Your partner’s parents sit across from your parents. A cousin has brought someone new, who knows nobody’s name yet. Your grandmother speaks one language, and the rest of the table speaks another. By the second helping of potatoes, the talk has covered the weather, the traffic on the way over and who’s working where. Then it stops, or it turns to the news.
This guide is for whoever is hosting, or bringing someone to, a Christmas table where people don’t share much history. It gives the table one word per course, a pass rule everyone agrees on before the food, and ten Christmas dinner conversation starters that work across ages and families. It works with the Thesis deck, the free online table, or a word written on the back of a place card.
Why a mixed table runs dry
A mixed table has fewer shared topics. Two families who met through a couple have the couple and the meal in common. A new partner has nothing yet. Three generations have different news, different music and different jobs. The safe topics are used up fast, and the topics left over are the ones people disagree on.
A word gives everyone the same starting point without needing the same history. Put “Home” in the middle of the table. A grandfather talks about a flat with a coal stove. A teenager talks about a group chat. The new partner talks about a kitchen in another country. Nobody needs to know the family’s stories to join in, and each answer is something the others haven’t heard.
Set it up before the food
Three decisions before dinner make the rest easy. Each one is easier to agree on before anyone sits down.
- The pass rule. The Thesis rules open with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” At a family table, the plainest version is that anyone can pass on any word, with no reason given.
- The phones. A basket by the door, or a shelf away from the plates.
- One word per course. Pick three words before dinner: one for the starter, one for the main, one for dessert. Write them on place cards or keep the deck by your plate.
The phones decision has some evidence behind it. In a study with more than 300 people, groups of friends and family went out for a restaurant meal, and some were asked to keep their phones on the table while others put them away. People with their phones out felt more distracted and enjoyed their time with their companions less (Dwyer et al. 2018). A basket costs nothing and doesn’t single anyone out.
One word per course
Between courses is where a family table goes quiet. The plates are cleared, someone is in the kitchen, and the people left at the table look at their glasses. That’s the moment for the word.
Each turn follows the rule card:
- Whoever suggested the game goes first.
- Draw a card. Choose a side: the idea or the thing.
- Roll the die.
- Look at the word from that side. Say as much or as little as feels right.
- The others ask what they’re curious about, gently, without judging.
- Hand the die to the left.
The die has six faces, each a plain word: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” With a large family, one round per course is enough. Not everyone has to go, and the round can move with the people who stay at the table.
The thing side helps guests who don’t know the family yet. A new partner may not want to talk about Family in front of people they’ve only met tonight. Bread is easier: a bakery near their school, a loaf someone made every Sunday. Things lead to places and people, and the idea can come back by itself.
When the talk turns to politics
The cost of political differences at a holiday table has been measured. Researchers used anonymized smartphone location data from Thanksgiving 2016 in the US. Dinners where guests came from precincts that voted for opposite parties were 30–50 minutes shorter than same-party dinners (Chen and Rohla 2018). The data are American and show shorter dinners, not what was said at them.
The word on the table is a way back. When the news comes up, the host can say “We’re still on Home. Who hasn’t had a go?” That moves the talk without telling anyone they were wrong. The rule card covers the rest: “Every view is welcome, especially one that differs from yours.” A story about a spoon, a kitchen or a grandmother leaves room for every view.
Bringing in the new person
The new partner, the in-laws who flew in, the cousin’s friend from abroad: they get the most from a follow-up question. In three studies of live conversations, people who asked more questions, particularly follow-up questions, were better liked by their partners. The same studies found that people didn’t expect asking questions to make them more liked (Huang et al. 2017). That may be why a guest can get one question about their job and nothing after it.
The rule card gives three follow-ups that fit any word and any guest:
What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?
A short answer is fine. The rule card says “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.” One follow-up from someone at the table tells the guest their answer was heard.
Ten questions for the Christmas table
If you’d rather start with questions than cards, these work for adults and teenagers at the same table. They’re sorted from light to deeper:
- What did Christmas dinner look like where you grew up?
- What’s one dish you’d bring to this table from your own family?
- Who did the cooking when you were a child?
- What’s a family tradition you didn’t understand until later?
- What’s one object in your parents’ home you’d recognize anywhere?
- Which relative told the best stories?
- Where did you spend your strangest Christmas?
- What’s a tradition you’d like to start?
- What did you learn from this family that you didn’t expect?
- What would you like to remember about this year’s table?
Two or three of these between courses can fill an evening. Questions 2 and 9 work well when two families are meeting for the first time.
Three cards for a Christmas table
Each of these cards reads in its own way at a mixed family table.
Family has Bread on its other side. At a table of two families, the idea side shows how differently each one works: who calls whom, who hosts, who’s in charge of the gravy. Bread is the gentle side for guests. Guests from any country can talk about the bread they grew up with and who bought it.
Home has Spoon on its other side. It fits a table where people grew up in different places or different countries. Each person’s home is different, so nobody’s answer competes. The spoon side goes to kitchens: a wooden spoon, a stirring job given to the youngest, a drawer that always stuck.
Tradition has Fridge on its other side. Christmas is full of traditions, and two families at one table may have two sets of them. The card turns that into stories instead of a negotiation. The fridge side is lighter: magnets, drawings, a note that stayed up for years.
Finish with the last round
When the dessert plates are empty, end the way every game of Thesis ends: “When the group is ready to stop, finish with one last round: each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” At a mixed table, that round gives the two families something to say about each other out loud.
Pick your three words this week and write them on the place cards. See the rules and the box, or open the online table on a phone in the middle. The cards above have their own pages: Family, Home and Tradition. For more on playing with a group, see Thesis for friends, and for the studies behind the deck, see the research page. For the quiet moments at other dinners, see how to handle an awkward silence at a dinner party. Related: dinner party conversation topics, from light to deep. See also things to talk about at dinner with your partner: keep the table, change the format.