You have a blank page, a wedding date, and a draft that keeps coming out the same: “I promise to love you, to be loyal, to be there for you.” Every word in it is true. Read it out loud and it could be anyone’s vow to anyone.
This post is for engaged couples who are writing their own vows. It gives you one evening of talk before either of you writes a line. You pick the three or four words your vows will lean on and find out what each of you means by them. Then you write separately, and the vows stay a surprise until the day. Bring a pen, paper, and an evening. Cards help, and a word written on a napkin works too.
Why vow drafts sound alike
The big vow words are ones you use every day and rarely define. Love, loyalty, trust, and home feel settled because both of you say them often. Loyalty can mean “you take my side in public” to one person and “you tell me when I’m wrong” to the other. Both are promises. They’re different promises, and a vow that says “I’ll be loyal” makes neither of them.
You may have read the tip “be specific, tell a story.” It’s hard to follow at a desk on your own. You remember the story of how you met, but you may not know which part of it mattered to your partner. Writing alone means guessing what the other person wants to hear. A talk first replaces the guess with their own words.
Talking first keeps the surprise
If you want the vows to be a surprise, this step can feel like a risk. The evening shares meanings, not lines. You’ll hear what home means to your partner. You won’t hear the sentence they’ll say about it on the day.
The surprise moves somewhere better. When your partner hears your vow, they recognize a scene they told you months ago, now turned into a promise. Your line could only have been written for them.
One evening before you write
This format works at the kitchen table, on a walk, or on a long drive. Do it a few weeks before the vows are due, so there’s time to write without pressure.
- Pick three or four words. Choose the ones you expect to say in your vows. Loyalty, Trust, and Home are a good start. Love is the obvious fourth. Write each on a scrap of paper, or draw cards from the online table.
- Agree how passing works. Before you start, decide together how either of you can pass on a word. No reason needed.
- One of you takes the first word. Say what it means through a scene, not a definition: a moment, a person, a place, an object. Say as much or as little as feels right.
- The other asks one follow-up, then listens. Short, open questions work best.
- Swap. The second person takes the same word somewhere else.
- Each of you writes a note. Keep it private, in your own notebook. Write the scene your partner told and any phrase they used. This isn’t a vow yet.
- Move to the next word. Stop when it feels done, even if one word is left.
If you have the Thesis die, roll it before each word: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. Look at the word from that side.
The Thesis rule card has three follow-up questions that fit any word:
What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?
The third one matters most for vows. A vow is a promise about the future, and the meanings you bring to it may come from the marriages you grew up around. Hearing how a word changed for your partner can tell you what they’re hoping it will mean now.
Three words for your vows
These three cards from the Thesis deck hold promises a vow can make: staying, being relied on, and building a life in one place.
Loyalty has Camera on its other side. Loyalty is a word where the two of you may find out you mean different things. For one of you it may mean standing by the other no matter what. For the other it may mean saying the hard thing because you’re on their side. Camera is a good second door: who takes the photos in your families, and who is never in them. At a wedding that question has a literal answer.
Trust has Window on its other side. Ask when your partner first trusted you with something, and what it was. The answer can make a better vow line than any promise about trust in general. Window can lead to a childhood bedroom, a view from a first apartment, or a window someone left open for them.
Home has Spoon on its other side. A vow line like “let’s build a home together” can hold two different pictures. One of you may picture an apartment. The other may picture a kitchen, a town, or a group of people at a table. Spoon is an easy start when the big word feels too big: a soup someone made, a drawer in a grandparent’s house, a spoon carried through every move.
Questions for the evening
If you’d rather start with a question than a word, these keep the talk on meaning and away from wedding logistics:
- What did loyalty look like in the house you grew up in?
- When did you first trust me with something?
- What’s a promise someone made to you that they kept?
- Where did you feel at home before we met?
- What does a home need for you: a place, a person, a routine?
- What’s something small I do that feels like love to you?
- Which couple you know would you like us to resemble, in one way?
- What would you like me to promise that you haven’t asked for?
- What word do you expect in my vows, and what do you hope I mean by it?
- Is there a word you’d rather leave out of your vows?
Use two or three of these, not all ten. Follow each answer with one of the three follow-ups.
From notes to vows
Now write, each on your own. A simple structure works: for each word, one sentence about what it means to your partner, then one promise that follows from it. Use their scene, not your summary of it.
Here’s the difference. A general line says, “I promise to make a home with you.” A line built from the evening says, “You told me home was your grandmother’s kitchen with the radio on. I promise a kitchen with the radio on.” The second could only be said to one person.
Keep the big promises next to small ones you can keep on an ordinary Tuesday. Read the draft out loud once. If a sentence sounds like a card from a shop, go back to your notes and find the scene it came from.
When a word opens a disagreement
A word can turn up a real difference. Loyalty can show that one of you puts family first and the other puts the couple first. Home can show you want to live in different cities years from now. That’s worth knowing before the wedding, and it doesn’t need settling that night.
Set it aside and agree when you’ll come back to it. The rule card puts it this way: “Every view is welcome, especially one that differs from yours.” If the difference is about money, how to talk about money with your partner uses the same start-with-the-word approach. And if one of you has little to say about a word, that’s fine too: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”
Start tonight
Write Loyalty on a scrap of paper and leave it on the table. After dinner, ask your partner what loyalty looked like in the house they grew up in. Write down the scene in your own notebook. Then end the way a game of Thesis ends: each of you names one thing you found out about the other today.
The three cards have their own pages: Loyalty, Trust, and Home. For more on playing as a couple, see Thesis for couples. To see the cards and die, see the box.