You put freedom on the syllabus for next week. The first question goes out, a student says “freedom means doing what you want,” a few heads nod, and the discussion is over before it starts. Everyone agrees, so nobody has anything to defend.
This guide gives a seminar leader, a philosophy teacher, or a reading group host ten philosophical questions about freedom that split a room. Each question is tied to one position from the literature, so students argue with an idea before anyone talks about their own life. A short session plan and an optional card round follow.
The short answer
A question about freedom works in a seminar when it forces a choice between two definitions. “Is freedom important?” gets a yes. “Is a person free if nobody stops them, but someone could at any moment?” gets a split vote, and a split vote is where the talk starts.
Four positions do most of the work. Three come from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on positive and negative liberty, and one from the entry on free will. Either entry makes a good shared reading before the session.
Four positions to start from
Berlin: two kinds of liberty. Isaiah Berlin split freedom in two. Negative liberty is, in the encyclopedia’s words, “a mere absence of something (i.e. of obstacles, barriers, constraints or interference from others).” Positive liberty is about control and self-mastery: who or what decides that you do this rather than that. Berlin worried about the second kind. If a “higher” rational self counts as the true self, others can claim to free you by overriding what you want. The entry illustrates the divided self with a smoker torn between going to the tobacconist and keeping an appointment.
MacCallum: one concept with three parts. Gerald MacCallum argued that both camps share one idea. In his formula, “a subject, or agent, is free from certain constraints, or preventing conditions, to do or become certain things.” On this view, every claim about freedom has three blanks: who, free from what, free to do what. A seminar disagreement can turn out to be about different blanks.
Pettit: freedom as non-domination. Philip Pettit’s republican view says freedom is the absence of domination, which is more than the absence of interference. The encyclopedia’s example is a slave whose master never interferes. Nobody stops her from doing anything, and she’s still unfree, because the master’s arbitrary power over her is still there.
Frankfurt: free without alternatives. The free will debate asks whether being free requires that you could have done otherwise. Harry Frankfurt built a thought experiment against that. A neurosurgeon, Black, implants a device in Jones’s brain that would step in if Jones were about to choose differently. Jones decides on his own, and the device never acts. Supporters of the argument say Jones is responsible even though he couldn’t have chosen otherwise.
Ten philosophical questions about freedom
These questions follow the order of the positions above. Read one aloud, wait a moment, and ask the second speaker to respond to the first before adding a new point.
- If nobody stops you, are you free, even if you can’t afford to do the thing?
- Can a person be unfree because of their own habits?
- Who gets to say which of your desires is the “real” you?
- When two people disagree about freedom, which of the three blanks are they filling differently?
- Is a person free if nobody interferes with them, but someone could at any moment?
- Can a law make you more free?
- Was Jones free, if he couldn’t have chosen otherwise?
- Does it matter to you whether your choices were caused by something earlier?
- Is there a freedom you gave up on purpose, and were you less free afterward?
- Which freedom would you trade for something else, and for what?
Questions 1–8 can stay in the abstract the whole session. Questions 9 and 10 open a door to the personal, and the group can leave it closed.
What believing in free will does: a replication debate
Research on free will beliefs gives a seminar a second kind of argument: one about evidence. Kathleen Vohs and Jonathan Schooler ran two experiments in which people read passages arguing that behavior is determined. In the first, reading the deterministic text increased cheating on a math task. In the second, people who read deterministic statements overpaid themselves for a task (Vohs and Schooler 2008).
A later team tried to replicate those findings. Thomas Nadelhoffer and colleagues ran five studies, four of them preregistered, with samples from 162 to 982 people. In their words, “Our efforts were largely unsuccessful.” They concluded that changing free will beliefs in a robust way is harder than earlier work implied (Nadelhoffer et al. 2020). Both papers are read here from their abstracts.
The pair makes a good closing question for a class. What would it mean for a society if the first result had held? And what does it mean for the argument that it mostly didn’t?
A session plan
A seminar on freedom runs better with a clear shape. The abstract part comes first and the personal part is optional, so nobody is put on the spot.
- One position. Read one of the four positions aloud. Ask a student to restate it in their own words before anyone attacks it.
- The questions. Work through three or four of questions 1–8. Each answer responds to the one before it.
- A card round, optional. Move from the position to a word, for anyone who wants to tell a story.
- Closing. Each person names one point someone else made that changed their mind, even a little.
Before the session, agree together how passing works. For ways to ask a hard question without cornering anyone, see the post on asking sensitive questions.
Move from the position to a word
A single word lets students move from a definition to an experience at their own speed. Thesis is a deck of 50 double-sided cards: an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other. A word written on the board works too.
Freedom has a Compass on its other side. In a seminar, the idea side keeps the talk close to Berlin and Pettit. The Compass side is a way in for anyone who wants a story: a trip taken alone, a move to another city, a direction chosen without a map. It also fits MacCallum, since a compass asks the third blank: free to go where?
Duty has a Ticket on its other side. Duty pairs well with question 9. A duty can feel like the opposite of freedom, or like a freedom someone chose. The Ticket side brings up places a person had to be, and places they went because they wanted to. Independence, another card in the deck, fits question 2: it asks whether standing on your own is the same as being free.
The Thesis die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” For a class, rolling the die gives each student a new angle on the same word, so the round doesn’t repeat the debate.
The rule card puts it plainly: “Every view is welcome, especially one that differs from yours.” It also gives three follow-up questions that fit any word: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? The third one suits a seminar. It asks whether a person’s idea of freedom has changed, and when.
For the next session
Send one position and question 5 to the class before the session. Ask each student to fill in MacCallum’s three blanks for one freedom they care about: who, free from what, free to do what. Collect the answers at the door and read three of them aloud, without names, before anyone speaks.
The Thesis rules end with one last round: “each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” In a class, that round shows what students heard in each other, beyond what they read.
See the rules and the box, or open the free online table. For using the deck with a class or seminar, see Thesis for teams and classes. Word pages: Freedom, Duty, and Independence. For where the words came from, see the research behind the deck. For a seminar on a heavier theme, see philosophical questions about death.