You put anger on the agenda for an ethics seminar, an adult education class, or a reading group. The first answers come fast and they’re the safe ones: anger is bad, count to ten, breathe. A few minutes later the room has agreed with itself and nobody has said anything they believe. The questions that keep a room talking ask what anger is for, when it’s fair, and what it changes.
This post is for the person leading that discussion with adults. It gives three findings that make good openers, 12 questions about anger, a plan for one class session, and three words from the Thesis deck that open the topic from different sides. It’s a discussion guide for a class or group, with no treatment advice. You can use the Thesis deck, the free online table, or the word Anger written on a card.
Start with a claim the room can argue with
A room argues better about a finding than about a slogan. Three studies give a group something specific to push against, and none of them calls anger good or bad.
Anger can be chosen. Maya Tamir, Caitlin Mitchell, and James Gross asked people to pick activities before a task. When people expected a confrontational task, they preferred activities that would make them angrier. They didn’t do this when the task was nonconfrontational. Anger also improved performance on the confrontational task only (Tamir et al. 2008). The question for the room: when have you wanted to stay angry?
Anger moves other people. Gerben van Kleef, Carsten De Dreu, and Antony Manstead ran negotiations over a computer. Participants made more concessions to an opponent described as angry than to one described as happy (van Kleef et al. 2004). The question for the room: is it fair that anger works?
Anger changes how risk looks. Jennifer Lerner and colleagues ran a national field experiment with 973 Americans. Fear raised people’s estimates of terrorism risk. Anger lowered them. This held for emotions stirred up in the study and for emotions people already felt (Lerner et al. 2003). The question for the room: what does anger make easier to ignore?
Each of these is one study, read from its abstract. They work as openers because they leave room for disagreement, and a class can ask what they’d need to see before believing them.
12 discussion questions about anger
These questions ask for opinions and stories, and none of them asks anyone to confess. Read one aloud, give people a minute, and take answers from anyone who wants to speak.
- What were you allowed to be angry about as a child, and what weren’t you?
- How did the adults in your home show anger: loud, quiet, or not at all?
- Is there anything you think a person ought to be angry about?
- When has anger helped you say something you’d held back for a long time?
- Is it fair that anger can get a person their way?
- Where’s the line between anger and cruelty?
- Which is harder for you to be around: someone who shouts or someone who goes silent?
- Do people judge anger differently depending on who shows it?
- Can a group be angry, or only the people in it?
- What’s something that made you angry ten years ago and doesn’t now?
- Is it possible to forgive someone while you’re still angry at them?
- What would you want someone to do when you’re angry?
Questions 3, 5, 8, and 9 can split a room, which gives a class something to argue about. “Every view is welcome, especially one that differs from yours.” That line is from the Thesis rules. Questions 1, 2, and 10 ask for memories, so they suit a group that has met a few times.
A plan for one class session
A plan with a clear opening and a clear end keeps a heavy topic from running over. This one fits a single class period, and a large group can split into small groups.
- Agreement. Say out loud that anyone can pass, no reason needed, and that nobody is asked about a specific fight or a specific person in the room.
- One finding. Read one of the three studies above. Ask the room whether it matches what they’ve seen.
- Pairs. Each pair picks two questions from the list and talks.
- Whole group. Ask each pair for the answer that surprised them. Then open one of the questions that split the room.
- Close. Each person names one thing they heard from someone else today.
The pair step can carry a lot. Someone who wouldn’t speak first in a large room may say more to one person. The whole-group step then hears ideas that were already tested once.
Keep the talk on anger, away from anyone at the table
Anger questions can drift toward a person in the room, a colleague, a classmate, or a partner sitting across the table. A short agreement at the start keeps that from happening. The Thesis rules put it first: “Before you start, decide together how passing works.” They also say: “What is said at the table stays there.”
Two small habits help. Ask for the situation instead of the name: “a coworker” is enough. And treat a short answer as finished. “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.” If someone’s story is clearly about more than a class can hold, thank them and move on. You know your group and its limits, and you decide how far a topic goes.
Three words that open anger from different sides
A single word on a card can carry a discussion longer than a list of questions. These three come from the Thesis deck. Each card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other.
Anger has a Ring on its other side. The idea side suits a group that wants to argue about when anger is fair. The Ring side brings stories of promises: a wedding, a ring handed down, a promise someone broke. A class can reach anger through the Ring without anyone naming it, because a broken promise can be where anger starts.
Fairness has a Sweater on its other side. Many of the questions above come back to fairness: who gets to be angry, and who gets heard. The Fairness side turns the talk to the rules people grew up with. The Sweater side can bring a hand-me-down, a uniform, or a gift that didn’t fit, and the stories can turn to who got what.
Forgiveness has a Door on its other side. Question 11 asks whether forgiveness and anger can live together, and this card gives that question a whole round. The Door side brings stories of a door slammed, a door left open, a door someone waited behind. If the word lands too close for someone, they can choose the Door, or pass.
Look at the word from six sides
The Thesis die adds a second way in. Its six faces are MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” Roll it and say what Anger brings up from there. The same word gives a different answer on each roll, so a class hears anger as a memory, a value, and a plan for later in one session.
The rules for a round are short. “Say as much or as little as you like. The others ask, gently.” Then hand the die to the left. The rule card gives three follow-ups that fit every word: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? With anger, the third one asks whether a view has changed over time, which can open a lot.
Run one round at your next session
Write the word Anger on a card. At your next class or group, say the pass agreement out loud, read the Tamir study, and ask question 3: is there anything a person ought to be angry about? Give the room one minute before anyone speaks. To finish, ask each person to name one thing they discovered about someone today.
See the rules and the box, or open the free online table. The cards above have their own pages: Anger, Fairness, and Forgiveness. For classrooms and workshops, see Thesis for teams and classes. For the studies behind the deck, see the research page. For another topic that splits a room in a useful way, see questions about money for discussion.