What does loyalty mean to you? To people, places and yourself

A friend from school calls after years of silence and asks for a favor. You say yes before you’ve thought about it. Later you wonder why. You haven’t been close for years, and still the yes came first. That reflex is one answer to the question of what loyalty means to you.

This guide helps you find the rest of the answer. Loyalty points in three directions: to people, to places and to yourself. Each one has its own stories, and they don’t always agree. Below are ten questions, one study on what happens when loyalty pulls against fairness, and a way to talk it through with one word on a card or a scrap of paper.

The short answer

Loyalty is a promise you keep without being asked to keep it. It shows in what you do when leaving would be easier: the friend you still call, the city you still defend, the value you still hold when it costs you something.

Your version of it comes from your history. A family that stuck together through a hard year teaches one kind. A family where loyalty meant keeping quiet teaches another. You can find your own definition by telling the stories behind it, then checking which of those rules you still agree with.

Loyalty to people

Loyalty to people can start with a few of them. A parent, a sibling, a best friend at 12. The rules come early and without words: you take their side in public, you keep their secrets, you show up when they move apartments.

Those rules get tested when loyalty meets another value. Adam Waytz, James Dungan and Liane Young ran five studies on what decides whether people report a wrong, whether it’s done by a stranger or by someone close. In their view, reporting serves fairness and can look disloyal at the same time. People who valued fairness over loyalty were more willing to report. Participants asked to write short essays on why justice matters more than loyalty became more willing to report a friend or family member than those who wrote about loyalty. When people recalled a real time they chose not to report someone, they described that choice as driven more by loyalty than by fairness (Waytz et al. 2013).

The study doesn’t say which choice is right. It shows that loyalty is one value among several, and the one that wins depends on which you’ve been thinking about. It helps to know your own order before the call comes.

Loyalty to places

Loyalty to a place is quieter. It sounds like defending your hometown to people who’ve never been there, or buying the same bread from the same bakery for years. It can attach to a country, a neighborhood, a team, a company, or a kitchen table.

It gets louder when you leave. You move abroad and find yourself defending a home you were glad to leave. Then the new city starts to feel like yours, and you feel a small guilt about it. Both feelings can be loyal at once. One is to the place that made you, the other to the place where you live now. For more on that split, see home after moving abroad.

Loyalty to yourself

The third direction is the hardest to name: what does it mean to be loyal to yourself? Here it means keeping the promises you made to your own values when other loyalties ask you to drop them. Saying no to a favor that would break something you care about. Leaving a job that asks you to stay quiet about something you’d report. Keeping a habit no one else sees.

Loyalty to yourself and loyalty to others can pull apart in small moments. A friend asks you to cover for them. A parent expects you to take over the family business. A team asks you to defend a decision you argued against. Each time, you choose which loyalty goes first, and the choice says more about your definition than any sentence would.

Ten questions to find your answer

These questions work with a pen, or with a friend asking them. Answer with a story where you can: a place, a year, a person.

  1. Who taught you what loyalty was, and how did they show it?
  2. When did someone stay loyal to you when leaving would have been easier?
  3. Who are you still loyal to, even though you rarely see them?
  4. When did loyalty to one person cost you something with another?
  5. Which place do you defend when someone criticizes it?
  6. What do you still do the way your family did it?
  7. When did you keep quiet out of loyalty, and how do you feel about it now?
  8. Which promise to yourself have you kept for the longest time?
  9. When did you choose yourself over someone you were loyal to?
  10. Has loyalty always meant the same thing to you?

Look for names and places that come up more than once. A person who appears in several answers is part of your definition.

One word from six sides

A second way in is to stay with the word and change the angle. The Thesis die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.”

Roll it, or pick a face, and say what Loyalty brings up from there. Then roll again.

Loyalty
Camera
Card 48: Loyalty / Camera. Tap to turn it over.

Loyalty has a Camera on its other side. Choose the idea when you want to talk about the people, places and values you stand by. Choose the Camera when a story is easier: the person who took the family photos, the album someone kept all these years, the friend who’s in every picture from your twenties. The people we photograph again and again may be the ones we’re loyal to.

Try it with someone

Loyalty is easier to talk about with someone who’s part of the story. An old friend, a sibling, or a partner will remember the moments you’ve forgotten. Two or three people at a table is enough.

Roll the die

Before you start, agree how passing works. The Thesis rules open with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” Then take turns:

  1. Draw a card. Choose a side: the idea or the thing.
  2. Roll the die.
  3. Look at the word from that side. Say as much or as little as feels right.
  4. The others ask what they’re curious about, gently, without judging.
  5. Hand the die to the left.

The rule card gives three follow-up questions: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? For Loyalty, the second one can do the most. Loyalty is about other people, and naming who was there shows who the loyalty was to.

“What is said at the table stays at the table.” For a word about keeping faith with people, this rule matters. Agree on it before the first card.

Two words close to Loyalty

Loyalty sits next to other words in the deck. Two of them open the parts of loyalty that feel heavier or harder to name.

Duty
Ticket
Card 36: Duty / Ticket. Tap to turn it over.

Duty has a Ticket on its other side. Duty is loyalty that someone else expects of you: the visit you make because it’s owed, the role you took because you were the eldest. Talking about Duty next to Loyalty shows which of your commitments you chose and which were handed to you. The Ticket side brings up trips taken for someone else: a flight home for a birthday, a train to a funeral.

Home
Spoon
Card 49: Home / Spoon. Tap to turn it over.

Home has a Spoon on its other side. Home is where loyalty to a place is most personal. Players may answer with a city, an apartment, a person, or a smell from a kitchen. The Spoon side brings up the meals and habits you carried from one home to the next, which can be where loyalty to a place lives.

What to do tonight

Write the word Loyalty on a piece of paper. Pick one direction: a person, a place, or yourself. Tell one story about it to someone you trust, and let them ask one follow-up. “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”

When you’re done, end the way every game of Thesis ends: each player names one thing they discovered about someone at the table today. “Sometimes one word is enough.”

See the rules and the box, or open the free online table. The cards above have their own pages: Loyalty, Duty and Home. For playing with old friends, see Thesis for friends. For more on the research behind the deck, see the research page. Related: deep questions about trust: friends, places, institutions and yourself. Related: what does beauty mean to you beyond appearance?.