You think back to the year you had no money, a bad job, and a room with a broken heater. It was hard, and you knew it was hard at the time. Now the memory feels warm, and part of you misses it. That can feel strange, even a little wrong.
This post explains what memory research has found about why hard times can turn warm, what that longing can point at, and how to talk about it with someone. At the end there are ten questions and one thing to try tonight.
The short answer
Memory doesn’t keep a hard period the way you lived it. The bad feelings attached to a memory tend to fade faster than the good ones. What stays can be the people who were there, the small wins, and the fact that you got through. So the nostalgia may not be for the broken heater. It may be for the friend who sat with you in that cold room, and for the person you were becoming.
Bad feelings fade faster
Psychologists call this the fading affect bias. The negative feeling tied to a memory fades faster than the positive feeling tied to another. Ritchie, Walker, and colleagues tested it in 10 cultures, with more than 2,400 memory descriptions from 562 people. Every sample showed the same pattern: positive feeling faded slower than negative feeling. The authors suggest it may help people recover from bad events and keep their good emotions (Ritchie et al. 2015).
That’s one reason a bad year softens. Years later, the fear of the rent date is faint. The evening you split one pizza with your roommates is still bright. Both happened in the same month. Only one of them kept its color.
Memory edits even good events
The softening shows up in short events too. Mitchell and colleagues followed people through a trip to Europe, a Thanksgiving vacation, and a 3-week bicycle trip in California. People expected more than they got, and later remembered the trip as better than it felt while it was happening. During the events, people had more negative thoughts, from distractions, disappointment, and a lower view of themselves. Within days, they rated the events much more positively (Mitchell et al. 1997).
The researchers called this the “rosy view.” These were vacations, so the finding doesn’t prove a bad year turns good. It does show that memory doesn’t play the past back as it felt. The rain on one day of the bike trip drops out of the story. The view from the top stays in.
What you miss may be the people
Nostalgic memories have a typical shape. Tim Wildschut, Constantine Sedikides, and colleagues ran seven studies on what nostalgia is about, what brings it on, and what it does. The memories usually showed the self with close others, such as friends, or at big events, such as weddings. They held more positive than negative feeling. Many of them told of a bad scene that was later redeemed by a triumph (Wildschut et al. 2006).
That last pattern fits nostalgia for bad times closely. The hard year comes with an ending you now know: you passed the exam, you left the job, you found the next apartment. Back then you didn’t know it would work out. Now the story has an arc, and stories with an arc can feel good to tell.
When you miss a bad time, it helps to ask who was in the room: a roommate, a coworker on the same night shift, a sibling during a family crisis. The answer can be the real object of the longing.
Why the feeling shows up now
The timing of the feeling says something too. The same 2006 studies found that negative mood and loneliness set off nostalgia (Wildschut et al. 2006). Xinyue Zhou and colleagues ran four studies on loneliness. Loneliness lowered how much support people felt they had. It also raised nostalgia, and nostalgia in turn raised the support they felt (Zhou et al. 2008).
Read together, the two papers suggest a plain explanation. If the present feels quiet or far from people, the mind may reach for a time when people were close, even if that time was hard. Missing the shared apartment can be a sign that you’d like more of what it had: people around, a common goal, someone to talk to at midnight.
The longing can also point forward. Cheung and colleagues ran four studies on nostalgia and optimism. Nostalgic stories held more optimism than ordinary ones, and bringing on nostalgia raised optimism. In the last study, nostalgia made people feel more connected to others, which raised self-esteem, which raised optimism (Cheung et al. 2013). These studies describe averages and don’t promise that one memory will change any particular evening.
Ten questions about the hard times you miss
These questions work best out loud with a friend, or on paper. Answer with a story where you can: a place, a year, a person.
- Which hard year of your life do you remember with some warmth?
- Who was with you during that time?
- What did a good evening look like back then?
- What do you miss from that time that you wouldn’t want back?
- What did you have then that you don’t have now?
- When did you last think about that time, and what kind of day was it?
- What small win from that time do you still remember?
- Who from that time would you call if you could?
- What did you learn to do on your own back then?
- What part of your life now might you miss in ten years?
Question 5 can do the most work. The answer may be a person, a routine, or a sense of purpose more than the hardship itself.
Look at the word from six sides
Another way in is to stay with one word and change the angle. The Thesis die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.”
Nostalgia has Key on its other side. For a hard period, Key works as a way in. The key to a cheap first apartment or a shared dorm room opens the memory through an object, which can be easier than naming the feeling. Ask who else had a copy.
Loneliness has Perfume on its other side. The research links loneliness to nostalgia, so this word looks at the present half of the feeling. Choose Perfume if the idea side lands too close: a smell can bring back the people from a hard year without asking you to describe how lonely you feel now. If either side is too much, pass.
Hope has Teddy bear on its other side. Hope looks at the arc of a hard time: what you hoped for then, and whether it came. The Teddy bear side can lead to the things people keep through bad stretches, and why they kept them.
Try it with someone
A hard time told to someone else can come back with more detail. A friend who was there may remember it differently, and the difference is worth hearing. Two or three people at a table is enough.
The rules open with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” Then take turns:
- Draw a card. Choose a side: the idea or the thing.
- Roll the die.
- Look at the word from that side. Say as much or as little as feels right.
- The others ask what they’re curious about, gently, without judging.
- Hand the die to the left.
The rule card gives three follow-ups: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? For a bad time you miss, the third one fits best. It asks how the memory has changed since you lived it.
What to do tonight
Pick the hard year you miss most. Write down three things from it: one person, one place, and one thing you did together. Then look at your week now and find which of the three is missing. Tell the memory to one person, and ask them about a hard time of their own. “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”
See the rules and the box, or open the free online table. The cards above have their own pages: Nostalgia, Loneliness, and Hope. For playing with a few close people, see Thesis for friends. For the studies behind the deck, see the research page. For the wider picture of where nostalgia comes from, see why we feel nostalgia: the psychology in plain words. Related: nostalgic for a time you never lived in? What it is.