What comes after small talk with new friends

You met at a climbing gym, a language class or a friend’s birthday. A few weeks later you’ve had coffee a few times. You know where they work, where they grew up and what they think of the neighborhood. At the next coffee, there’s a pause, and both of you reach for your phones.

What comes after small talk is three kinds of talk: catching up on each other’s lives, playing, and one serious thread. A study of new friendships linked all three to growing closer. This post shows what each one sounds like over coffee, and how one word on the table can start the serious one.

Why the easy questions run out

Small talk trades facts. Job, city, siblings, the weather, the last film you saw. Each question has an answer, and once you have it, the question is closed. After a few meetups, the list is used up on both sides.

The pause that follows feels like a verdict on the friendship. It’s a sign the first stage is done. The facts are in, and there’s room for something else.

What the research says comes next

Jeffrey Hall followed 112 first-year students through their first nine weeks at university, and surveyed 355 adults who had recently moved to a new city (Hall 2018). Hours spent together went with growing closer. The students’ talk mattered too: friends who caught up on each other’s lives, talked playfully and had serious conversations grew closer. Student friends whose talk stayed on current events, pets, sports, movies and music tended to drift apart (Greater Good summary). Time spent talking, counted on its own, didn’t predict closeness.

So the kind of talk carries the weight. Small talk about the news went with drifting apart. Talk about your own lives does, and so does play.

Three kinds of talk to try

Each of the three has its own way in. You don’t need all three at every meetup.

Catching up. Ask about something they told you last time. “How did the apartment viewing go?” tells them you remembered, and it pulls the talk toward their week instead of the world’s. Small updates count: a bad night’s sleep, a call with their sister, a plant that died.

Playing. Shared jokes, teasing, a silly game, a ranking argument about the best bakery on the street. Play gives new friends a history of their own. The second time you mention the bakery, it’s an inside joke.

One serious thread. One question about values, a memory or a choice, picked up for a while and put down again. It doesn’t need to be heavy. “What made you move here?” is a serious question if the answer goes past the job offer.

Why the obvious advice gets skipped

“Go deeper” is the standard tip, and it’s hard to follow with someone you’ve met a handful of times. A sudden deep question can feel like an interview. The other person doesn’t know what kind of answer you want, and you don’t know how far they’ll go.

A structure helps here. In a lab study, pairs worked through self-disclosure tasks that got more personal over 45 minutes. They felt closer afterward than pairs who did comparable small-talk tasks (Aron et al. 1997). The tasks got personal a step at a time, and both people did each one. That’s the part to copy: take turns, and let it get personal a little at a time.

One word as the way in

A word on the table gives you the serious thread without the interview feel. You both answer the same word. Nobody has to invent a question, and each of you decides how far to take it.

With the Thesis deck, each card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other. The thing side is the light way in. Someone who’d rather not talk about Home can talk about a spoon from their grandmother’s kitchen. The die adds an angle, from six plain words: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. “Look at the word from that side.”

No deck at the table? Write a word on a napkin, or open the free online table on one phone between you.

Roll the die

Agree on passing first. The rules open with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” With a new friend, that line tells them up front that they can say no.

Questions for the next coffee

These work for new friends who’ve done the basics. They’re sorted from light to deeper, so you can stop at any point:

  1. What did you do last weekend that you’d do again?
  2. What’s the best thing you’ve found in this city so far?
  3. Which bakery, bar or park would you defend in an argument?
  4. What did you think this place would be like before you moved here?
  5. Who was the first friend you made here, and how?
  6. What’s something you do now that you didn’t do five years ago?
  7. What made you choose this city over the others?
  8. Where do you feel at home here?

When they answer, follow up instead of moving to the next number. The rule card gives three: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? For more on follow-ups, see follow-up questions.

Three cards for new friends

Each of these words fits a friendship that’s a few weeks old.

Play
Laptop
Card 50: Play / Laptop. Tap to turn it over.

Play has Laptop on its other side. It covers the playing part of the three. The idea side brings up childhood games and what each of you does for fun now. The laptop side is easy for new friends: the game you lost a weekend to, the video you’ve watched again and again.

Home
Spoon
Card 49: Home / Spoon. Tap to turn it over.

Home has Spoon on its other side. It fits new friends in a new city, because “home” can mean two places. The spoon side is the light version: a family kitchen, a dish someone always made, the first thing you cooked in your apartment here.

Curiosity
Sewing machine
Card 19: Curiosity / Sewing machine. Tap to turn it over.

Curiosity has Sewing machine on its other side. It turns the talk to what each of you wants to learn, which is a catch-up topic that lasts. The sewing machine side goes to grandparents, school projects and things people made by hand.

Next meetup, bring one thing

Next time, ask about one thing from last time, make one joke that’s yours, and put one word on the table. A short answer is fine. The rule card puts it plainly: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”

The cards above have their own pages: Play, Home and Curiosity. For a group of new friends, see Thesis for friends. For the studies behind the deck, see the research. See the rules and the box, or start on the online table. For light topics that still mean something, see meaningful topics to talk about. See also how to make friends in your 40s.