Your reading group picked death as next month’s theme. You have a handout and a room of people who came to talk. The first question goes out, someone says “it’s natural,” someone else agrees, and the room goes quiet a few minutes in.
This guide gives a seminar leader or reading group host ten philosophical questions about death that keep a room talking. Each question is tied to one classic argument, so people argue with an idea before anyone talks about themselves. Personal stories come later, and only for those who choose them.
The short answer
The questions that hold a seminar together have an argument behind them. “What do you think about death?” invites a mood. “Can something be bad for you if you never experience it?” invites a position, and a position can be tested by the next person at the table.
Four arguments do most of the work. They come from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on death, which is a good shared reading if your group wants one text before the session. Each one gives a short claim that people can accept, reject, or repair.
Four arguments to start from
Epicurus: death is nothing to us. Epicurus held that only sensations are good or bad for us, and death isn’t a sensation. A person and their death never overlap. The encyclopedia gives his line as “when we are, death is not, and when death is present, then we are not.” The argument is tidy, and a group can have fun finding where it leaks.
Lucretius: the time before birth. Lucretius asked why the endless time before we were born doesn’t trouble us, if the endless time after death does. He called the two symmetrical. The encyclopedia notes one reply: birth starts a life going and death ends one, so the two may not mirror each other in what they do to us.
Nagel: what death takes away. The deprivation view says death harms us by making our life as a whole worse than it would have been. Thomas Nagel is cited as an early voice for this comparative view. On this view, the harm is in the goods a person would have had and won’t.
Williams: the problem with forever. Bernard Williams argued that endless life would be undesirable. The desires that give a life its shape would run out, and in the encyclopedia’s summary of his view, “oppressive boredom will set in.” Critics reply that a life without end need not turn dull.
A fifth puzzle sits under all four. If death is bad for the one who dies, when is it bad? Before, at the moment, after, or at no particular time? The encyclopedia lists five answers philosophers have given. It’s a good question for the end of the session, when the group has warmed up.
Ten philosophical questions about death
These questions follow the order of the arguments above. Read one aloud, give the room a moment of silence, and let the first answer be challenged before the second one comes.
- Can something be bad for you if you’ll never experience it?
- If Epicurus is right, why does the thought of dying still feel like something?
- Why does the time before your birth feel different from the time after your death?
- Would it matter to you if you’d been born 100 years earlier?
- What exactly does death take from a person who dies at 90?
- Is an early death worse because of what it takes, or because of what it interrupts?
- Would you choose to live forever if you could stop at any time?
- What would you still want after 500 years?
- When is death bad for the person who dies: before, at the moment, or after?
- Does knowing that life ends change what you choose to do with a Tuesday?
Questions 1–9 can stay in the abstract the whole time. Question 10 opens a door to the personal, and the group can leave it closed.
What thinking about death does to choices
One line of research looked at the step from question 9 to question 10. Philip Cozzolino and colleagues ran three studies on two ways of facing one’s own death. One was the mortality reminder used in earlier research, which had been shown to make people greedier. The other, called death reflection, was modeled on reports from people who nearly died. In the third study, among participants with a strong extrinsic value orientation, the mortality reminder led to greed, and death reflection led to unselfish behavior (Cozzolino et al. 2004).
This is one set of lab studies, read here from its abstract. It doesn’t say a seminar changes anyone. It suggests that the way a person thinks about death can point their choices in different directions. That’s a fair topic for the group itself: which of the two did your last session feel like?
A session plan
A seminar on death runs better with a clear shape. People know the abstract part comes first and the personal part is optional, so nobody feels cornered.
- One argument. Read one of the four arguments aloud. Ask the group to state it in their own words before anyone attacks it.
- The questions. Work through three or four of questions 1–9. Each answer has to respond to the one before it.
- A card round, optional. Move from the argument to a word, for anyone who wants to tell a story.
- Closing. Each person names one argument that moved them, or one point someone else made.
Before the session, agree how passing works. A pass needs no reason. If you want more on how to ask a hard question in a room, see the post on asking sensitive questions.
Move from the argument to a word
A single word lets people move from a position to an experience at their own speed. Thesis is a deck of 50 double-sided cards: an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other. A word written on an index card works too.
Death has a Phone on its other side. In a seminar, the idea side keeps the talk close to the arguments, and the die adds a side to look from. The Phone side gives a way in for anyone who wants one: a call that brought news, or a number still saved. A player who draws Death can turn it over or pass.
Hope has a Teddy bear on its other side. Hope pairs well with Williams. If forever would be tedious, what does a person hope for in a life that ends? The Teddy bear side brings up childhood, and with it the age when someone first understood that people die. Freedom, another card in the deck, fits question 7: the choice to stop at any time is a kind of freedom.
The Thesis die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” For a seminar group, rolling the die gives each person a new angle on the same word, so the round doesn’t turn into a repeat of the debate.
The rule card puts it plainly: “Every view is welcome, especially one that differs from yours.” It also gives three follow-up questions that fit any word: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? The third one fits a seminar well. It asks whether a person’s view of death has changed, and when.
For the next session
Pick one argument from the four and send it to the group before the session, with question 1 and question 10 underneath. Ask each person to bring one objection. At the start of the session, read the objections aloud before anyone defends the argument.
The Thesis rules end with one last round: “each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” In a reading group, that round shows what people heard in each other, beyond what they read.
See the rules and the box, or open the free online table. For using the deck with a class or seminar, see Thesis for teams and classes. Word pages: Death, Hope, and Freedom. For where the words came from, see the research behind the deck. Related: questions about death and dying: 10 to talk through while there’s time. Related: philosophical questions about loneliness for a class or reading group.