nobody texts first.

Time does the rest. In a study of adults who had recently moved, those who reported more time with a new acquaintance felt closer, and shared leisure activities also went with closeness (Hall 2019). A plus-one night is one block of those hours. A second one is another.

How to set up a plus-one night

The setup takes one message and one evening. These steps follow the order you’ll do them in:

  1. Pick two friends. Choose friends who’d enjoy each other’s company, so the core of the table already works.
  2. Ask each to bring one person. The plus-one is someone the others haven’t met: a colleague, a neighbor, a teammate, a cousin in town.
  3. Keep it at five or six. You, two friends and their two plus-ones make five. There’s room for one more, and the deck plays 2–6.
  4. Name the plan in the invite. “Food, then a word game at the table. Bring one person I haven’t met.” The plus-ones know what they’re walking into.
  5. Seat people apart from the person they came with. Each new person sits next to someone they don’t know.
  6. Set a finish time. A plus-one who knows the end time can plan the trip home.

The invite matters most for the plus-ones. A stranger who knows there’ll be a game can prepare for it, and one who wasn’t told may feel ambushed.

The evening, step by step

A plus-one night has three parts: eating, one game, and a closing round. The food part covers the catch-up questions. Let people ask about jobs and where they live while plates go around. That’s the normal opening, and cutting it can make the table stiff.

The game part is where strangers stop being strangers. Use the Thesis deck, the free online table, or one word written on paper. Each turn follows the steps from the rule card:

  1. Whoever suggested the game goes first.
  2. Draw a card. Choose a side: the idea or the thing.
  3. Roll the die.
  4. Look at the word from that side. Say as much or as little as feels right.
  5. The others ask what they’re curious about, gently, without judging.
  6. Hand the die to the left.

Agree on passing first. The rules open with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” A new person needs to know they can skip a card and still be part of the table.

Roll the die

The die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only line is “Look at the word from that side.” A plus-one who draws a word and rolls a face has a starting point that has nothing to do with how well they know the host.

Follow-up questions do the connecting

On a plus-one night, the follow-up question is how two strangers meet. The person telling the story gets heard, and the person asking learns something specific to bring up later. The rule card gives three that work for any word:

What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?

“Who else was there?” works well at this table. It pulls in names, places and old friend groups, and that’s where people can discover they went to the same school or know the same bar.

Questions for a table of half-strangers

If the group would rather skip cards, put one word in the middle and use these. They run from light to deeper:

  1. Where did you first hear this word used about you?
  2. What object in your home goes with it?
  3. Who in your life does this word best?
  4. How did your family use it when you were a kid?
  5. What’s a place in this city that fits it?
  6. When did it last surprise you?
  7. What does it mean to you that it didn’t mean five years ago?
  8. Who would you call first if it showed up in your week?

Two or three of these per word is enough. The rest is follow-up.

Three cards for a plus-one night

Each of these three cards reads in its own way at a table of friends and their friends.

Friendship
Ball
Card 21: Friendship / Ball. Tap to turn it over.

Friendship has Ball on its other side. The idea side asks people to talk about how they make friends, in a room built for that purpose, and plus-ones may answer with how they met the friend who brought them. The ball side goes to sports clubs, school yards and street games, and it’s an easy first turn for someone shy.

Community
Mirror
Card 42: Community / Mirror. Tap to turn it over.

Community has Mirror on its other side. The idea side brings out the groups each person belongs to: a choir, a running club, a building’s group chat. Those are the next places to meet people, so this card can end with an invitation. The mirror side is personal and quick: a hallway mirror, getting ready for a night out.

Belonging
Headphones
Card 44: Belonging / Headphones. Tap to turn it over.

Belonging has Headphones on its other side. New people at a table may have a story about a place where they didn’t belong yet, and hearing one from a stranger makes the room warmer. The headphones side is the light way in: a commute, an album from a first year in a new city.

End with the last round

Close the game the way Thesis ends: “When the group is ready to stop, finish with one last round: each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” On a plus-one night, ask each person to name something about a person they met tonight. Everyone leaves with one specific thing to mention in a message the next day.

The week after

The plus-one night works when something follows it. Two steps in the next few days carry it on:

  • Send one message to one new person. Mention the thing from the last round. Given the liking gap, they may have enjoyed it more than you assume.
  • Set the next date before the group chat goes quiet. Same format, and this time the first plus-ones bring a plus-one of their own.

Weak ties count here too. Students reported more happiness and belonging on days they interacted with more classmates than usual (Sandstrom & Dunn 2014). A plus-one who stays an acquaintance still adds to the week.

Write two names and a date in your phone today, then send the invite. See the rules and the box, or play on the online table. The cards above have their own pages: Friendship, Community and Belonging. For more on playing with a group, see Thesis for friends, and the research behind the deck. If the plus-ones like games, see making friends through board games. If you’re starting over in a new decade, see how to make friends in your 30s. Related: friendship when busy: a low-effort night for tired friends.