Regret of inaction: what the research found

You sent the angry email recently, and it still stings. Years ago you didn’t apply for the course, and that one stings in a different way: quieter, and it hasn’t faded. Research on the regret of inaction explains why the two feel so different, and why the second kind lasts.

The short version: in the short term, people regret what they did more. Over a lifetime, they regret what they didn’t do more. This post walks through the studies behind that finding, a newer replication, and one way to use it this week.

The finding in one paragraph

Thomas Gilovich and Victoria Husted Medvec at Cornell asked adults about their regrets through phone surveys, questionnaires, and face-to-face interviews. People’s biggest regrets tended to be things they had failed to do. In the authors’ words, “Actions cause more pain in the short-term, but inactions are regretted more in the long run” (Gilovich and Medvec 1994). A year later the same authors set out why this time pattern appears (Gilovich and Medvec 1995).

What the studies asked

The 1994 paper reports five studies. Each one asked about regret from a different angle, so the result doesn’t rest on a single question.

  • The phone survey. 60 adults picked at random from a Syracuse phone directory were asked which they regretted more: things they did, or things they didn’t do. 45 of the 60 (75%) chose the things they didn’t do.
  • The interviews. 77 people, from retired professors to nursing home residents to students, described their biggest regrets in their own words. Of 213 regrets, failures to act outnumbered actions 63% to 37%.
  • The scenario. 80 Cornell students read about two students who both made a bad call: Dave stayed at his university, Jim transferred. 76% thought Jim would regret his choice more at first. 64% thought Dave would regret his more in the long run.
  • The two time frames. 32 adults recalled their worst action and worst inaction from the past week, and from their whole life. For the past week, the group was roughly split. For the whole life, 84% regretted the inaction more.

The most common regrets in the interviews were missed chances for education and failing to “seize the moment.” Missed romance and too little time for close relationships came up often too. One detail in the paper stands out: nobody regretted time spent on a skill or hobby, even one they’d since dropped.

Why inaction lasts longer

The authors propose several reasons the pain of a regretted action fades while the regret of inaction grows. They’re explanations from the paper, offered as likely mechanisms.

Actions get repaired. After a bad action, people tend to do something about it: leave the job, end the relationship, apologize. In a related study the paper reports, 65% said they’d made bigger changes to deal with their worst action than their worst inaction. Inaction leaves you where you were, and it’s harder to move from there.

The reasons for not acting fade. At the moment of choice, the fear is real: rejection, a bad outcome, money. Years later, the fear is gone and the choice looks hard to explain. “Why didn’t I at least try?” is a question the paper quotes as typical.

The other road has no end. A regretted action has known consequences, and they stop somewhere. A regretted inaction has imagined ones, and the list can keep growing. The authors describe regrets of inaction as “something of an open book,” while the book on actions is “typically closed.”

Open loops come back. Some inactions can still be acted on: learning a language, calling a parent. That keeps them in the present, so they come to mind more often. A regret you’re reminded of more often is a regret you feel more often.

Does it still hold?

In 2022, Yeung and Feldman repeated four of the original studies with 988 Americans online. They found support for the original pattern in three of the four, with weaker effects, and no support in the study that compared the past week with the whole life (Yeung and Feldman 2022). They also found that people feel more responsible for actions than for inactions, in the short term and the long term.

So the pattern holds in broad terms, and the size of it is smaller than the 1994 numbers suggest. The original authors also flagged a limit themselves: their samples were American, and they wondered whether cultures that value action less would show the same result.

Which inactions stay with us

A later line of work by Shai Davidai and Thomas Gilovich looked at what the lasting regrets are about. Across six studies, people’s most enduring regrets came more often from falling short of their ideal self (hopes and goals) than from falling short of their ought self (duties). One proposed reason: people deal faster with regrets about duties, so the ones about hopes stay unresolved (Davidai and Gilovich 2018).

Put together with the 1994 results, this suggests a picture. The regret of inaction that lasts can be about a person you meant to become.

Using the research

The research gives two practical hints. A regret of action can ease once something is done about it. A regret of inaction stays open, which also means part of it can still be acted on.

Saying it out loud to someone can help sort which part is which. A friend can ask what was in the way back then, and whether it’s still in the way now. These questions work as a start:

  1. What’s one thing you didn’t do that you still think about?
  2. What stopped you at the time?
  3. Is that reason still there today?
  4. Which part of it could you still do, even in a smaller form?
  5. Who would have been there if you had done it?
  6. What did you do instead, and what came from that?
  7. Which regret from your twenties has faded, and why?
  8. What would you like to have tried by this time next year?

Three cards that fit this topic

The Thesis deck has words that open this subject without a question at all. Each card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other.

Regret
Lamp
Card 09: Regret / Lamp. Tap to turn it over.

Regret has a Lamp on its other side. The idea side invites the direct story: the thing done or not done. The Lamp is softer. A lamp left on in a window, a desk lamp from a room you studied in. For a regret of inaction, the Lamp can lead to the place where the decision was made.

Courage
Bicycle
Card 29: Courage / Bicycle. Tap to turn it over.

Courage has a Bicycle on its other side. Courage turns the topic forward: a time someone did act, and what it took. The Bicycle brings up learning to ride, falling, and getting back on, which is a story of action told without any pressure to confess.

Failure
Washing machine
Card 37: Failure / Washing machine. Tap to turn it over.

Failure has a Washing machine on its other side. Failure sits close to regret of action, and the research suggests those regrets tend to ease with time. Talking about an old failure can show how a past mistake was repaired, or what came from it.

Try it at a table

A regret is easier to look at from more than one side. The Thesis die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. “Look at the word from that side.”

Roll the die

The rules begin with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” That matters for a word like Regret. The table card adds: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.” And the follow-ups fit this topic well: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? The third one connects to the research: has the regret grown, faded, or stayed the same? For more on asking a second question that lands, see follow-up questions.

One thing to do this week

Write down one regret of inaction. Next to it, write what stopped you then, and whether it still applies. If part of it can still be done, pick the smallest version and put a date on it. If it can’t, tell the story to one person you trust and let them ask one follow-up.

See the rules and the box, or open the free online table. The cards above have their own pages: Regret, Courage, and Failure. For a small group of close people, see Thesis for friends. For the studies behind the deck, see the research page.