A talking piece is an object that moves around a circle to show whose turn it is. The person holding it speaks. Everyone else listens. When it reaches you, you can talk, pass, or hold it in silence for a moment, and then it moves on. This guide is for anyone who runs a circle, a support group, a class or a workshop and wants to know how the object works, how to choose one, and what to do when the round stalls.
The examples use the Thesis card deck, because each card has an everyday thing on one side. A mug from the kitchen works the same way.
What a talking piece does
Loyola Marymount University’s restorative justice center describes it as an object of meaning for the group, “e.g., a stone, plant, a stuffed toy,” passed from person to person to show who holds the space (LMU Center for Restorative Justice). The same page lists three things a person can do when it reaches them: share, pass, or hold a time of silence.
The object does three jobs at once. It sets the order, so nobody has to decide who goes next. It protects the speaker, because interrupting someone who holds the piece breaks a rule everyone can see. And it gives listeners a task: watch the object, wait for it.
UC Berkeley’s Greater Good in Education puts the round in one line. Use a talking piece “passed sequentially around the Circle, giving each person the choice to speak or pass when the talking piece comes to them” (Greater Good in Education). The pass is part of the definition from the start.
Where the practice comes from
The University of Pennsylvania’s guide to restorative circles describes them as “informed by sacred and secular practices of numerous Indigenous Peoples in North America,” and names the talking piece as one of a circle’s essential elements (Penn Restorative Circles).
That history is worth one sentence when you introduce the object to a new group. If your circle borrows a specific ceremony or a named object from one tradition, learn it from people who hold that tradition. An ordinary object from your own room keeps the turn-taking and leaves the ceremony where it belongs.
The rules of the round
A round with a talking piece follows four rules. Say them out loud before the object moves for the first time:
- Only the person holding the piece speaks.
- Everyone else listens and waits for the piece to reach them.
- The holder can speak, pass, or hold the piece in silence.
- When the holder is done, the piece goes to the next person in the circle.
Greater Good in Education adds one line about the round: “Honoring the talking piece means active listening to each person and respecting the right to pass.” The same guide asks the keeper to answer first and then hand the piece left or right. Your first turn can set the length and tone for the turns after it.
How to choose a talking piece
A good talking piece is easy to hold, quiet when it moves, and plain enough that nobody worries about dropping it. It helps when the object has a small story, because the story can open the first round. These everyday objects work well:
- A stone. Fits in one hand, survives being dropped, and gets warm as it travels.
- A mug. Easy to find in a staff room or kitchen. Empty it first.
- A key. Small, and someone in the room may have one in a pocket.
- A spoon. Light and ordinary, which makes it easy to pass on.
- A book. Heavier, so the turn feels deliberate.
- A pair of headphones. Soft, light, and familiar to younger groups.
Pick one and keep it. Greater Good in Education notes that “Consistency is important,” and asks keepers to be patient as people “learn to honor the rhythm of the talking piece.” The same object at every session becomes a signal on its own. When it comes out of the bag, the room knows how the round will go.
When the round gets stuck
Three snags are worth planning for. Each has a small fix.
Someone holds it too long. Agree on a rough length before the first round, such as “a few sentences each.” The keeper can model it in the first turn. A shorter first answer from the keeper gives everyone permission to stop early.
Someone talks without it. Point at the object, smile, and wait. The object does the reminding, so the keeper doesn’t have to correct a person by name.
Someone freezes. Holding the piece in silence is one of the three options. Say so when you explain the rules, and say it again the first time it happens: “You can hold it for a moment or pass it on.” Then wait.
The object as the first prompt
A talking piece can also be what the group talks about. Before the first real question, send the object around once and ask each person to say one thing it reminds them of. The answers are short, nobody has to share anything private, and everyone has spoken once before the harder question arrives.
These questions work for that first round, with the talking piece or any object on the table:
- Where have you seen one like this before?
- Who in your life would use this every day?
- What’s the oldest one you’ve owned?
- What would you put in it, or on it?
- Where in your home does this live?
- What sound does it make?
- When did you last hold one without thinking about it?
- What would you replace it with if it broke?
An object gives people something concrete to start from. For more on objects and the people they bring to mind, see objects that remind you of a loved one.
Using a card’s object side as the talking piece
Each Thesis card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other. Rule 2 on the rule card reads: “Draw a card. Choose a side: the idea or the thing.” The thing side can serve as the round’s talking piece. Lay the card in the middle, name the object, and pass a real one if it’s in the room.
Work sits on the back of Stone. A stone is the first example on LMU’s list of talking pieces, so the card fits a group’s first session. A player can talk about a stone they kept from a trip, or turn the card and talk about work. Both are full turns.
Home is on the back of Spoon. A spoon is easy to find in any room with a kitchen, and it opens small, safe stories: who cooked, which drawer it lived in. The idea side goes further for people who want it. The spoon side stays open for people who don’t.
Belonging is on the back of Headphones. In a group of students or young adults, headphones are an object everyone in the room can picture. Passing them around makes the listening rule visible: while you hold them, you speak, and while others hold them, you listen.
Try it at your next session
The online table lets a group run a round with a card on a shared screen. Choose the thing side, name the object, and pass the turn around the circle.
The die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” A short turn still counts. The rule card says it plainly: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”
You know your group, its purpose and its limits, and you decide how a game format fits into it. Thesis is a conversation format. What is said at the table follows the rule card: “What is said at the table stays at the table.”
Before your next circle, pick one object from your own desk or kitchen. Say the four rules, answer first yourself, and hand it to your left.
For running the game with a group, see Thesis for therapy groups. The three cards above have their own pages: Work, Home and Belonging. You can play online for free, see the rules and the box, or read the research behind the deck. Related: low pressure conversation starters: start with the object, then the word.