Meeting science glossary: eight terms, each with its source

Meeting science is the research on what happens in workplace meetings and what it changes afterward. The terms below come up when facilitators, managers and journalists write about it: pre-meeting talk, check-in, check-out, functional interaction, complaining, turn-taking, psychological safety and the liking gap. Each entry gives a plain definition, the study it comes from and where the finding stops. The last section shows how to try three of the terms in your next meeting with a single word.

How to read the entries

Each definition is short enough to quote. Where a term comes from a study, the entry names the study, its sample and its design. Several of these studies measure links between things people report or do. A link means two things go together. It doesn’t show that one causes the other, and the entries say so where the authors say so. Two terms, check-in and check-out, are facilitation practices with no single study behind them, and their entries describe the practice only.

Pre-meeting talk

Definition. Pre-meeting talk is the conversation in the room or on the call before the meeting formally starts. Allen, Lehmann-Willenbrock and Landowski sorted it into four types: small talk, work talk, meeting preparatory talk and shop talk.

What the study found. In an online survey of 252 working adults, pre-meeting small talk predicted how effective people rated the meeting, even after accounting for good meeting procedures. The link was stronger for less extraverted participants (Allen et al. 2014).

Where it stops. The design was cross-sectional and correlational. The authors themselves call for experiments to test whether pre-meeting talk causes better meetings.

Check-in

Definition. A check-in is a short round at the start of a meeting in which each person says something before the agenda begins. It can be one word, one sentence or an answer to one prompt. It differs from pre-meeting talk in one way: it’s planned, and everyone gets a turn.

What it’s for. A facilitator can use it to hear every voice once before decisions are made. No study in this glossary tests check-ins directly. The pre-meeting talk study above is the closest evidence, and it measured unplanned small talk.

Check-out

Definition. A check-out is the closing round: each person names one thing before the meeting ends, such as a takeaway, a next step or a word for how the meeting went. The Thesis rules end a game the same way: “each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” For prompts, see check-out questions for meetings.

Functional interaction

Definition. Functional interaction is the talk that moves a meeting’s work forward, such as problem-solving and action planning. The term comes from studies that code every statement in recorded meetings.

What the study found. Kauffeld and Lehmann-Willenbrock videotaped 92 regular team meetings and coded the interaction. Teams with more functional interaction were more satisfied with their meetings. Better meetings went with higher team productivity, and constructive meeting processes were related to organizational success 2.5 years later (Kauffeld and Lehmann-Willenbrock 2012).

Complaining and criticizing

Definition. In the same coding scheme, criticizing others and complaining count as dysfunctional communication.

What the study found. In the 92 meetings, these statements had significant negative relationships with satisfaction, productivity and organizational success. The negative effects were larger than the positive effects of functional interaction (Kauffeld and Lehmann-Willenbrock 2012).

Turn-taking equality

Definition. Turn-taking equality describes how evenly speaking turns are spread across a group. A group where two people do most of the talking scores low.

What the study found. In two studies with 699 people working in groups of two to five, Woolley and colleagues found a general “collective intelligence” factor that explained a group’s performance on a wide variety of tasks. It wasn’t strongly correlated with members’ average or maximum individual intelligence. It was correlated with members’ average social sensitivity, the equality of conversational turn-taking and the proportion of women in the group (Woolley et al. 2010).

Silence
Tree
Card 16: Silence / Tree. Tap to turn it over.

Silence has Tree on its back. It suits this entry because turn-taking is also about who stays quiet and why. Someone might talk about the pause before they speak in a meeting. Someone else might pick the tree and describe a place they go to think.

Psychological safety

Definition. Amy Edmondson defined team psychological safety as “a shared belief held by members of a team that the team is safe for interpersonal risk taking.” In a meeting, that risk can be asking a basic question, naming a mistake or disagreeing with a senior person.

What the study found. In a field study of 51 work teams in a manufacturing company, psychological safety was associated with learning behavior, and learning behavior mediated its link with team performance (Edmondson 1999). For a list of everyday moments, see psychological safety examples.

Trust
Window
Card 34: Trust / Window. Tap to turn it over.

Trust has Window on its back. For a team, Trust can be read as who people go to with a mistake, or what made them trust a colleague the first time. The Window side gives a lighter way in: the view from someone’s desk, or a window they look out of on calls.

Liking gap

Definition. The liking gap is the difference between how much people think others like them after a conversation and how much those others report liking them. The guess comes out lower than the report.

What the study found. Mastroianni, Cooney, Boothby and Reece showed the gap in conversations among small groups and in engineering teams working on a project together. In a sample of working adults, it was linked to teams’ ability to work together. The gap was largest between peers, and it came partly from people focusing on the negative parts of the impression they made (Mastroianni et al. 2021). The longer version is in the liking gap at work.

Belonging
Headphones
Card 44: Belonging / Headphones. Tap to turn it over.

Belonging has Headphones on its back. It fits the liking gap because both are about where someone thinks they stand in a group. Someone might talk about the first week on a team. Someone else might pick the headphones and describe what they listen to on the way to work.

Where the terms sit in one meeting

The eight terms map onto the order of a meeting. Pre-meeting talk happens before the start. The check-in opens the meeting. Functional interaction, complaining and turn-taking describe the agenda itself. The check-out closes it. Psychological safety and the liking gap run underneath all of it and show up in what people say, and don’t say, the next time.

Questions for checking your own meetings

These questions turn the glossary into a quick review of a meeting you ran this week:

  1. Did people talk before the start, or arrive at the last second?
  2. Did everyone speak once before the first decision?
  3. Who spoke the most, and who didn’t speak at all?
  4. How much of the time went to complaints about things nobody in the room can change?
  5. Did the meeting end with a next step someone owns?
  6. Did anyone ask a question that could have sounded basic?
  7. Did anyone mention a mistake of their own?
  8. Did the meeting end with a round, or with people dropping off the call?

Trying three terms with one word

A one-word round covers the check-in, turn-taking and the check-out at once. Write a word on a sticky note or in the chat. Go around in a fixed order, so every person gets one turn, and say before the first turn that anyone can pass. The Thesis rules put the pass agreement first: “Before you start, agree together how passing works.”

With the deck or the online table, each person draws a card, chooses the idea or the thing and rolls the die. The die has six words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” The others can ask a short, open question, such as What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?

Roll the die

Pick one entry from this glossary and watch for it in your next meeting. Count the turns, or note how the meeting ended. The cards above have their own pages: Silence, Trust and Belonging. For more on running it at work, see Thesis for teams and classes. For the sources behind the deck, see the research, and for the rules and the box, see Thesis. Related: conversation psychology terms: a short glossary with sources.