In a one-on-one, someone on your team says the sprint was “fine, a bit messy.” You write “fine” in your notes and move to the next item. Later the meeting ends on time, and you still don’t know what was messy. One question about that word would have told you.
This guide is for managers who run one-on-ones, skip-levels or team meetings. It covers what research links to follow-up questions, why managers skip them, how to ask one that doesn’t sound like an audit, and ten questions to keep in your notes.
The short answer
A follow-up question takes something the other person said a moment ago and asks for more of it. “What was messy about it?” is a follow-up. “Anything else on your list?” moves on. The first shows you heard the last sentence and gives the turn back to the speaker.
In conversation studies, people who asked more follow-up questions were liked more by the people they talked to.
What the research found
Karen Huang and colleagues studied question-asking in live conversations between two people. Across three studies, people who asked more questions, “particularly follow-up questions,” were better liked by their partners (Huang et al. 2017). Asking more questions made partners see the asker as more responsive, and that perceived responsiveness explained the effect on liking. The askers themselves didn’t expect questions to make them more liked.
Those studies used strangers and speed dates, not managers and their reports. Research on listening at work points in a similar direction. In a survey of 238 employees from several organizations, Avraham Kluger and Keren Zaidel found that how much a leader listened to the employee as a person correlated strongly with how considerate the leader seemed (r = .71). Destructive listening correlated with inconsiderate leadership (r = .67) (Kluger and Zaidel 2013). It was a survey, so it shows a link and not a cause.
A later review by Kluger and Guy Itzchakov describes listening as linked to, and likely a cause of, outcomes such as job performance, leadership, trust and well-being. They describe listening as something that happens between two people, including supervisors and their reports, and that benefits both of them (Kluger and Itzchakov 2021). A follow-up question is a listening behavior the other person can hear.
Why managers skip the follow-up
Managers skip the follow-up for ordinary reasons, and several come from the job itself.
- The agenda is long. Every follow-up takes time, and the list of status items is waiting.
- A manager’s question can sound like a check. “Why was it messy?” from a peer is curiosity. From the person who writes your review, it can sound like a hunt for whose fault it was.
- The fix is already loading. Managers are asked to solve things, so the reply to a problem turns into advice before the problem is clear.
- The meeting has a script. On employee forums, people describe one-on-ones that feel performative, and some say their managers were never shown how to run one. A script with fixed questions leaves no room for the next one.
Each of these has a small fix. Put fewer items on the agenda. Ask about the situation instead of the person. Hold the advice until the second answer. Leave one slot in the script that you can’t fill in advance.
How to ask a follow-up that doesn’t feel like an audit
A follow-up from a manager lands well when it’s short, clearly curious and easy to decline. The habits below help with that.
Use their word. If someone says the week was “a bit messy,” ask about “messy.” Repeating their word shows you heard it, and it lets them define it. A new word from you, like “problem,” can change what they think you’re asking.
Ask about the work, then the person. “What made that part slow?” is easier to answer than “Why were you slow?” The answer to the first one can include the second anyway.
Ask one, then wait. Leave a pause after the answer. The pause can give the person room to add the part they held back.
Let a short answer stand. The Thesis rule card says it in one line: “A short answer is a full answer. You can always ask for more.” In a one-on-one, a short answer can mean the topic isn’t safe yet, or that it’s done. Note it and come back in a later meeting.
Write down what they said. Notes in the other person’s words make the next follow-up easy. “Last time you said the handoff was messy. How did it go this week?” shows that someone kept listening after the meeting ended.
Ten follow-up questions managers can use
Each question below picks up something from the last answer, so it works in a one-on-one, a skip-level or a team meeting. Swap in the person’s own words where the brackets are.
- What was [messy] about it?
- Which part took the longest?
- What did you try first?
- Who else was involved?
- What would have made that easier?
- Is that new, or has it been like that for a while?
- What did you expect to happen?
- What part of it are you still thinking about?
- What would you do differently next time?
- What do you need from me on that, if anything?
The rule card for Thesis gives three more that fit any answer: What did that feel like? Who else was there? Has it always meant that to you? The last one fits a skip-level, where the talk can turn to how a team or process changed. In a team meeting, one follow-up after a check-in answer shows the room that the round is heard. For openers that give you something to follow up on, see check-in questions for team meetings.
Practice with a word
Follow-ups are easier to practice when a word sets the topic. One person talks about the word for a while, and the others each ask one follow-up. It works at a team offsite or at the start of a one-on-one.
Balance has a Watch on its other side. At work, Balance can be read as workload, a week with no meetings, or a trade between two projects. The Watch side is easier for someone who’d rather not talk about their hours: a watch from a parent, a time zone, a deadline that moved. Either answer gives a manager a detail to follow up on.
Success has a Notebook on its other side. Answers about Success can range from a shipped release to leaving on time, and Has it always meant that to you? can show what someone wants from the next year. The Notebook side brings up how people keep track of things.
Work has a Stone on its other side. The idea side gets stories about first jobs and how people learned to work. The Stone side is slower and more concrete: a stone kept on a desk, a path in a garden, something heavy someone carried.
The Thesis die adds an angle to each word. Its six faces are MEMORIES · BODY · PEOPLE · VALUES · CHILDHOOD · FUTURE. The only instruction is “Look at the word from that side.” In the rules, the follow-up is a step of the turn: “The others ask what they’re curious about, gently, without judging.”
Before you start, agree on how passing works. The rules open with “Before you start, agree together how passing works.” At work, a pass has to cost nothing, and the manager says that first.
Try it in your next one-on-one
Before the meeting, write one slot on the agenda that says “follow-up.” When the person gives an answer with a vague word in it, ask about that word and wait. After the meeting, write down what they said in their own words. Next week, start with it.
The words above have their own pages: Balance, Success and Work. For more on running it at work, see Thesis for teams and classes. For the studies behind the deck, see research. Open the free online table, or see the rules and the box. Related: follow-up questions: the small habit research links to being liked.