You’re leading a class or a reading group, and this week’s theme is loneliness. The first question goes out. Someone says “everyone feels lonely sometimes,” a few people nod, and the talk drifts toward advice for getting out more.
This guide gives you ten philosophical questions about loneliness that keep a room on the idea. Each question rests on one of three ways philosophers describe loneliness, so people argue with a view before anyone talks about their own life. A personal round comes at the end, for those who want it.
The short answer
A philosophical question about loneliness asks what loneliness is, before it asks how to fix it. “Are you lonely?” invites a confession. “Can you be lonely for a person you’ve never met?” invites a position that the next person can test.
The working definition is a good place to start. Psychologists Louise Hawkley and John Cacioppo describe loneliness as perceived social isolation (Hawkley and Cacioppo 2010). The key word is “perceived.” The definition is about how connected a person feels, which can differ from how many people are in the room. That gap is where the philosophy starts.
Three ways to think about loneliness
Philosopher Axel Seemann sorts accounts of what loneliness feels like into three groups (Seemann 2022). He argues that each one has something to contribute and that a fuller picture draws on all three. They make a good frame for a session, because each gives a short claim people can accept, reject, or repair.
Loneliness has an object. On the first view, loneliness is directed at something: an absent person or a missing kind of company. Seemann’s example is someone who is lonely because their partner has died. The loneliness points at one gap in the world.
Loneliness is a mood. On the second view, loneliness colors everything at once. Chronic loneliness can spread across every part of a person’s life, with no single object to point at. Here loneliness reads more like weather than like a missing piece.
Loneliness is a missing kind of contact. On the third view, loneliness comes from a lack of being part of shared, back-and-forth social life. Seemann notes that watching a crowd or following someone online doesn’t seem to reduce it. Being near people and being in contact with them come apart.
Seemann also marks where loneliness ends and solitude begins. Both can involve few social connections. The difference is in how the person experiences them: solitude is felt as good for you, loneliness as a lack. He adds that the two ideas were less clearly separated in the past.
Arendt and the political side
Hannah Arendt gives a group a fourth angle: loneliness as a feature of a society. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on Arendt describes her picture of the modern age as one where “isolation and loneliness have eroded human solidarity and all spontaneous forms of living together.” In her account, totalitarian movements drew their supporters from “rootless and lonely” masses.
The same entry adds a turn that a seminar can use. For Arendt, thinking itself is a lonely activity, yet the inner dialogue of thinking can stay in contact with the world as long as the world is represented in it. That raises a question worth a whole session: is the solitude needed for thought the same thing as the loneliness she saw in politics?
Ten philosophical questions about loneliness
These questions follow the order of the views above. Read one aloud, give the room a moment of silence, and let the first answer be challenged before the second one comes.
- If loneliness is perceived isolation, can a person be wrong about being lonely?
- Can you be lonely for someone you’ve never met?
- When a partner dies, is the loneliness about that person, or about the life that went with them?
- Can loneliness be a mood with no object at all?
- Why might a crowd, or a feed full of people, leave someone lonelier?
- What exactly is missing when two people sit together and still feel alone?
- Where is the line between solitude and loneliness, and who draws it?
- Can a whole society be lonely, or only the people in it?
- Is the solitude needed for thinking a kind of loneliness?
- When did being alone last feel good to you, and what made it different?
Questions 1–9 can stay in the abstract the whole time. Question 10 opens a door to the personal, and the group can leave it closed.
A session plan
A class on loneliness can run better with a clear shape. People know the abstract part comes first and the personal part is optional, so nobody has to describe their own loneliness to take part.
- One view. Read one of the three views, or the Arendt passage, aloud. Ask the group to restate it in their own words before anyone attacks it.
- The questions. Work through three or four of questions 1–9. Each answer has to respond to the one before it.
- A card round, optional. Move from the argument to a word, for anyone who wants to tell a story.
- Closing. Each person names one view that moved them, or one point someone else made.
Before the session, agree how passing works, and say that a pass needs no reason. For more on how to put a hard question to a room, see the post on asking sensitive questions.
Move from the argument to a word
A single word lets people move from a position to an experience at their own speed. Thesis is a deck of 50 double-sided cards: an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other. A word written on an index card works too.
Loneliness has a Perfume on its other side. In a class, the idea side keeps the talk close to the three views. The Perfume side gives a quieter way in: a scent that brings back a person who is gone, or a room that used to be full. That fits the first view, where loneliness points at someone in particular. A player who draws Loneliness can turn it over or pass.
Belonging has Headphones on its other side. It works as the opposite pole for questions 5 and 6. Where does belonging start, and can a person belong to a group they never talk to? The Headphones side brings up the solitude people choose in a crowded place, which leads straight back to question 7.
Silence has a Tree on its other side. It pairs with Arendt and question 9. A group can ask when silence feels like room to think and when it feels like no one is there.
The Thesis die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” In a class, the die gives each person a new angle on the same word, so the round is less likely to turn into a repeat of the debate.
The rule card puts it plainly: “Every view is welcome, especially one that differs from yours.” It also gives three follow-up questions that fit any word: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? For Loneliness, the second one does quiet work. Sometimes the answer is “nobody,” and sometimes it’s a room full of people.
For the next session
Pick one of the three views and send it to the group before the session, with question 1 and question 7 underneath. Ask each person to bring one case that the view can’t explain. At the start of the session, read the cases aloud before anyone defends the view.
The Thesis rules end with one last round: “each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” In a class on loneliness, that round puts the topic into practice: everyone is noticed by name at least once.
See the rules and the box, or open the free online table. For using the deck with a class or seminar, see Thesis for teams and classes. Word pages: Loneliness, Belonging, and Silence. For where the words came from, see the research behind the deck. Related: philosophical questions about freedom. Related: philosophical questions about death for a seminar or reading group.