Leadership offsite ideas: three rounds on Duty, Loyalty, and Fairness

A leadership offsite agenda fills up with strategy, budgets, and next year’s targets. The conversation about how the team itself makes decisions can slip to the bar after dinner, or out of the day entirely. This post gives that conversation a slot: three words, three rounds. Duty asks who each leader answers to. Loyalty asks which group each leader stands with when the two pull apart. Fairness asks how the team splits what’s scarce. You can run it with three words written on cards, or with the free online table.

Why these three words split an executive team

Two leaders can agree on the goal and still clash over a decision. One possible reason is that each person weighs different things. Graham and colleagues built the Moral Foundations Questionnaire on five sets of moral intuitions, two of them Fairness/Reciprocity and Ingroup/Loyalty. They describe these intuitions as universally available but variably developed (Graham et al. 2011). On a leadership team, that shows up as a familiar argument. One person calls a decision unfair to another department. Another calls it loyal to their own people. Both are describing the same decision from a different side.

Duty adds the question underneath both: who is each leader accountable to? The board, the customers, the people in their function, the leadership team itself. Answers can differ by role, and they may never be said out loud. Naming them at an offsite costs one agenda slot. Finding them out in the middle of a budget fight costs more.

Why the most senior person sets the tone

An executive team has a hierarchy inside it, and it shapes who speaks. Nembhard and Edmondson surveyed teams in 23 neonatal intensive care units. Staff with higher professional status reported more psychological safety. Leader inclusiveness, defined as “words and deeds exhibited by leaders that invite and appreciate others’ contributions,” predicted psychological safety and softened the link between status and safety (Nembhard and Edmondson 2006). The setting was health care, and the data came from surveys, so treat it as a lead for a leadership team.

In practice, the CEO or the most senior person decides how this block goes. Three habits help. Speak in the middle of the order, so your answer neither opens nor closes the round. Keep it short, so the first answer doesn’t set a long length for everyone else. Thank people for answers that disagree with yours, and leave them without a rebuttal.

Before the first round

The setup comes first and shapes whether people talk openly. Agree on three things before anyone draws a word.

  • Passing. The Thesis rules put it first: “Before you start, decide together how passing works.” On a leadership team, a pass needs no reason and gets no comment.
  • What leaves the room. The rule line is “What is said at the table stays there.” Decide together whether that covers direct reports, the board, and the chief of staff.
  • No decisions. This block is for hearing how people think. Any decision that comes up goes on a list for the next working session.

The block, round by round

Each round has one word and one turn per person. The rules say 2–6 players, so with more than six leaders, split into two tables and run the rounds in parallel.

Round 1: Duty. Each leader says who they feel answerable to in their role, and where that duty feels heavy. A finance lead may name the board. A product lead may name the customers. That difference is the point of the round.

Round 2: Loyalty. Each leader describes a time their loyalty to their own function and to this leadership team pulled in different directions. Keep it to a past case, not a live one. A live case turns the round into a negotiation.

Round 3: Fairness. Each leader says what a fair split of budget, headcount, or credit looks like to them. One leader may mean equal shares, another shares by contribution, a third a fair process.

Closing round. The Thesis rules end with “each player names one thing they discovered about someone today.” At an offsite, add one line: each leader names one thing they’ll do differently in the next decision meeting.

Three cards for the three rounds

Each Thesis card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other. The thing side gives a leader a lighter way into the same word.

Duty
Ticket
Card 36: Duty / Ticket. Tap to turn it over.

Duty has Ticket on its back. For a leadership team, Duty reads as the promise attached to the title: to shareholders, to staff, to a founder’s original plan. Ticket gives an easier route. Someone might talk about a ticket they bought for a team event they couldn’t attend, or the ticket queue their support team works through every morning.

Loyalty
Camera
Card 48: Loyalty / Camera. Tap to turn it over.

Loyalty has Camera on its back. On an executive team, Loyalty can bring up stories about the first boss who backed someone, or the team they built and later left. Camera lets a leader talk about who’s in the picture: whose work gets shown at the all-hands, and whose stays out of frame.

Fairness
Sweater
Card 39: Fairness / Sweater. Tap to turn it over.

Fairness has Sweater on its back. Fairness reads as pay bands, promotions, and who gets the bigger budget. Sweater can take the talk somewhere smaller: a hand-me-down, a company sweater that only some people got, or a team where everyone had the same one.

Questions for the three rounds

The questions below work without cards. Pick three or four per round, and keep the rest for the walk or dinner:

  1. Who do you feel most answerable to in this role?
  2. What’s a duty of your job that nobody wrote down?
  3. When did a duty to your team and a duty to the company pull apart?
  4. Who backed you early, and what did that look like?
  5. What does loyalty to this leadership team ask of you?
  6. When is loyalty to your own function the right call?
  7. What’s a decision here that felt fair to you and unfair to someone else?
  8. Does fair mean equal shares, shares by effort, or a fair process to you?
  9. What would make a budget decision feel fair even if you lost?
  10. What’s one thing this team could do to make its decisions easier to accept?

Running the rounds with the deck

With the deck or the online table, put the three cards face up and play one per round. A turn follows the rules on the box: pick a side, roll the die, look at the word from that side. The die has six words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” Then “Say as much or as little as you like. The others ask, gently.” Three short follow-ups work well: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? The rules also include a line that suits this block: “There are no right answers.”

Roll the die

For the offsite itself, put the block in the agenda before lunch, write the three words on the slide, and send the passing rule with the invite. The word pages for Duty, Loyalty, and Fairness have more ways in. For the rest of the day, see team offsite ideas built on purpose and choice. If the Fairness round opens a bigger topic, talking about fairness at work has a full session for it. For more on running it at work, see Thesis for teams and classes. For the studies behind the deck, see the research, and for the full deck, see the rules and the box.