Questions about forgiveness in recovery: a format for peer groups

You’ve signed up to chair, and the topic for the night is forgiveness. One member is still angry at a parent. Another is waiting to hear back from a sister he wronged. A third is newly sober and can’t look at herself yet. One open question, “What does forgiveness mean to you?”, lands on all three at once. This guide gives peer group chairs a one-meeting format: four rounds in a set order, ten questions about forgiveness in recovery, and a pass that stays open the whole time.

It’s written for chairs and convenors of peer support and recovery meetings. Thesis is a conversation format. It makes no clinical claims and isn’t affiliated with any fellowship or program. Your group’s traditions come first, and you decide if forgiveness fits your meeting. The format works with a word on an index card. Where a card helps, the examples use the Thesis deck.

Why the order of the questions matters

Forgiveness in recovery points in several directions: toward people who hurt you, from people you hurt, and toward yourself. These directions don’t feel equally hard. In a study of 157 people entering treatment for alcohol problems, Webb, Robinson, Brower and Zucker measured forgiveness of self, of others and by God. Scores for forgiving oneself were the lowest of the three (Webb et al. 2006). The authors suggest self-forgiveness may be the hardest to reach.

For a chair, that’s a reason to put self-forgiveness last and make it optional. A member who starts with the hardest direction may freeze or pass for the rest of the night. A member who starts with someone else’s story has already spoken once when the harder question comes.

A second study gives a reason to word the questions carefully. McGaffin, Lyons and Deane surveyed 133 people in residential treatment. Guilt went with more self-forgiveness, and shame went with less (McGaffin et al. 2013). Guilt is about something a person did. Shame is about who they think they are. So the questions below ask about acts, moments and people, and stay away from “What kind of person” wording.

Before the first turn: agree on passing

A forgiveness meeting needs a pass that everyone has heard out loud. The Thesis rules say: “Before you start, decide together how passing works.” Keep the agreement to one sentence, such as “You can pass on any round, or take the object side of the card, with no reason.”

Say two more things at the start. First, nobody in this room has to forgive anyone tonight, and “I don’t forgive” is a full answer. Second, the meeting is no place to share the details of someone else’s wrongdoing or to name a person who isn’t present. Then read the confidentiality line: “What is said at the table stays there.” Connect it to the agreement your group already uses.

Round 1: start with the door

The first round gives everyone a turn that asks for nothing personal. The Thesis card for this topic has Forgiveness on one side and Door on the other. Put it in the middle and ask each member to describe one door, any door.

Forgiveness
Door
Card 40: Forgiveness / Door. Tap to turn it over.

Forgiveness sits on the back of Door. In a recovery group the door side leaves the distance up to the member. One describes the door of a parent’s house that stayed locked. Another describes the meeting room door the first night. A third talks about a fridge door late at night and stops there. All three are full turns.

The rules give the length: “Say as much or as little as you like. The others ask, gently.” In this round, skip the follow-ups.

Rounds 2–4: ten questions in order

The ten questions run from the outside in. Write them on a sheet, or read out two or three per round and let members pick one. A member answers one question per round, or passes.

Round 2, forgiving others. These open with someone else’s act:

  1. What’s one thing someone did that you’ve stopped carrying?
  2. What happened to your anger at someone over time?
  3. Who did you forgive before you were ready, and what came of it?

Round 3, being forgiven. These turn toward the member’s own acts, without asking for details:

  1. When did someone forgive you before you asked?
  2. What did it feel like to wait for an answer from someone you hurt?
  3. Who are you not ready to ask yet?
  4. What would you want the other person to know, even if they never forgive you?

Round 4, forgiving yourself. These stay with moments and acts, and this round is the easiest to pass:

  1. What’s one thing you did while using that you’ve started to forgive?
  2. What would you say to someone new here who did the same thing?
  3. What changes on a day when you’re easier on yourself?

Between rounds, the rest of the group uses only the three follow-ups from the Thesis rule card: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? Leave out any question about whether the member has forgiven or been forgiven. If they want to say it, they will.

Honesty
Radio
Card 14: Honesty / Radio. Tap to turn it over.

Honesty is on the back of Radio. It suits round 3, when a member wants to talk about telling the truth to someone they hurt. The radio side gives a way around it: the radio in a car on a long drive, a song that was playing the night something happened. A member can pick either side and keep it short.

Failure
Washing machine
Card 37: Failure / Washing machine. Tap to turn it over.

Failure sits on the back of Washing machine. It fits round 4 for a member who has relapsed and is back in the room. A washing machine is an ordinary object with a cycle that repeats, and some members may talk about that. Others may talk about laundry piling up in a bad month. Either way, the turn is about an act and a time, which keeps it closer to guilt than to shame.

Close the meeting with the people in the room

A forgiveness meeting can leave members inside an old story with a person who isn’t there. The closing round brings attention back to the room. In it, each member names one thing they discovered about someone today. A member who passed every round can still take part, because they talk about what they heard.

End on time. If someone has said more than they meant to, a short word from the chair after the meeting can be easier to hear than a follow-up in front of the group. Remind everyone of the confidentiality line on the way out.

Try the format before the meeting

Run the four rounds once with a co-chair or a longtime member. Open the online table, pick Forgiveness, and take one turn each from the door side.

Roll the die

The die is optional in this format. It has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” A member who rolls a side they don’t want can pass on it like any other turn.

For a shorter opening to the same meeting, see check-in questions for recovery groups. The cards above have their own pages: Forgiveness, Honesty and Failure. You can play online for free, read about Thesis for therapy groups, see the rules and the box, or read the research behind the deck. Related: A forgiveness group activity for grief groups.

Before your next meeting, copy the ten questions onto one sheet in the order above, with round 4 at the bottom. Read the pass agreement aloud, then take the first turn on the door side yourself.