What to say instead of "How are you?"

“How are you?” “Good, busy. You?” “Good, good.” Two people, two lines, zero information. You both said the lines, and the conversation is now exactly where it started.

The fix is small. Ask about one moment instead of a whole life. “What was the best part of your day so far?” is as short as “How are you?”, and it can’t be answered with a word. Below are ten openers built that way, why they work, and what to say once the other person answers.

Why “How are you?” stops the conversation

“How are you?” is a greeting dressed as a question. The expected answer is “fine,” so neither person has to think. Behavioral researcher Vanessa Van Edwards puts it this way in a long interview on conversation: questions like this are so socially scripted that the brain goes on autopilot. Autopilot in, autopilot out.

The question is also too big. “How are you” covers a job, a body, a family, and a mood. Summing all of that up for an acquaintance in the hallway is hard, so the safest summary wins. A question about one hour of one day is small enough to answer honestly.

There’s one more reason people stay with the script: going past it feels risky. In a set of experiments with strangers, Kardas, Kumar, and Epley found that people expected deeper conversations to be more awkward than they turned out to be. People also underestimated how interested their partner would be in what they shared, and felt more connected and happier afterward than they predicted (Kardas et al. 2021). The step off the script is smaller from the other side.

10 openers that ask about one moment

These questions are about the same size as “How are you?” but point at something specific. Each one asks for a moment, a plan, or a small detail, and each one works in a hallway, at a party, or by text:

  1. What was the best part of your day so far?
  2. What’s been keeping you busy this week?
  3. Anything you’re looking forward to this weekend?
  4. What did you have for lunch, and was it good?
  5. What’s the last thing that made you laugh?
  6. What are you in the middle of right now: a book, a show, a project?
  7. How long have you lived here? And what’s the best thing about it so far?
  8. What’s one thing that went well today?
  9. Did anything surprise you this week?
  10. What’s the first thing you’ll do when you get home tonight?

The first one is a version of Van Edwards’s suggestion to replace “How are you?” with “What was the highlight of your day?” She points out it’s casual and not too deep, and it asks the other person to look for something good. Number 7 follows a trick she describes: ask a “how long” question, then ask about the best moment in that time.

Small words carry these questions. “Best,” “last,” and “first” point at one specific memory, so the other person doesn’t have to choose from a whole week. “Surprise” works the same way. A question with one of these words can get a story instead of a summary.

What to say after the answer

The opener gets a moment. The next sentence decides whether the moment turns into a conversation. If someone says “Lunch, honestly. I found a new noodle place,” ask one thing about the noodle place before you mention your own lunch.

Three questions from the Thesis rule card fit after almost any answer:

What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?

For a lunch, the second one is enough. For something bigger, like a first week in a new city, the first one opens it up. More on this in follow-up questions.

Not every opener lands. Someone might say “Nothing good today, to be honest.” That’s a real answer, and it tells you more than “fine” would have. You can ask “Rough day?” and let them decide how much to say. If they keep it short, keep it short too. A question is an invitation, and the other person can decline it.

Where small moments count

Short exchanges with near strangers count too. A study from Elizabeth Dunn’s lab at the University of British Columbia recruited people on their way into a Starbucks in downtown Vancouver. Some were told to get in and out with their coffee. Others were asked to have a social interaction with the cashier: smile, make eye contact, chat. The social group felt happier and felt a greater sense of belonging in their community (UBC Psychology). Dunn notes that a short chat doesn’t replace close relationships. It still counts for something.

So the barista, the neighbor in the elevator, and the colleague at the coffee machine are all good people to try one line on. “Busy morning?” to a barista is already a step off the script. “What’s the best thing you’ve made today?” is two.

One word does the same job

If thinking up a question on the spot is the hard part, a single word can do it for you. A word gives both people one thing to look at, the way “best part of your day” does. Thesis is a deck of 50 double-sided cards: an idea on one side, an everyday thing on the other. You can play it at a table, on the free online table, or with a word written on a napkin.

Roll the die

Each turn, you draw a card, choose a side, and roll a die with six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. Look at the word from that side. The rules say it plainly: “Say as much or as little as feels right.”

Joy
Chair
Card 05: Joy / Chair. Tap to turn it over.

Joy has Chair on its other side. Joy is the “best part of your day” question in one word. The chair side is easier for a first meeting: a favorite chair, a chair at a grandparent’s house, the worst office chair you’ve had.

Rest
Clock
Card 38: Rest / Clock. Tap to turn it over.

Rest has Clock on its other side. The honest answer to “How are you?” can be “tired.” Rest lets someone talk about what tired means for them this month, and what helps. The clock is a lighter way in: early mornings, a late train, an alarm.

Curiosity
Sewing machine
Card 19: Curiosity / Sewing machine. Tap to turn it over.

Curiosity has Sewing machine on its other side. It works like “What are you in the middle of right now?”: people talk about what they’re learning or what caught their attention lately. The sewing machine can bring out a story about someone who made things by hand.

Try it once today

Pick one person you’ll see today and one question from the list. When they answer, ask one thing about what they said before you talk about yourself. Then notice what you learned that “Good, busy” would have hidden.

For more ways to play with people you know, see Thesis for friends. The cards above have their own pages: Joy, Rest, and Curiosity. See the rules and the box, and the research behind the deck. For the job question, see better questions than “What do you do?”.