You write “Who are you?” on the whiteboard and wait. One person says “a student”. Another names a football club. The rest shrug, and the evening moves on to snacks. The question is too big to answer in a room of peers, so people reach for a label and stop there. This post gives youth group leaders 12 discussion questions about identity for ages 16 and up, and a five-part session to ask them in. The session comes at identity sideways: through a thing, a habit, or a small moment, one short turn at a time.
The plan works with questions on paper slips. The examples also use the Thesis card deck, which is rated 16+ and built for 2–6 players. Each card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other, and that second side is where this session starts.
Why “who are you” gets a label
A label is the safest answer to a big question. It’s short, it’s public already, and nobody can disagree with it. A story about the time you changed your mind, or the object you’d save from a fire, says more and risks more. Older teens can tell the difference, and in a group of peers they may pick the label.
Stories are also where identity takes shape at this age. A review by Habermas and Bluck argued that the life story, the way a person links memories into an account of who they are, begins to develop in adolescence (Habermas & Bluck 2000). That makes the late teens a good age for this conversation. It also suggests the useful prompt asks for a moment or a reason, and leaves the label out.
The listeners shape the story too. In three studies with 220 late adolescents and young adults, Pasupathi and Hoyt found that people gave more meaning-laden, interpretive accounts of everyday events when they talked with responsive friends (Pasupathi & Hoyt 2009). For a youth group, the room’s response after a turn matters too. A nod and one gentle follow-up can give the next speaker more room than silence or a joke.
A session plan in five parts
The plan below fits a regular evening slot. The order matters more than the timing, so stretch or cut each part to fit your group.
- Agree on passing. Before anyone speaks, the group decides how a pass works. The Thesis box says: “Before you start, decide together how passing works.” A pass needs no reason.
- Start with the thing. Each person draws a card and talks about the everyday object on it: a mirror, a fridge, a calculator. This round asks for nothing personal, and it gets everyone talking once.
- Turn the card over. In the second round, players can switch to the idea side. Anyone who’d rather stay with the object stays with it.
- Questions from the list. Pick two or three questions from the list below. Each person answers one, or passes.
- Last round. Each person names one thing they noticed about someone else today. It closes the session on listening.
Sit at the same table as the group and take a turn in each round. When the adult answers too, the round can read as a conversation. When the adult only asks, it can read as a test.
12 discussion questions about identity
These questions ask for a moment, a thing, or a reason. Each one can be answered in a sentence, and none needs a label.
- What’s an object you’ve kept for years, and why that one?
- What’s something about you that people only learn after a while?
- When did you last change your mind about something that mattered?
- Which habit of yours came from someone in your family?
- What would a friend say you’re like when you’re tired?
- What’s a word people use for you that doesn’t fit?
- Where do you act most like yourself?
- What’s a choice you made this year that was yours alone?
- What part of your background do you want to keep?
- What did you care about at 12 that you’ve let go of?
- Who do you sound like when you laugh?
- What’s something you’d like people to ask you about?
Question 6 can bring up names people have been called. If your group is new, leave it for a later session. Question 9 can open talk about culture, faith, or family, and some people will want to keep that private. The pass covers both.
Three cards for an identity session
These three cards suit the topic because each object side gives a way in that asks little at first. The idea side is there for anyone who wants to go further.
Community sits on the back of Mirror. The mirror is a direct way into identity without saying the word. A player can talk about getting ready in the morning, or what they check before they leave the house. On the other side, Community asks which groups a person counts themselves part of, and which ones count them in.
Tradition is on the back of Fridge. A fridge holds the food a family keeps buying, the magnets, the notes, the leftovers from a holiday. For older teens it’s an easy way to talk about where they come from. The idea side asks which family or cultural habits they’ll carry on and which they’ll drop.
Pride is on the back of Calculator. The calculator can lead to school, exams, or money, which everyone in the room knows. Pride asks what a person has done that they’d point to. It also leaves room for pride in where they’re from, or in who they’ve become.
Running it with the die
The Thesis die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” A roll gives a player an angle on the word, so the answer stays specific.
Two rules from the box keep turns short and safe: “Say as much or as little as you like. The others ask, gently.” Read them out before the first round. A one-sentence turn counts, and a follow-up question is an offer the speaker can decline.
Identity topics can touch gender, sexuality, faith, and family history. You know your group and its context, and you decide how far a session goes. Thesis is a conversation format and makes no clinical claims. Agree up front that “What is said at the table stays there.” Link that line to the confidentiality rules your youth group already uses, including when you as the leader would have to pass something on.
Try it at your next session
Run one round with objects only before you plan a whole evening. Put the online table on a shared screen, agree on passing, and let each person talk about the thing on their card.
For the next meeting, write questions 1, 7, and 12 on three slips of paper. Put them face down in the middle and let the group pick which one to open first.
For a broader set of prompts, see discussion questions for older teens or questions to ask teens in group. Running sessions with a class or club? See Thesis for teams and classes. The three cards above have their own pages: Community, Tradition, and Pride. You can play online for free, see the rules and the box, or read the research behind the deck.