You read a few questions from a list of deep questions aloud at dinner, and the table went flat. Some felt like a quiz. Some sounded like the one before.
A question is deep when the honest answer reveals something personal: a thought, a feeling, or an experience. That’s how a team of researchers who study deep talk define it. This post shows the 20 questions they rated, what the top ones have in common, and how to write a deep question yourself, with or without a card deck.
The short answer
Michael Kardas, Amit Kumar and Nicholas Epley define deep conversations as “those in which two people engage in self-disclosure by revealing personally intimate information about their thoughts, feelings, or experiences” (Kardas et al. 2021). Depth lives in the answer. A question is deep when it asks for that kind of answer and leaves room for it.
In the list of questions their study used, the deep ones point at four things: what a person values, a specific memory, other people, and the future. The shallow ones point at routines, plans and small events.
Twenty questions, rated
The researchers pretested 20 questions and scored each one for intimacy. Ten were labeled shallow and ten deep. The full list is in the paper’s appendix. A few points along the scale show how it moves:
- “What do you think about the weather today?” scored 1.21, the lowest.
- A three-part question about haircuts, ending with a bad haircut you once had, scored 2.39.
- “What’s your daily routine like?” scored 4.40, the highest of the shallow ten.
- A question about what your ideal day would look like scored 4.75, the lowest of the deep ten.
- “For what in your life do you feel most grateful?” scored 6.47.
- “Can you describe a time you cried in front of another person?” scored 7.39.
- “If you could undo one mistake you have made in your life, what would it be and why would you undo it?” scored 7.82, the highest.
The gap between the daily routine and the ideal day is small. Both ask about a day. One asks what you do; the other asks what you’d want. In this list, that one shift, from habit to wish, is where the line between shallow and deep falls.
What the deep questions share
Read the ten deep questions side by side and four patterns repeat. Each one is a way to turn a flat question into a deeper one.
A value. “Most grateful” and the ideal day ask what matters to you. There’s no correct answer, so the answer has to come from you.
A specific memory. “A time you cried,” “one of your most meaningful memories” and “one of the more embarrassing moments” ask for one scene. A scene has a place, a year and a feeling in it. A habit has none.
Another person. Two of the deep questions name someone else: crying in front of another person, and what a new close friend should know about you. People in a story bring feelings with them.
The future. “If a crystal ball could tell you the truth about yourself” and “something you’ve dreamed of doing for a long time” ask about hopes and fears. The dream question goes on: “Why haven’t you done it?” That second half asks for the reason.
One smaller feature shows up too. Three of the ten deep questions end by asking why. Of the shallow ten, one does.
Why a list of deep questions still falls flat
The haircut question is the useful one here. It starts with how often and where, then asks about one bad haircut. That last part asks for a story. Depth can arrive in the follow-up, after someone has answered and the asker wants to know more. A printed list can’t do that part.
Lists also run out of angles. When ten questions in a row ask for a memory, the tenth sounds like the first. Mixing the four patterns keeps one topic sounding new.
There’s also a gap between asking and answering. In a pilot with 188 online participants, people picked five questions from the same list of 20 for an imagined talk with a stranger. Those who imagined only listening picked questions with an average intimacy of 5.06. Those who imagined only answering picked 3.58 (Kardas et al. 2021). In that pilot, people chose deeper questions to hear answered than to answer themselves. A list that only one person reads aloud puts all the weight on the person answering.
Deep and heavy are two different things
Depth measures how much an answer reveals. A happy memory can reveal as much as a sad one. The study shows why the difference matters.
In one experiment, 178 master’s students talked with a stranger using either shallow or deep questions. The deep talks did feel more awkward than the shallow ones. But before talking, people expected a difference about four times larger than the one they felt. Afterward, the deep group also reported feeling lonelier than the shallow group. The authors point to two of their deep questions, the embarrassing moment and the time you cried, which likely brought to mind memories of negative social experiences. In later experiments they measured happiness instead (Kardas et al. 2021).
So a good deep question doesn’t have to hurt. “What is one of your most meaningful memories? Why is it meaningful for you?” scored 7.29, close to the top, and it lets the person pick a happy one. More on the awkwardness finding is in why deep conversations feel awkward.
Ten deep questions built from the four patterns
These questions use the patterns above. Each asks for one value, one scene, one person or one future, and most leave the choice of a light or heavy answer to the person answering.
- What’s something you own that you’d save first, and why that one?
- When did you last change your mind about something important?
- Which meal from your childhood could you still describe in detail?
- Who taught you something they don’t know they taught you?
- What’s a compliment you still remember, and who said it?
- Which place feels most like home to you right now?
- What would you like to be better at in ten years?
- What’s a small thing you do that your parents also did?
- Who would you call first with good news, and why them?
- What did you want to become at 12, and what’s left of it?
The rule card in Thesis gives three follow-ups that fit almost any answer: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you?
One word, looked at from six sides
A single word can do the work of a question list. Write a word like Home on a napkin and ask someone what it brings up from one angle, then another. The word stays the same, so the conversation doesn’t repeat; the angle changes, so the answers do.
The Thesis die has six faces: MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” You can try the angles alone with the die roller, or deal a word on the free online table.
Each card has an idea on one side and an everyday thing on the other.
Nostalgia has a Key on its other side. The idea side invites a memory straight away. The Key is quieter: the key to a first apartment, a grandparent’s house, a locker. A key belongs to a door, and a door belongs to a time in someone’s life, so the story arrives without anyone asking for it.
Hope has a Teddy bear on its other side. Hope pulls toward the future. The Teddy bear lets a player start in the past, with a toy and who gave it, and the hopes from that time come up on their own.
Try it tonight
Pick one shallow question you’d normally ask, like “How was your weekend?” Add one of the four patterns: “What was the best part, and who was there?” Then ask one follow-up and wait for the answer. “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.”
If you’d rather start from a word, see the rules and the box, or play on the free online table. The cards above have their own pages, Nostalgia and Hope, and so does Family. For playing with a few close people, see Thesis for friends. The research behind the deck lists the studies the deck draws on. For the steps of a full conversation, see how to have deep conversations. Related: the space between small talk and deep conversation. Related: deep questions about nostalgia and the memories you share.