Meaning in life: having it and looking for it

Your life looks fine from the outside: work you can do, people you love, a place to live. And you still catch yourself looking for something that would make it feel like it matters. It’s easy to read that search as proof that something is missing.

Research on meaning in life says the two can sit side by side. This guide explains the two scales psychologists use, in plain words, then gives ten questions and a way to talk them over with a friend. You can use the Thesis deck, the free online table, or a word written on a scrap of paper.

The short answer

Psychologists Michael Steger, Patricia Frazier, Shigehiro Oishi, and Matthew Kaler built a 10-item questionnaire on meaning in life. It scores two things apart. The first is presence: the sense that your life already means something. The second is search: the drive to find meaning, or more of it. In their data the two were only slightly related, so a high score on one says little about the other (Steger et al. 2006).

So looking for meaning is a separate state, and a person can be in it while their life already feels meaningful. The authors report that their data gave little support to the idea that people search only when life feels meaningless.

What the two scales ask

The questionnaire has five statements for each scale. People rate each one from 1, “Absolutely Untrue”, to 7, “Absolutely True”. One presence item reads “My life has a clear sense of purpose.” One search item reads “I am searching for meaning in my life.” Read both and you may notice you can agree with each of them on the same day.

The researchers tested the questionnaire in three studies. Most participants were Midwestern undergraduate students, around 20 years old on average. In the third study, students also asked friends and family members to fill it in about them. Scores held fairly steady when people answered again one month later (Steger et al. 2006). That’s a narrow group, so the results are a starting map with blank areas in it.

Four places you might be

The authors sketch four combinations of the two scores, borrowing names from research on identity. They offer it as an idea for later research to test.

  • Low presence, low search. Life doesn’t feel meaningful, and the question isn’t on your mind.
  • High presence, low search. Life feels meaningful, and you aren’t looking further.
  • Low presence, high search. Life feels empty of meaning, and you’re actively looking.
  • High presence, high search. Life feels meaningful, and you’re still looking for more.

The authors also note that people move between these places. Their example is a person who finds meaning in training for a first marathon, finishes it, and starts looking for the next thing without feeling that life is empty. Another of their examples is the expected birth of a child in a happy relationship: a lot of meaning and a lot of searching at once.

Why the search can still feel heavy

The two scales didn’t relate to well-being in the same way. People with higher presence scores reported more life satisfaction and positive emotions, and fewer symptoms of depression. Search scores were mostly unrelated to those measures, with small to medium links to negative emotions and depression (Steger et al. 2006). The authors point to an older idea: a search that stays frustrated may be distressing.

This helps explain why a common piece of advice falls flat. “Find your purpose” assumes you’re on the low-presence side. If you already have meaning and are still looking, that advice sends you hunting for something you have. A more useful question is what the search is for: more sources of meaning, a deeper sense of the ones you have, or a replacement for one that faded. The paper names all three as possible reasons.

Ten questions about meaning in life

These questions ask for stories, which can be easier to answer than “What’s the meaning of your life?” Answer them on paper, or have a friend ask them. A place, a year, and a person make an answer concrete.

  1. When did your life last feel like it mattered, and where were you?
  2. What gave your days meaning five years ago that doesn’t now?
  3. What are you looking for at the moment, in one sentence?
  4. Who do you know who seems settled about what matters to them?
  5. When did finishing something leave you looking for the next thing?
  6. What would you keep doing if nobody noticed it?
  7. Which part of your week would you defend first if it were taken away?
  8. When did your search start, and what was happening then?
  9. What did your parents seem to live for?
  10. What would tell you the search had found something?

Look at your answers to questions 1 and 3 side by side. One describes presence, the other describes search. If both have answers, you may be in the fourth place on the list above.

Look at one word from six sides

A single word can do the work of a long question. The Thesis die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” The same word gives a different story from each face, and the stories show what you have and what you’re still after.

Passion
Guitar
Card 13: Passion / Guitar. Tap to turn it over.

Passion has a Guitar on its other side. Choose Passion when you want to talk about what used to pull you in and whether it still does. Choose the Guitar when an object is easier: an instrument you played at 15, or one you bought and never learned. Lost passion and the search for meaning can show up in the same story.

Work
Stone
Card 27: Work / Stone. Tap to turn it over.

Work has a Stone on its other side. Work can be where the question of meaning gets loud, because it fills so many hours. The Work side brings up a job that mattered or one that didn’t. The Stone is slower and heavier: something you carried, built, or kept.

Hope
Teddy bear
Card 32: Hope / Teddy bear. Tap to turn it over.

Hope has a Teddy bear on its other side. Hope points at the search part: what you’re still waiting to find. The Teddy bear points back at childhood, to what felt safe and important before anyone asked you about purpose. If either side lands too close, pass.

Talk it over with a friend

A friend can hear which of your two answers carries more weight. Two or three people at a table after dinner is enough. Before you start, agree how passing works. The Thesis rules open with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.”

Roll the die

Then take turns:

  1. Draw a card. Choose a side: the idea or the thing.
  2. Roll the die.
  3. Look at the word from that side. Say as much or as little as feels right.
  4. The others ask what they’re curious about, gently, without judging.
  5. Hand the die to the left.

The rule card gives three follow-up questions: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? The third one fits meaning in life best. It turns a single answer into a timeline, and timelines show the moments when the search started or paused.

“There are no right answers.” That line matters here, because the questionnaire itself tells people the same thing.

What to do tonight

Write two lines on a piece of paper. On the first, write one thing that already gives your life meaning. On the second, write what you’re still looking for. Show both to someone you trust and let them ask one follow-up. “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”

See the rules and the box, or open the free online table. The cards above have their own pages: Passion, Work, and Hope. For playing with a few close people, see Thesis for friends. For the studies behind the deck, see the research page. For more questions like these, grouped by idea, see deep questions about life.