A forgiveness group activity for grief groups

A member says, almost in passing, that the last thing she told her father was that he’d ruined Christmas. He died in February. Another member is angry at his brother for refusing treatment, and can’t say so at home. Forgiveness sits under both stories, and the person it concerns is no longer there to answer. This guide gives grief group facilitators one forgiveness activity for a single session: how to frame it, three rounds, and a way to close.

It’s written for volunteer and peer facilitators of adult bereavement groups. Thesis is a conversation format and makes no clinical claims. You know your group and its limits, and you decide if and when forgiveness fits. The activity works with paper and a pen. Where a card helps, the examples use the Thesis deck.

Why forgiveness comes up after a death

A death can end a conversation halfway. Researchers call what’s left “unfinished business”: things unsaid, unresolved or unexpressed with the person who died. In a study by Klingspon, Holland, Neimeyer and Lichtenthal, 97 of 224 bereaved adults (43.3%) said they had some unfinished business with the deceased (Klingspon et al. 2015).

The same study sorted the written examples from 74 of those people into three groups. The largest, with 35 responses, was missed chances: a visit that didn’t happen, a plan that ran out of time. The next, with 24, was praise and love left unspoken. The third, with 15, was about forgiveness and things left undisclosed. Within it, 7 responses were about wanting to forgive the person who died, and 4 about wanting to apologize to them. The kind of unfinished business wasn’t linked to how much distress it caused. In that sample, more distress about it went with stronger grief symptoms.

A follow-up paper by Holland and colleagues tested a scale for this in two samples of 292 and 168 bereaved adults. It separated unfulfilled wishes from unresolved conflict. Unresolved conflict was linked to a higher risk of prolonged grief even at moderate levels (Holland et al. 2020). For a facilitator, that’s a reason to leave room for the hard version of the story, and for anger, too.

Before the session: name three directions

Forgiveness after a loss runs in more than one direction. Naming them at the start lets each member find their own without having to explain it. Write these three on a sheet and put it in the middle of the table:

  • Toward them. Something the person who died did, or didn’t do.
  • From them. Something you’d ask them to forgive, if you could.
  • Toward yourself. Something you did or missed around the illness, the death or the funeral.

Say plainly that forgiving is optional. A member may decide they don’t forgive, today or at all, and that’s a complete answer in this room. Say it once at the start and once before the writing round. A member who expects to be steered toward forgiving hears early that nobody will steer them.

Read the rule card’s line on confidentiality aloud here: “What is said at the table stays at the table.” Connect it to the agreement your group already uses.

Round 1: a door, before the word

Open with the object side. The Thesis card for this word has Forgiveness on one side and Door on the other, so the first round starts with the door. Each member who wants to describes one door from their life with the person they lost. It can be a front door, a hospital door, a car door, a door they knocked on or didn’t.

Forgiveness
Door
Card 40: Forgiveness / Door. Tap to turn it over.

Forgiveness sits on the back of Door. In a grief group, the door side can lead to the same story by a softer route. One member may describe the door he closed too hard after their last argument. Another may describe her mother’s kitchen door, always open. A third may hold the card and pass. All three are full turns, and none needs a follow-up.

Before anyone speaks, agree how passing works. The rule card opens with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” Keep it to one sentence, such as “You can pass, or take the door side, with no reason.”

Round 2: one sentence nobody reads

Writing lets a member say the thing without saying it to the room. Hand out paper and give a few quiet minutes. Each person writes one sentence to the person who died, in any of the three directions. Then they choose: read it aloud, say what it’s about in a few words, or fold it and keep it. Nobody collects the pages.

These prompts can sit on the table for anyone who wants a starting point:

  1. What would you say to them if the door opened now?
  2. What did they do that you’re still angry about?
  3. What do you wish you’d said at the last visit?
  4. What would you want them to forgive?
  5. Who else in the family is part of this story?
  6. What did they never apologize for?
  7. What have you already forgiven, without noticing when?
  8. What would forgiving them change, and what would it leave the same?
  9. What are you still holding against yourself?
  10. Which part of this would you leave unforgiven?

Folding the page is a full turn. The folded sentence has still been written, and the member decides what happens to it later.

Round 3: a word next to forgiveness

Some members may not want to start from forgiveness itself. A neighboring word gives them another way into the same story. Put two more cards on the table next to Forgiveness and let each member pick the one that fits today.

Regret
Lamp
Card 09: Regret / Lamp. Tap to turn it over.

Regret is on the back of Lamp. It suits the “toward yourself” direction: the call not made, the decision about care. The lamp side can be literal: a bedside lamp left on, a lamp in a parent’s window. A member can talk about either side and stop after two sentences.

Anger
Ring
Card 22: Anger / Ring. Tap to turn it over.

Anger sits on the back of Ring. It gives anger a place before forgiveness is discussed at all, including anger at the person who died. A ring can also carry the story of a marriage, an inheritance or a promise.

The others ask follow-ups only if the speaker seems open to them. Keep them to the rule card’s three: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? Avoid asking whether the person has forgiven. The speaker brings that up or doesn’t.

The die is optional in this round. It has six plain words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” A member who rolls a side they don’t want can pass on it.

Close the session with the people in the room

A forgiveness session can leave people inside an old argument. The closing round brings them back to the room. Thesis ends with one: “each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today.” A member who passed every turn can still take part. They talk about what they heard.

Give the folded pages a plan before people leave. A member might keep theirs in a wallet, burn it, bury it, or tuck it into a book that belonged to the person. Say that any of these, or nothing, is fine. Then end on time.

Try it before the session

Run the three rounds once with a co-facilitator before you bring them to the group. Open the online table, pick Forgiveness, and take one turn each from the door side.

Roll the die

For the wider setup of a group, see how to run a grief support group. The cards in this post have their own pages: Forgiveness, Regret and Anger. You can play online for free, read about Thesis for therapy groups, see the rules and the box, or read the research behind the deck. Related: A boundaries activity for group therapy: one session, one word. Related: questions about forgiveness in recovery: a format for peer groups.

Before your next session, write the three directions on one sheet of paper. Put it in the middle of the table and read it aloud before the first turn.