The December cover rota goes out, and by lunch two people have messaged the team lead. One says it’s unfair that she covers again because she covered last year. The other says it’s unfair that he covers at all, since his family lives on another continent and the holiday is his one trip home. Both are using the same word for two different rules. This guide shows a team lead how to run one conversation where the team says what fair means to each of them, sorts the complaints, and agrees on one rule. It works with a word written on a sticky note.
Why the same word starts two arguments
People can mean different rules when they say “fair.” The social psychologist Morton Deutsch argued that equity, where rewards follow contribution, is only one possible basis for distributive justice. Equality and need are others, and groups lean on different ones under different conditions (Deutsch 1975). The rota fight above fits that split. Equal turns says everyone covers once in rotation. Need says the person with the hardest trip home gets the holiday off. Contribution says whoever carried the launch in November gets first pick.
None of the three is wrong. The trouble starts when a team uses one in January and another in June without saying so. Then every decision looks like favoritism to someone, because each person checks it against a different rule.
Four kinds of fairness complaints
A complaint about fairness is easier to answer once you know what it’s about. Jason Colquitt and colleagues reviewed 183 studies of fairness at work. They separated four kinds: the outcome (distributive), the process that produced it (procedural), how people were treated along the way (interpersonal), and how the decision was explained (informational). The four are related, but each one adds something of its own to how fair people judge a situation (Colquitt et al. 2001).
The same rota can draw a complaint of each kind:
- Outcome: “I got the worst shift again.”
- Process: “Nobody asked us before the rota went out.”
- Treatment: “My request was laughed off in the channel.”
- Explanation: “I still don’t know how the shifts were picked.”
The fix differs for each. A new outcome won’t help someone whose complaint is about not being asked. A clear explanation won’t help someone who felt mocked. Sorting the complaints first saves the team from fixing the wrong thing.
Why asking before deciding matters
Being heard before a decision counts for more than being heard after it. E. Allan Lind, Ruth Kanfer and P. Christopher Earley ran a goal-setting study with 179 undergraduates. Some could give their view before the goal was set, some only after, and some not at all. Both kinds of voice led to higher fairness ratings than no voice, and voice before the decision led to higher ratings than voice after. Relevant information about the task also raised perceived fairness (Lind et al. 1990). It was a lab study with students, so it’s a lead for a team and not a promise. It still suggests a timing rule: hold the conversation before the next rota, review or project split, and not after the complaints arrive.
A fairness conversation in five steps
The session below fits a regular team meeting, with one person running it.
- Pick one decision, not a person. Name a recurring decision: holiday cover, who gets the interesting projects, who presents the work to leadership. Say out loud that nobody’s past decision is on trial. A conversation about a type of decision lets people speak without accusing a colleague.
- Write a rule each. Everyone writes one line on a sticky note: “For this decision, fair would mean…” Collect the notes and read them out without names. If the notes mix equal turns, contribution and need, the team can see where past friction came from.
- Play one round with the word. Put the word Fairness on the table. Each person says a few sentences about it from any angle they like: a time something felt fair or unfair, a rule from childhood, a team they once worked on. This round is where people explain why they hold their rule.
- Sort the complaints. Ask for current complaints about the chosen decision, without names. Place each one under outcome, process, treatment or explanation. If one column fills up first, that’s the place to start.
- Agree on one rule and a review date. Pick the rule for the next round of this decision, write it where the team can see it, and set a date to check it. If the lead can’t change the decision, say so at the start, and use the session to fix the process and the explanation instead.
Three cards that fit the round
Each Thesis card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other. For a team, the thing side gives anyone a way in that doesn’t touch their private life.
Fairness has Sweater on its back. On a team, Fairness can bring up rules people learned early: how a sibling split dessert, how a first manager handed out shifts. The Sweater side can carry grief for some players, since a kept sweater may have belonged to someone they lost. Anyone can pick the other side or pass, and the group agrees how passing works before the first turn.
Luck has Passport on its back. It suits a fairness round because it lets people talk about what they didn’t earn: a good first boss, a project that landed at the right time. On an international team, Passport can touch visa status, so the pass rule matters here too. Someone might pick it and talk about a trip instead.
Competition has Bench on its back. It opens the contribution side of fairness: who gets credit, who gets picked. The Bench side gives a way to talk about sitting out, whether in a school team or on a project that went to someone else.
Questions for the round
The questions below can replace the card round or follow it. Each one works at any depth:
- What’s a rule from childhood about sharing that you still use?
- When did a decision at work feel fair to you, even though it didn’t go your way?
- What makes a decision feel fair before you know the result?
- Who taught you what fair means?
- When is equal treatment the wrong rule?
- What would you want to know about how a decision was made?
- What’s something you got at work that you see as luck?
- When does need count more than contribution?
- What would a fair way to hand out the interesting work look like here?
- What’s one thing that would make the next rota feel fairer?
Running it as a card round
With the deck or the online table, each turn follows the same steps. Draw a card, choose the idea or the thing, roll the die and look at the word from that side. The die has six words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” The rule card adds a line that fits a fairness talk well: “Every view is welcome, especially one that differs from yours.” The others can ask one short question, such as What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?
Before the next rota, review or project split goes out, pick that decision and put this session on the calendar for the week before. Each card has its own word page: Fairness, Luck, and Competition. For more on running it at work, see Thesis for teams and classes. For the research, see the research behind the deck. See the rules and the box. For a longer talk once the team trusts the format, see deep conversations at work. Related: gratitude at work: an end-of-year thank-you round for your team. Related: belonging at work: how to talk about it as a team.