Your group meets every other Thursday: people who moved to the city recently, a few who came for work, a few who came for a partner. The shared language is English, and for many in the room it’s a second one. You want one evening on belonging, and “Do you feel you belong here?” gets nods and silence. This guide gives a host of a newcomer, expat or integration group ten discussion questions about belonging, a session plan in four parts, and a way to start with home before anyone talks about fitting in.
The plan works with a word written on an index card. The examples use two cards from the Thesis deck, Home and Belonging, because each has an everyday object on its other side.
Why a direct question about belonging stalls
A question about belonging asks a newcomer to rate their own place in a group, in front of that group. The honest answer may be “not yet”, and saying it out loud can feel like a complaint about the people in the room. So people may give the polite answer or pass.
A definition helps here. Bonnie Hagerty and colleagues described a sense of belonging as the experience of personal involvement in a system or environment, so that a person feels part of it (Hagerty et al. 1992). That definition points to places and systems, not only people. A newcomer can talk about a bakery, a tram line or a stairwell before they talk about the group. Those are easier answers, and they still count.
The need underneath is common to everyone at the table. Roy Baumeister and Mark Leary reviewed the evidence for a need to form and keep lasting relationships. They found that people form attachments readily under most conditions and resist ending them (Baumeister and Leary 1995). For someone who moved, that second half matters too. The bonds they left behind are still there, and they’re part of the answer.
Start with home, then move to belonging
Home comes first because it has a concrete answer. Everyone can name a kitchen, a street or a smell. Belonging comes second, once the room has heard a few homes and knows what kind of answers are welcome.
Home sits on the back of Spoon. For a newcomer group, the spoon side is a gentle way in: a dish someone cooks to feel at home, or a spoon they packed when they moved. The Home side can hold two places at once. A player can say where home was, where it is now, or that it’s somewhere in between, and each of those is a full turn.
Belonging sits on the back of Headphones. That object fits newcomers well. Headphones are what people wear on the commute in a city where they don’t yet know anyone, and what they take off when someone starts talking to them. A player can describe a place where they kept them on, or the first time they took them off without thinking.
Ten discussion questions about belonging
Pick three or four for one evening. The first few work as openers, the later ones suit a group that has met several times.
- Where in this city did you first feel you knew your way around?
- What’s a small routine here that’s starting to feel like yours?
- Which place from before do you still picture when someone says “home”?
- When did someone here first remember your name?
- What do you do to feel at home in a new flat?
- Where do you feel like a guest, and where like a regular?
- What did you belong to before you moved that you still miss?
- Which language do you belong in, and has that changed?
- What would tell you that you belong here a little more than last year?
- Who in this room helped you feel less new, and how?
Question 10 works best late in the evening, when people already know each other. In a multilingual group, question 8 can open a longer conversation, so leave time after it.
Normalize the early doubt
A newcomer can read an awkward moment as proof they don’t fit. Gregory Walton and Geoffrey Cohen tested a short intervention with first-year college students. It changed how students read early setbacks, so they no longer saw them as a sign they didn’t belong, and over three years it raised the grades and reported well-being of the Black students in the study (Walton and Cohen 2011). The study was with college students, not with migrants. It still suggests something a host can do: let people hear that doubts about fitting in are common at the start.
In a newcomer group, the people who arrived earlier can do this better than the host. Ask one of them to take an early turn on question 9. Their answer shows the newer people that “not yet” was once their answer too.
A session plan in four parts
The plan has four parts and fits a regular meeting slot. Keep the two middle rounds the longest.
- Agreement. The group decides how passing works. The Thesis rules put it in one line: “Before you start, decide together how passing works.”
- Home round. Each person takes a turn on Home or Spoon, or on question 3 or 5.
- Belonging round. Each person takes a turn on Belonging or Headphones, or on one of questions 1, 2, 6 or 9.
- Last round. Each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.
A short answer is a full turn. The Thesis rule reads: “Say as much or as little as you like. The others ask, gently.” For follow-ups, three short questions do most of the work: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?
When the shared language is a second language
One word on a card is easier to answer than a long question in a second language. A player can repeat the word, point to the object, and say one sentence. If someone doesn’t know a word, the group explains it before the turn. That explanation can become part of the turn.
Let people use a word from their own language when English runs out. Ask what it means, then let them go on. In a group about belonging, a word with no English translation is a fair answer.
Community sits on the back of Mirror. It’s a good third card for a group that meets often. A player can talk about a community they had before the move, or this group itself. The mirror side asks for less: a mirror in a first flat, or the moment of seeing yourself in a new place.
Keep it a conversation
You know your group and its purpose, and you decide how deep an evening goes. Thesis is a conversation format and makes no clinical claims. What is said at the table stays there, and that line is worth saying out loud in a group where people may see each other at work or in class.
Try it at your next meeting
The online table works on a shared screen or a phone passed around the circle.
The die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” Rolled on Belonging, the same word gives a newcomer six ways to answer, and none of them has to be about this city.
Before your next meeting, write Home on one index card and Belonging on another. Start with Home, and take the first turn yourself.
For more on running the game with a group, see Thesis for teams and classes. The cards above have their own pages: Belonging, Home and Community. You can play online for free, see the rules and the box, or read the research behind the deck. For a group with members aged 16–19, see discussion questions for older teens.