I hate small talk: what to talk about with friends

You meet friends for dinner. By dessert you’ve covered the weather, a new series, rent prices, and someone’s commute. Everyone was nice. You walk home feeling like you spent the evening with people you know by sight.

The fix is smaller than it sounds. Keep the catch-up, because it does real work. Then put one word on the table and let each person take it somewhere. This post explains why the evening stalls, and gives a format that fits into the second half of any dinner.

Small talk is fine. The evening stalls there

Talk about the news and the weather isn’t the problem by itself. A study of daily conversations started with 486 adults and pooled them with three more samples. Life satisfaction was moderately associated with substantive conversations, and showed no reliable association with small talk (Milek et al. 2018). In that data, small talk showed no link either way.

Friendships are a different story. Jeffrey Hall followed 112 first-year students over nine weeks as they got to know new people. Catching up on each other’s lives, joking around, and serious conversations went with growing closer. Small talk about current events, pets, sports, movies, or music went with drifting apart (Hall 2019, as summarized by Greater Good).

So the line that matters runs between “what happened in the world” and “what happened to you.” The first fills time. The second is how friends keep up with each other.

Why nobody goes deeper first

Everyone at the table may want more, and nobody moves. Michael Kardas, Amit Kumar, and Nicholas Epley found a reason for that. In a series of experiments, conversations between strangers felt less awkward, and created more connection and happiness, than the people in them expected. People were especially likely to overestimate how awkward a deep conversation would be. Their guesses got more accurate with close friends and partners (Kardas et al. 2021).

Friends know each other better than strangers do, so the fear is smaller. It’s still there. Asking “what are you afraid of these days” over pasta feels like a speech. A word on a card takes that weight off. Nobody chose the topic, so nobody has to defend it.

A format for the second half of dinner

This works for 2–6 friends at a table, a bar, or a video call. It takes no setup beyond one word.

  1. Catch up first. Go around the table on each person’s week. Ask about their life, and let the world news wait.
  2. Put one word in the middle. Draw a card, or write a word on a napkin: Home, Rest, or Curiosity.
  3. Let the first person pick a way in. The idea side goes deep. The thing side is the light door: Spoon, Clock, or Sewing machine.
  4. Ask one more question. The rule card gives three: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?
  5. Pass the word on. The next person takes the same word somewhere else.

Agree on passing before the first word. The Thesis rules open with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” A pass keeps the evening easy for the friend who came to unwind.

The deck adds a die with six plain words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” One word turns into six starts. If nobody brought a deck, open the free table on a phone.

Roll the die

Three words that skip the weather

Each of these cards has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other.

Home
Spoon
Card 49: Home / Spoon. Tap to turn it over.

Home has Spoon on its other side. Home pulls out first flats, parents’ kitchens, and the place that felt right. The spoon side starts at the table you’re sitting at: the soup someone’s grandmother made, the drawer where the cutlery never matched.

Rest
Clock
Card 38: Rest / Clock. Tap to turn it over.

Rest has Clock on its other side. Friends who meet after work already brought this word with them. Ask what rest looks like for each person, and the answers run from a long run to a whole Sunday in bed. The clock side goes to time: alarms, school bells, and the hour that drags.

Curiosity
Sewing machine
Card 19: Curiosity / Sewing machine. Tap to turn it over.

Curiosity has Sewing machine on its other side. Ask what someone wanted to know as a child, and what they’re reading about now. The sewing machine brings up who in the family made things by hand.

Eight questions for one word

If the group prefers questions to cards, pick any word and use these. They run from light to deeper:

  1. Where did this word show up in your week?
  2. What object reminds you of it?
  3. Who in your family had the strongest opinion about it?
  4. What did it mean to you at 12?
  5. When did you last argue about it?
  6. What would you like more of, connected to it?
  7. Has your view of it changed in the last five years?
  8. What would you like it to mean ten years from now?

A short answer is fine. The rule card says it plainly: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”

Try it at the next dinner

Pick one word before you leave the house. Catch up on each other’s lives first. Then say the word out loud and ask who wants to start. At the end, borrow the last round from the rules: “each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.”

The cards above have their own pages: Home, Rest, and Curiosity. Play a round on the online table, or see the rules and the box. For a regular group, see Thesis for friends. The studies behind the deck are on the research page. If the follow-up is where you get stuck, read how to have deep conversations where both people talk. For what the research says about small talk, see is small talk bad?.