You’re new in the city. You know the barista’s face, the neighbor’s dog, and a few people from work. Every morning on the train you put your headphones on, and so does the person next to you. Talking to the person next to you feels like breaking a rule nobody wrote down.
Psychologists have tested that rule. This post covers four studies on the benefits of talking to strangers, what each one found, and where the findings stop. It ends with something to try tomorrow.
The short answer
People expect a talk with a stranger to go worse than it does. They expect the other person not to want it, they expect to learn little, and they expect rejection. In the studies below, each of those forecasts turned out too gloomy. The talk itself was the part that went well.
1. The train ride was better with a conversation
Nicholas Epley and Juliana Schroeder ran experiments with commuters on trains and buses. Some were asked to connect with a stranger, others to sit in solitude. The ones who talked reported a more positive ride, and they weren’t less productive. Before the ride, people predicted the opposite: they expected solitude to feel better (Epley and Schroeder 2014).
The authors trace the mistake partly to one guess: people underestimated how much the others wanted to connect. In a lab experiment, the people who were talked to had experiences as positive as the people who did the talking. So the person next to you may be making the same guess about you.
2. Small talk with classmates counted
Gillian Sandstrom and Elizabeth Dunn looked at weak ties: the people at the edge of your circle. Students reported more happiness and more belonging on days they interacted with more classmates than usual. Two more studies, which counted every interaction in a day, linked weak-tie interactions to social and emotional well-being too (Sandstrom and Dunn 2014).
This matters for anyone new in a city. A close friendship takes time. The person at the bakery, the neighbor, the regular at your gym are already there, and those small exchanges showed up in how people felt that day.
3. People learned more than they expected
Stav Atir, Kristina Wald and Nicholas Epley ran seven experiments on what we learn from strangers. In the first, 206 visitors to a park in Chicago had a 10-minute conversation with someone they didn’t know. Afterward they reported learning more than they had predicted, both in general and about the other person (Atir et al. 2022).
The gap comes from uncertainty. With a friend or relative, people guessed about right. With a stranger, they couldn’t picture what the talk would hold, so they guessed low. A stranger’s story is the one you can’t predict, and that’s where the surprise came from.
4. A week of practice made it easier
Gillian Sandstrom, Erica Boothby and Gus Cooney turned talking to strangers into a game. For a week, participants used a scavenger-hunt app with missions like finding someone “wearing a hat” or “drinking a coffee.” One group talked to the stranger they found for a few minutes. The other group only observed them (Sandstrom, Boothby and Cooney 2022).
Before the week, people expected rejections and awkward silences. Of the 1,336 conversations in the study, 87% were with the first person they approached. By the end, the talkers predicted fewer rejections and felt more confident starting, keeping up and ending a conversation. The observers didn’t change. The new attitudes held a week after the study ended, and about 40% of the talkers said they’d exchanged contact information with someone.
Where the studies stop
These are short conversations, measured over hours or days. The week-long study followed people for one more week, and the authors call it an open question whether they kept talking to strangers after that. The first weak-ties study worked with students. None of them say a chat on the train replaces a close friend. They say the chat goes better than the guess.
Why the headphones stay on
If talking feels good, why does the train stay quiet? The studies point at the forecast. Each commuter may assume the others want silence, so nobody tests it, and the wrong guess never meets the evidence. The scavenger-hunt study suggests the fix is repetition. One good talk is easy to call luck. A week of them can start to change the forecast.
Start with something you can both see
A stranger is easier to talk to with a shared thing in front of you. A menu, a dog, a book on the table: something to point at gives both people a topic that belongs to neither. A single word works the same way.
Belonging has Headphones on its other side. The idea fits a newcomer’s evening: where you’ve felt you belonged, and where you haven’t yet. The Headphones side is lighter. A song you played on a long commute or a first night in a new place is an easy story to tell to someone you met that day.
Curiosity has a Sewing machine on its other side. The idea opens the kind of talk the Atir study measured: what the other person knows that you don’t. The Sewing machine brings up a grandmother, a school class, a costume made the night before a party. A shared detail can turn up in the first story.
At a meetup or a dinner with people you half-know, a card can do the opening for you. The Thesis die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” Before the first turn, agree how passing works. “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”
Try one this week
Pick one stranger a day for five days: the person at the bakery, the neighbor in the elevator, the seatmate on the train. Say one line about something you can both see. If they answer, ask one follow-up. The rule card’s three work with strangers too: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? At the end of the week, compare what you expected with what happened.
See the rules and the box, or open the free online table. The cards above have their own pages: Belonging and Curiosity, and Community is close to both. For playing with people you’re getting to know, see Thesis for friends. For the studies behind the deck, see the research page. If the replay after a talk is the hard part, read the liking gap. For the short version of the train study, see what happened when commuters talked to strangers.