Someone calls before your first grief group meeting and asks, “Will it help?” The research gives a careful answer. Reviews of peer and mutual help groups report benefits in many studies, no differences in others, and almost no harm. They also say the studies are small and uneven, and that a group doesn’t suit everyone. This post sets out what four reviews found, what they can’t tell you, and how to turn that into an honest reply for the person on the phone.
It’s written for hosts and facilitators of non-clinical grief groups: hospice volunteers, community organizers, and people who started a group after their own loss.
What the research found
Three reviews looked at peer support and mutual help groups, where people with the same experience meet without a therapist leading. Their findings point the same way, with different levels of confidence.
- Mutual help groups across mental health problems. A 2008 review found 12 studies that met its criteria, including studies on bereavement. Seven reported positive changes for group members, 5 found no differences from non-members, and none showed negative effects. The authors call the evidence “limited but promising” (Pistrang et al. 2008).
- Peer support after a sudden or unexpected death. A 2019 review included 32 studies. Most showed that peer support helped bereaved survivors, with fewer grief symptoms and more well-being (Bartone et al. 2019).
- Peer-led support after suicide loss. A 2022 scoping review of 10 studies found “the potential benefit of peer-led support to those bereaved through suicide.” Its authors add that “it is difficult to determine the true impact” from the studies available (Higgins et al. 2022).
So the short answer is a cautious yes, with a wide margin of doubt. The 2008 review’s strongest results came from two randomized trials, where mutual help groups did as well as more expensive professional treatments. That covers the groups in those trials, not any given room.
What the research can’t say
The limits matter as much as the findings, because they decide what a host can promise. The 2022 review found methodological limitations in most of its studies, and its authors call for more controlled studies with valid outcome measures. Over 70% of reported participants were women, and men and people over 65 were underrepresented. No study defined who counts as a peer, and facilitator training was poorly described (Higgins et al. 2022).
There’s a second limit that’s easy to miss. Grief changes over time on its own, and a study without a comparison group can’t separate that change from the group’s effect. A 2008 meta-analysis of 61 controlled studies shows why this matters. It covered psychotherapy for bereaved people, a different format from a peer group. Interventions had a small effect right after they ended and no statistically significant benefit at follow-up. The authors suggest one reason: people in the control groups tended to improve naturally over time (Currier et al. 2008).
The same review found better results for programs that only included grievers with marked difficulties adapting to the loss. For a host, that cuts both ways. Support may matter most to someone who is struggling. And a person who is struggling a lot may need more than a peer group offers.
Who a group suits, and who it doesn’t
The 2022 review also gathered what members said about their groups. People who came wanting to meet others with the same experience, or looking for a space without judgment, described benefits. Longer-bereaved members could offer guidance and hope to newer ones (Higgins et al. 2022).
The same review is plain about the other side: “not all participants may benefit from partaking in a group.” A few studies linked participation to distress. Sharing was upsetting for some members. Poor facilitation, such as one person taking over, cliques forming, or online posts going unmonitored, led some people to leave. Groups that were too large, or where members shared no kind of loss, were less acceptable.
Members of a UK bereavement forum describe the same mix (Sue Ryder Online Community). One found a group closer to group counseling than a social meeting, and was trying another. Another left a general grief group and found a better fit in an evening group for people who had lost a partner. A third found a monthly group helpful at first, then felt they were outgrowing it. Each was looking for a group that fit.
What to tell someone who asks
An honest answer to “Will it help?” has three parts: what the research found, what it can’t promise, and what the person can try. It might sound like this: “Studies of peer groups often report fewer grief symptoms and better well-being for members, though some find no difference and not everyone benefits. Come to a session or two and see whether it fits. You can listen the whole time. If it isn’t right, that’s useful to know, and I can point you to other options.”
That reply promises no recovery and no timeline. It leaves a way out, which the forum members above needed. And it points to support beyond the group for someone struggling a lot, where the 2008 meta-analysis found interventions did best.
These questions help a newcomer and a host work out the fit together, before or after a first session:
- Who is the group for: any loss, or one kind, such as a partner or a child?
- How long ago was the loss, and how long ago for the others in the room?
- Is the group more social or more structured?
- How many people usually come?
- Can a person listen without speaking?
- Who leads it, and what training do they have?
- Does it meet in person, online, or both?
- What does a person do if a session leaves them more upset than before?
- Who can they contact between sessions?
A group can be right for a season and then stop fitting, as one forum member found. That’s a normal end.
A word to start the first session
A host can shape a first session so a newcomer takes part at their own pace. One way is a single word in the middle of the table, which people can answer, turn over or pass on. A word on an index card works. The Thesis deck puts an idea on one side of each card and an everyday thing on the other.
Belonging is on the back of Headphones. It touches what the 2022 review found people came for: being with others who’ve had a similar loss. A member can talk about where they feel they belong now, or about the headphones they wear on the walk home. Both are full turns.
Nostalgia sits on the back of Key. It lets people bring the person they lost into the room without starting from the death. A key to a house, a car or a shed can carry a story, and the turn can stay with the object.
Hope is on the back of Teddy bear. A member further from their loss may talk about where hope came back, and the 2022 review lists more hope among what members reported. A newer member can pick the bear instead and talk about someone who kept one.
The Thesis rule card begins: “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” In a grief group, agree on it before the first word. The table card adds, “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.” The die has six faces, MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE, with one line: “Look at the word from that side.” Good follow-ups are short and open: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?
You know your group and its limits, and you decide how far a game format goes in it. Thesis is a conversation format and makes no clinical claims.
Before your next session
Write your three-part answer to “Will it help?” on a card and keep it by the phone. Add the name of one local service you’d point someone to if a group isn’t enough.
For questions to use inside the session, see grief support group discussion questions. If you’re still choosing a format, read Death Cafe or grief group. For more on using it with groups, see Thesis for therapy groups. The three cards above have their own pages: Belonging, Nostalgia and Hope. You can play online for free, see the rules and the box, or read the research behind the deck. Related: check-out questions for group therapy and support groups.